Buster Keaton's Sherlock Jr. (Cambridge Film Handbooks)

Rating:
Summary: You're being too harsh!
Review: I don't think this book is bad at all! It has a lot of interesting things to say about Sherlock, Jr. I really think the past two reviewers were way too harsh!

Rating:
Summary: Worst sort of academic writing
Review: Please, please, please avoid this book. If it was possible to give it NO stars, I would have done so. It is the most turgid academic bilge I have read in years. Why is there so much drivel written about Keaton? You are better off searching out David Robinson's KEATON, the best critial analysis of his films. Check this out on OOP booksearches instead; it probably costs the same as this wretched book and it is at least worth it.

Rating:
Summary: They made Buster Keaton boring.
Review: Read the other one star review. It was being kind