Home :: Books :: History  

Arts & Photography
Audio CDs
Audiocassettes
Biographies & Memoirs
Business & Investing
Children's Books
Christianity
Comics & Graphic Novels
Computers & Internet
Cooking, Food & Wine
Entertainment
Gay & Lesbian
Health, Mind & Body
History

Home & Garden
Horror
Literature & Fiction
Mystery & Thrillers
Nonfiction
Outdoors & Nature
Parenting & Families
Professional & Technical
Reference
Religion & Spirituality
Romance
Science
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Sports
Teens
Travel
Women's Fiction
Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era (Oxford History of the United States)

Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era (Oxford History of the United States)

List Price: $47.50
Your Price: $32.30
Product Info Reviews

<< 1 2 3 4 .. 13 >>

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Best Political History of the Civil War
Review: James McPherson's "Battle Cry of Freedom" is the best work on the politics of The Civil War available. For example, McPherson spends nearly the first three hundred pages of the book on the events, political and otherwise, leading up to the firing on Fort Sumter. As a result, his book gives the war a proper context that is lacking in many other works. His descriptions of the battles themselves tend to be brief overviews rather than extensive studies. But there are countless other volumes by other authors available for those whose interest primarily lies with the shooting war itself. McPherson would rather focus on why the North ans South decided to fight it out and once they did, how the war evolved slowly from an attempt to put down an insurrection to a holy quest to end slavery.

No other period in American History has seen as many political changes of earthquake proportions as The Civil War. This fact often gets lost in the tales of epic battles, almost mythical generals and incredible sacrifice. What McPherson has done is place the great painting of the war in a proper frame to give one the whole picture. As such, it is vital reaading for anyone interested in the War and its effect on American History.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: A great comprehensive history of the entire Civil War
Review: If you are looking for a comprehensive single volume book on the Civil War (and pre and post Civil War) history this is simply a great book for you. The first 300 or so pages deal with the conditions in the United States prior to the war- focusing mainly on the 1850's- and give a great synopsis of the mind set of the everyday people, politicians, business leaders, etc. North and South which lead to the war itself. The middle of the book deals with the war and it's battles, it's military leaders, as well as the politicians, and how the profound impact it had on the population in the North and South.

I still have a couple hundred pages left to read so I can't comment on the final chapters but the entire book has been so incredibly educational, enlightening, and enjoyable to read I can't expect I'll be let down. Truly a great book and you finish with a great well-rounded education on the America's most turbulent period.

Some seem to have been let down by the focus on slavery and their perception that McPherson implies the war was caused and fought to free the slaves. I didn't see it this way at all. Slavery was a major issue for the war so of course McPherson is going to have a significant amount of pages dedicated to it. But, it is not as simple as the Union thought slavery was wrong and fought for it's end and the South resisted. McPherson describes more how slavery issue was an example of the South believing the Federal government was governing like a King and associated it's own behavior with that of the 1776 revolutionists who fought against the King. So don't let that stop you from reading book. I felt it gave the slavery issue its just importance.

Also, if you are looking only for an in-depth description of the military battles this is not the book. It definitely gives the chronology, logistics, impact and details of the battles but it isn't solely focused on the fighting. It is an overall history of the politics, economy, foreign relations, military, and people of the Civil War.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Terrific One-Volume History
Review: I'm just a neophyte when it comes to Civil War history, but after moving to Maryland I thought it was about time I started getting better acquainted with it. Like many Americans, I was enthralled by the PBS Civil War series of some years back. Prior to that, I had exposure to the history of the period in a college class or two. Back then, the revisionist view of the War held that the hostilities stemmed predominantly from economic causes. McPherson's tome, which manages, adeptly, to be both readable and scholarly, reveals how complex this War and its causes were.

If you expect to join the battle within the first chapter or two, be forewarned. McPherson devotes considerable space to the lead up to the conflict. If one is patient, one will end up savoring McPherson's careful exposition of the events and circumstances of the first half of the nineteenth century that resulted in this horrific conflict. One learns that, yes, economic circumstances played a role, as did slavery from various angles (economic, sociological, social justice, etc.), the desire to preserve the Union, and the desire to preserve a way of life. One learns as the book progresses that the causes were not constant, nor were they pure; Lincoln seems a lot more real once one recognizes that his attitudes towards abolition, freedom, and black suffrage were nuanced, were not completely principled, and were affected by events.

