D-Day: The Greatest Invasion - A People's History

Rating:
Summary: D-Day: The Greatest Invasion - A People's History
Review: American soldiers and sailors were threatened with court-marshal for taking diaries or cameras ashore on Normandy D-Day. Most of Robert Capa's June 6, 1944 photos shot at 8:30 A.M. on the Easy Red/Fox Green sectors of Omaha Beach were accidentally destroyed during developing. Fortunately, D-Day combat artist Dwight Shepler, USNR, captured many great scenes of the U.S. Naval Beach Battalions and LCI sailors in France. Author Dan van der Vat's D-Day: The Greatest Invasion - A People's History is a well written overview of Operation Overlord and ingeniously combines Shepler's invasion art, never-before-published photos and most important, first person accounts of American, British, Canadian, Free French and Polish Allied participants. I never knew my father, a beach battalion medical officer, but I do know many D-Day veterans. The Greatest Invasion is quite a tribute to "those who were there," and will surely become a bestseller at the National D-Day Memorial Foundation in Bedford, VA and the "new" National WWII Museum in New Orleans, LA.

Rating:
Summary: D-Day: The Greatest Invasion - A People's History
Review: American soldiers and sailors were threatened with court-marshal for taking diaries or cameras ashore on Normandy D-Day. Most of Robert Capa's June 6, 1944 photos shot at 8:30 A.M. on the Easy Red/Fox Green sectors of Omaha Beach were accidentally destroyed during developing. Fortunately, D-Day combat artist Dwight Shepler, USNR, captured many great scenes of the U.S. Naval Beach Battalions and LCI sailors in France. Author Dan van der Vat's D-Day: The Greatest Invasion - A People's History is a well written overview of Operation Overlord and ingeniously combines Shepler's invasion art, never-before-published photos and most important, first person accounts of American, British, Canadian, Free French and Polish Allied participants. I never knew my father, a beach battalion medical officer, but I do know many D-Day veterans. The Greatest Invasion is quite a tribute to "those who were there," and will surely become a bestseller at the National D-Day Memorial Foundation in Bedford, VA and the "new" National WWII Museum in New Orleans, LA.

Rating:
Summary: "A fine tribute"
Review: I was surprised to read Jon Gawne's negative review of Dan van der Vat's D-Day book - especially in light of the dozens of moving letters we've received from D-Day veterans and associations praising Mr. van der Vat's even-handed and complete re-telling of this epic story:

"On behalf of all of us, and especially those who gave their lives in Normandy, it is with great appreciation that we recognize and thank you for your excellent documentation of D-Day." - Bud Rice, veteran, 316th Troop Carrier Group

"The author and your staff have produced a fine tribute to those who were involved in this historic day." - National D-Day Memorial Foundation

"It is the finest accounting I have ever read of what took place sixty years ago." - Harvey A. Jacobs, veteran, U.S. 9th Air Force

"I have read it through and was pleased with the accuracy of the contents." - Donald Jakeway, veteran, 82nd Airborne Division

"Well written and superbly illustrated and produced. The coverage of Pegasus Bridge has been done well, with information compiled lucidly and accurately." - David Booth, Editor, Journal of the Glider Pilot Regimental Association

"Dan van der Vat has compiled a truly memorable volume to mark the upcoming 60th anniversary of D-Day. I hope to carry a volume with me when I visit Normandy in June." - Howard Clarkson, veteran crewmember, LCI-537

I'm sure Amazon customers will be heartened to know that D-DAY: THE GREATEST INVASION - A PEOPLE'S HISTORY is a far richer book than Jon Gawne imagines. Just ask the vets who were there...

Rating:
Summary: Terrific Book
Review: One can see where Mr. Gawne's vitriol comes from; he has published a minor work on uniforms and underwear called Spearheading D-Day, which was not consulted in the preparation of Mr. van der Vat's far more comprehensive book. The sour grapes in Mr. Gawne's review are apparent, not to mention the jealousy over the introduction by Mr. Eisenhower.

All that aside, this is indeed a very good overall view of a seminal event in 20th Century History. Good photos, crisp layout, and flowing prose mark this among the better anniversary projects.

For a comparison, check out Mr. Gawne's website at http://www.militaria.com and see if he should really be considered a historian or author judging the work of others in public.

Congratulations, Mr. Van der Vat, for a job well done.

Rating:
Summary: just fluff, nothing new, some errors
Review: Sorry, its a pretty book, but it seems to me a compilation of the popular stuff written on D-day. Nothing new, and some factual errors. To pick two: use of the 2nd Ranger Bn scroll, and the author's description of Operation Fortitude is incorrect.

There are better books out there on the subject. Why do publishers keep pumping this stuff out? Everyone HAS to get on the 60th annv of D-day bandwagon, and I guess they just hire the first person that has heard of WW2 to write them. But why not have it vetted by someone that actually knows the subject?

What's really sad is that Ike's son wrote the introduction, which will make most people think this is well researched important book. Its not.

It is a coffee table book where more work has gone into making it LOOK nice, than be a good history book. And even for that type fo book there are better ones available.

Rating:
Summary: A chronicle of men who gave everything they had
Review: The logistics of the allied invasion of Western Europe are incredible, even in retrospect. It involved hundreds of ships and planes, thousands of men and devices to kill men everywhere. The wonder is not that there was confusion, but that it went as well as it did. It is a tribute to the planners that it did succeed, for if it had not, it is nearly certain that Soviet Armies would have marched to the Rhine and perhaps even to the Normandy coast. The consequences of the Soviet armies dominating all of Europe after the war are enormous and communism could have emerged victorious in the cold war.
This book is a chronicle of the men who created the victory against extreme opposition. While some of the German units were not the highest caliber, all still put up a ferocious fight, and it was only the courage of the allied soldiers and their willing to shed their blood that made it happen. A combination of photos, pictures and text describe the invasion from the initial planning to the destruction of the German armies in the Falaise pocket. In many cases, before and after photos are paired to show how the region looked then and now.
Two days truly changed the course of World War II. The first is the day of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, which brought the United States into the war and which guaranteed that the allies would not be defeated. The second is D-Day, which meant that Soviet influence would end somewhere in the middle of Europe rather than at the western border. This is a story of one of the greatest days in American history, where the course of world history for five decades was decided. We all owe so much to the men who hit those beaches and this book is a history lesson that should never, ever be forgotten.

Rating:
Summary: Very Informative of The Politics
Review: While it may not be the most detailed book on D-Day, it was very informative about the politics side of the invasion on both sides of the battle. It is definately more informative about the Canadian troops that helped in the invasion. This is stated at the beginning of the book also. Overall though, it is one of the best books on D-Day I have read.