Cleopatra: Histories, Dreams and Distortions

Rating:
Summary: Marvelous Read
Review: I beg to differ with the previous reviewer. Hughes-Hallett's Cleopatra is a fascinating--and sociologically astute--work. Hughes-Hallett is looking at Cleopatra's image as it has been created and recreated through the ages. She begins with a review of Cleopatra's story through the eyes of her Roman enemies (specifically Octavius--later Caesar Augustus) and explains how Octavius' "propaganda machine" used certain images and concepts to discredit Cleopatra. Like all propaganda, the images tell us more about Octavius and the world he lived in than about Cleopatra.

Likewise, when, in the next chapter, Hughes-Hallett describes the images Cleopatra used to promote herself, we learn more about the religion and society surrounding Cleopatra than any specific biographical information.

The book moves on through history: Cleopatra in Shakespeare, for instance. It is not a biography, and Hughes-Hallett makes it quite clear that it is not meant to be a biography. What we know about Cleopatra is very little. Instead Hughes-Hallett's book explores what Cleopatra has meant to the different ages in which her myth and story have been told. Like many famous women throughout history, she has been both villified and romanticized.

I would rank Hughes-Hallett's book with Marina Warner's From the Beast to the Blond (although it is not as erudite) for its exploration of story and history and how the two mix together.

Rating:
Summary: Completely inaccurate.
Review: I've done extensive reasherch on The Life, as well as the comon veiws, of Cleopatra VII. Out of all of the books I have read, this has to be the worst. Do not let the sub-title "dreams and distortions" distract you. This book looks at Cleopatra as her enemies veiwed her, as a witch and a whore. I would not recomend this book for anyone who is truly interested in the life of the great Cleopatra VII. Don't waiste you time and money on this poor excuse for a biography. I would, though, like to recomend a historical novel, on Cleopatra by Margret George. Although it is technicly non fiction, it is extreemly historicly acurate as well as I great book to read.

~* Mikisha Anne ...

Rating:
Summary: A very informative read
Review: The author does an excellent job of laying out all the various portrayals of Cleopatra, both historical and literary, and relating them to women's status in society at the time.
The book is filled with clear examples of the author's points, and her theories are backed up with documentation.
Cleopatra comes across as a very human "character" whose actions can be interpretted in many ways, depending on who is telling the story.
Lucy Hughes Hallett gives the reader several "historical" Clepatras, ranging from a "Nile vamp" to a romantic heroine dying for love. The author stresses the point that various periods in history have used the Cleopatra legend for different purposes, everything from instilling national pride to selling shampoo.
The book in no way presents a one-sided version of the queen's story. If anything the reader is presented wth an array of contradictory elements and allowed to pick and choose the ones he wants to incorporate into his own version of Cleopatra.
I found the book well written, intelligent and thought provoking.