I particularly enjoyed the brief treatment of the war at sea--not an aspect of the conflict that seems to get a lot of popular attention, aside from the armored ships. The battles, at land and on sea, were depicted with an economy of words; McPherson's narratives manage to be to the point and clear, and often moving. And it is fascinating to read how close the Republicans came to losing the election of 1864.

Like at least one other reviewer, I noted with alarm the pages dwindle before the war really seemed to be over. Lincoln's assassination is only briefly mentioned, and the reconstruction is left for another volume of the Oxford series. However that may be, this reader yearned for some discussion of the more immediate aftermath of the events described, and of the fate of more than one or two of the key players in the War.

But it should be a compliment to the author that after some 860-someodd pages the reader still wants more. Buy this book!

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Phenomenal.
Review: This fine work is simply the best single volume history on the American Civil War ever written. Complete, thorough and very readable, this scholarly yet practical history is the best cause and effect analysis to date of the event which spawned the America that exists as we know it today. It is a most detailed account of the complete redefinition of what America was to stand for. Very compelling, you will want to read this excellent book two or three times.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: A GREAT BOOK THAT EARNED ITS PULITZER.
Review: Battle Cry of Freedom is an excellent history of the Civil War Era. McPherson neatly weaves all aspects of the war into a grand narrative that will satisfy the serious historian without intimidating the casual reader. While not as comprehensive as Foote's excellent yet monumental three-volume series, Battle Cry delivers more than enough detail to bring the era to life without weighing the reader down with excessive amounts of facts and figures. McPherson's lively writing style is a pleasure to read, and avoids the dry and lifeless tone that plagues so much of historical literature. Also, the chapters alternate between military events and politics/homefront themes, so the reader who is interested mainly in one can skip the other, although I myself would consider skipping any of this book a mistake. In short, a better single-volume history of this book does not exist, and is not likely to be written anytime soon

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: A Standard in Civil War Research
Review: I am not one of the many "experts" on the Civil War. I am a novice on the subject. But I must say that I think it will be hard for me to find a single volume work on the Civil War that surpasses Battle Cry of Freedom. The author does a marvelous job of painting a picture of the nature of the war and the events that led up to it. This is not just a battle by battle account of the war. Rather it speaks of the battles and the political and social ramafications that those battles had. This book is award winning and does not need my written approval, but I just had to say something about. This book is a must read.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: Bias and one sided
Review: While the book contained a lot of good information, the data was greatly manipulated to suit the author's point of view. In many cases partial quotes were taken completely out of context, facts were omitted, and the reader was "set-up" to draw a particular conclusion based on what information was shared and what was withheld. Most disturbing was the way Mr. McPherson attempted to explain to the reader the thoughts and motives (as he believed them to be) behind the actions of various figures, painting the individuals he admired as being of noble intend and those he did not as sinister. I think most people can agree that one can never understand completely what motivates their mate, family member, or closest friend, so to attempt to explain what was in the mind of someone who lived more than a century ago is rather far fetched. It's a shame, as there was obviously a lot of research that went into this book, and it could have been really good had it been presented in an unbiased fashion. Unfortunately, the author's political views were apparent from the very first page. Perhaps the most useful part of the book is the bibliography, providing the reader with sources with which they can do their own research and draw their own conclusions.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Excellent Summary of US Civil War Publications
Review: This is undoubtably the best one-volume work available reagarding the US Civil War. From the Mexican-American War to the US Civil War's end in 1865, James McPherson compiles viewpoints from hundreds of authors into one coherent work. Throughout the book he makes effective use of footnotes and he includes a chapter of suggested further readings to help you sort through the tens of thousands of books on the subject as board as the US Civil War. The copious chapters dedicated to the antebellum period give the reader an easily understood view of WHY the war started and then delves into the major campaigns of the war.

