Rating: Summary: Excellent first exposure Review: This book is an exceptionally good primer for those who haven't had much exposure to Buddhist philosophy. I see that many other reviewers felt that Dr. Cutler's portions of the book were not worthwhile. However, being a person of Eastern origin who has lived much of her life in the West, the thing that strikes me about how Eastern thought is generally discussed in the West is how it gets removed from the context of day-to-day problems and solutions. Dr. Cutler does a very good job of helping his reader make the connection between the centuries-old wisdom of Buddhism and one's own daily situations. I found it to be the most inspirational book I've read in a very long time.
Rating: Summary: Good expose of the negative qualities of Western psychology. Review: Western psychology compares poorly with Buddhist philosophy when they meet to discuss emotions, happiness, insight, love, and compassion. Dr. Cutler is to be praised for honestly revealing the shortfalls of his field and his own attitudes. I would have preferred for there to be more Dalai Lama and less Dr. Cutler, but Dr. Cutler's ruminations gave me a good glimpse into the mental attitude of the people working in the psychology field today, as well as the general Western cultural attitude. No wonder there are so many depressed people!
Rating: Summary: NOT A HANDBOOK OF ANYTHING Review: IF THERE HAS EVER BEEN A BOOK THAT HAS NOT LIVED UP TO IT'S TITLE , IT IS THIS ONE, THIS IS NOT A HANDBOOK , IT'S AN ORGANIZED GROUP OF IDEAS. THE DALAI LAMA'S PART OF THE BOOK IS GREAT , IT DESERVES 5 STARS , BUT THE REST IS NOT WORTH READING , A BAD INTRO TO BUDDHISM. YOU'LL FIND YOURSELF SKIPPING AROUND TO FIND WHAT THE DALAI LAMA AND ONLY THE DALAI LAMA HAS TO SAY. IF YOU WANT A BOOK THIS IS FINE , IF YOU WANT A CLEAR AND WORTHWHILE BUDDHIST HANDBOOK ,LOOK ELSEWHERE
Rating: Summary: An overview of the Dalai Lama's philosophy of life Review: It's an interesting book that provides much insight into the Dalai Lama's philosophy regarding answers to the essential questions of our being. His values stem from the Tibetan Buddhism as he is the religious leader thereof. Another book along these lines that deals with the art of happiness and is also a great handbook for living which has helped me a lot, and I recommend highly is Dietmar Scherf's "I Love Me: Avoiding and Overcoming Depression"--also available at Amazon.
Rating: Summary: East meets West and West meets East Review: I couldn't help but to write a few more words regarding the recurring debate on the part of Howard Cutler's work in this book.For those who are critical about Cutler's writing and case studies, put yourself into the shoes of a Western trained psychiatrist with strong background in psychoanalysis. You've been working all your life in this profession. How easy is it to take in the Eastern philosophy wholesale without a single question? Eastern mindset takes all master teachings for granted and would not raise a single question. Western training emphasise on critical thinking. What we are reading in the book is a blend of the two. On one hand, we are reading the stories of the Dalai Lama and his speeches/teachings/elaborations - which some of us take it for granted as something should not be questioned; on the other hand, there are readers who are not familiar with the concept of buddhism and seek ways to try an grasp the ideas - to them (probably through the eyes of Cutler) the questions raised will help answer many questions which some buddhists dare not to ask. If you read the book from a Eastern perspective and expect something that is more Oriental in nature, you would come out saying that Cutler has unnecessarily taken a negative stance towards the teachings. If you read the book from a Western perspective, you probably would come out thinking that there's a great deal of intriguing insights and healthy dialogues probing the philosophy of the East from a Western perspective. The way to appreciate this book is, to me, to separate the quotations and Cutler's comments mentally when reading it. Each one would have their own uniquely different contribution to the understanding of happiness (one from the East and the other from the West). Then, put the two together mentally and you will find the book to be a very enjoyable read. It is a good way to train yourself to switch perspective and attitudes and take on a different views on the same subject.
Rating: Summary: Excellent!!!! One of the very best self-illuminating books. Review: I'm re-reading the book again--it cannot be absorbed in one reading. This book could be used as a daily guide to living. I am purchasing other copies for friends. The only short-coming, in my view as a professional socilogist, was there is sometimes too much personal psychological babble included by the interviewer/writer.
Rating: Summary: Decent But Heavy On The Personal Agenda Review: This book was a decent read, but I found Cutler to be a bit overwhelming. It seemed as if he was trying to question the simplicty and thoughts of His Holiness. And also it seemed that he was trying to boast of his own experiences and cases, using the Buddhist thought and way to perhaps make himself look smart or just to say "Yeah that's how I see it too!" This was a easy to understand book and for that I must give him credit. But it was bit weighed down with Cutler's own personal agenda. There are many other good books by and about His Holiness which are much more insightful.
Rating: Summary: Both the scientist, and the Buddhist disappointed. Review: I am a biologist, and I bought this book because I was intrigued by the idea of asking questions of the Dalai Lama from a scientific perspective. Looking at "The Art of Happiness" both as a scientist, and as a begginer in Buddhist thought, I found myself disappointed from both perspectives. This book isn't really a "handbook" of anything. It is poorly organized, and takes the form of a strangely interrupted "stream of consciousness" conversation. It feels sketchy and incomplete, and left me feeling that I was missing a great deal from both sides. Although I disagree with those who mistake critical thinking and hard questions for "sarcasm", I can't say that I was overly impressed with Dr. Cutler's style. However, I was equally dissatisfied with some of the Dalai Lama's answers. So, as a beginning Buddhist, I say skip this book and try "Buddhism Plain and Simple" by Steve Hagan. As a scientist, I can also recommend a book about cognitive therapy called "Feeling Good" by Dr. David Burns, which has a great deal in common with Buddhist thought, particularly on the subject of happiness.
Rating: Summary: Dalai Lama's Message Clouded by Cutler Review: The insights in this book from the Dalai Lama are very worthwhile. This part of the book deserves five stars. The analysis by the author Michael Cutler and his study-question style of interviewing the Dalai Lama was frustrating and annoying. Furthermore, many of his extrapolations on human behavior seemed a little unworthy of publication, such as his analysis of Western Romantic Love. This was a very superficial and somewhat inaccurate history of romantic love in Western culture, which began much before the literary period of Romanticism, but rather finds its roots in the Middle Ages with the Troubadours and then on through the Renaissance. Additionally, it seems that Mr. Cutler expressed a lot of pointless anger in the book, unworthy of someone who should even be talking to the Dalai Lama let alone writing a book about his teachings. I cite the lengthy diatribe about how he disliked the person next to him on the airplane, and then coming to the marvelous conclusion that in fact, he did not truly hate this person's thumb, etc.
Rating: Summary: Very enjoyable to read, very enjoyable to live by Review: This book is for those who really cannot get along with themselves. People who are unconfident, depressed or afraid. The Dalai Lama's insites on life are truly inspiring. Bieh.
|