Due to the scope of the topic, each chapter only briefly touches on the material concerned with the chapter. For example, the chapter entitled "The Salt-Water War" discusses the Union's operations to enforce the blockade against the Confederacy while presenting material about the Confederacy's use of commerce raiders and blockade runners. But it's all very high level. Some time is spent giving details about USS Monitor vs CSS Virgina and a few pages are devoted to the discussion of the Trent affair, but not many details are given about men like Raphael Semmes and his command of CSS Sumter and CSS Alabama. The most that's said of Semmes is a paragraph saying he destroyed eighteen vessels while commanding Sumter and "went on to bigger achievements" when commanding the Alabama. But there isn't a discussion on what impact these sorts of achievements had on the North.

But that's where the footnotes come into play. He liberaly cites sources for the material he's covering and it's easy to find more detailed sources for those topics the reader is interested in. This is also somewhat of a shortcoming because there doesn't seem to be much of the author's actual viewpoints in the book - it comes off as simply an assembly of other's authors ideas.

However, this is what makes this book so valuable. It gives the reader an opportunity to survey a large number of other works in an easy to read format while getting an excellent high level overview of the antebellum period and the war.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Authoritative account of Civil War era
Review: James McPherson has done an excellent job of condensing a very complicated (and controversial) era of U.S. history into a single volume. His book provides a detailed account of the battles and military strategy which defined the war. Just as importantly, however, it provides a social and political context for understanding why the war unfolded the way it did. His narrative of Abraham Lincoln especially gave me a deeper appreciation of how courageous and brilliant this great American president was.

Interestingly, the book doesn't follow a strict chronological order. This seems to have been done in order to maintain some continuity in the subject matter. It doesn't take away from the overall experience, as all events are eventually discussed in detail.

I enjoyed the book very much, and it is not difficult to see why Battle Cry of Freedom won a Pulitzer Prize.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: THE Civil War book to own
Review: James McPherson is Edwards Professor of American History at Princeton University. He has written more than eight other books on the Civil
War era including The Struggle for Equality, The Abolitionist Legacy, and Ordeal by Fire.

During the hundredth anniversary years of the Civil War, Bruce Catton wrote a series of books on the war which were highly praised for their content and his writing. Allan Nevins produced eight detailed books on the events leading to, following through, and subsequent to the conflict. With Shelby Foote's three volume history, this trio and hundreds of other standard and new sources provide the most comprehensive history of this pivotal period of American history. McPherson's research and narrative deservedly won the Pulitzer Prize.

The beginning is one year after what Bernard Devoto calls 1846;Year of Decision.
McPherson recalls the generals who served in the Mexican War and how they were led to the greater, more personal conflict in 1861 as friends and enemies. He reaches back to the 1776 Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of 1787, bringing us through the torturous trail that was the basis for America's founding and what some call the inevitable path to civil war.

The book's greatest strength lies in the exploration of the details which brought about this inevitability; the Declaration's omission by not dealing with slavery, the Constitution's allowance of its continuance, the abrogation of the Missouri Compromise and the Dred Scott Decision as well as the many other events which were precursors to the loss of more than 600,000 Americans.

When battles are described, McPherson uses the interim between them to tell us what was happening in other aspects of government, the reactions of the people, politics and international reaction. The battles are related not only as to their excitement and ferocity but, more important, their effect on the outcome of the war.
(How many times could the war have ended had individual outcomes been different, for the actions of its principals, ruled by their personalities and the quirks of weather, health and fate, been different?)

McPherson devotes considerable thought to slavery (Is this not what the war was about?) and promises that he will treat the subject further in his subsequent writings. He tells of the impact of Negro military forces in the fighting on the outcome to the point of the South's eventually giving in to using Blacks near the end in desperation despite the protests of many Southerners. The importance of the effect of the Emancipation Proclamation on Black enlistments is brought to mind and how hard they believed and fought, "If the white man can fight for my freedom, we can fight just as hard."

I highly recommend Battle Cry of Freedom to anyone interested in American history. An understanding of this epochal period is crucial in understanding what we were and what we are. Be forewarned that reading it - and rereading it - can lead to greater desire for more.


<< 1 2 3 4 .. 13 >>

© 2004, ReviewFocus or its affiliates