Grant Green: Rediscovering the Forgotten Genius of Jazz Guitar

Rating:
Summary: needs some more critical perspective
Review: Sharony Green is trying something interesting here, a biography which is also something of an autobiography. She does a nice job of letting the various people who knew Green speak, and you do get an interesting sense of the man from the book. I have two criticisms. The first is that it goes on and on about how forgotten and unappreciated Green is, which gets tiring after a while. After all, most people who read this book will already think green was a great guitarist. And the guy is one more records than anybody but Milt Hinton--he was hardly unappreciated. He was never as famous as Wes or Benson, but they were more marketable than Green was

The other annoying thing about the book is that it goes on and on about how Green was ripped off. It's true that the white controlled industry is doubly tough on African Americans, and musicians get exploited frequently. But Green never lacked a gig--he worked ALL the time. He had more work in a year, more high quality work, with first rate musicians, than some people get in a decade. So he had money--he was well paid by the standards of his profession. He blew it all in addiction--his sad end came through his own doing. He was a lousy father and husband, and pissed his success away. I don't know why, and the book can't say--maybe nobody can. It'd be easy and wrong to understate the power of racism to twist and warp lives, but it's hard to pity Green in some ways. He never lacked for work or recognition in his lifetime, he had prodigious gifts, stunning intelligence and fire (i've spent all afternoon working on his solo on "Speak Low," and I'm more amazed as I go along), but he did himself in, which was maybe nore of a tragedy than if he was done in by racism

It's an interesting and evocative book, that conveys a good sense of the world Green came up in and the world of jazz in the 50s and 60s Worth a read for any jazz fan or lover of Green's great playing

Rating:
Summary: Harsh realities of the jazz business underscored
Review: This often inspiring biography not only provides a concise outline of the great guitarist's life, but also underscores the harsh economic realities of the era. Drummer Elvin Jones' comments at page 112 are particularly instructive. Regarding business practices at the esteemed Blue Note record company, Mr. Jones relates, "...it was easy for the record companies to make a lot of recordings because there wasn't a big outlay as far as money was concerned...but I don't think very many of the jazz artists received any of the benefits of the marketing process...it was a life-and-death struggle all the time."

These and similar anecdotes make this biography a must reading for those interested in the realities of the jazz business.

Rating:
Summary: Jazz fans may not like it.
Review: When I bought the book I looked forward to some insite to the genius of the great guitarist. It is there,but the book suffers from many editing and content errors,the reviews are just the worst,for example Tobias Jundt states that the Green tune "Blues for Charlie" was written as a tribute to Charlie Parker,when the liner notes to the record state it was written for Charlie Christian. A disturbing error is on pages 170-171 when Idris Muhammad speaks about a recording he did with John Scofield,the book has his name mispelled "John Schofield",this is bad due to the fact Muhammad insists that the author check out the recording. There are too many herion stories that seem to be always included in any music related biography,and the author's personal life is elaborated too much in the book,but there is some interesting reading in some parts such as the blue note content,I would recommend this for a casual read but not for one who seeks technical jazz information.

Rating:
Summary: needs some more critical perspective
Review: While a good book, and admittedly the only source out there from which one can gain much info about Grant Green, the style is a bit cramped and extremely subjective making it a tough read. Sharony Green conveys a good deal of information about Grant, but at the same time presents it in a stale and not very insightful style. There is a wealth of unwarranted speculation that does little to forward a view of Grant Green, and instead of "Rediscovering the Lost Genius" of Grant Green, the reader feels more as if the author feels a need to validate Grant Green. For that, just pick up "Idle Moments" or "Matador" or any of the other great Green recordings. This validation seems a bit irreverent and at times, didactic.

That being said, the subjectivity of the book lends a viewpoint that is worth noting and there is a vast amount of information regarding Grant collected in the book, though at times it is less than completely accurate (eg. At one point, the author refers to Grant's "I Want to Hold Your Hand" recording as a collection of Beatle and other pop tunes. In fact, the title track is the only pop tune on the LP). The book's discography approaches a comprehensive survey of the recordings available, and the reviews offered at the end of the text are particularly helpful. If this book were part of a larger literature devoted to Grant Green it would be a valuable addition, but as the only extant source for info on Grant Green it misses its mark.

Rating:
Summary: Fair amount of info, not much insight.
Review: While a good book, and admittedly the only source out there from which one can gain much info about Grant Green, the style is a bit cramped and extremely subjective making it a tough read. Sharony Green conveys a good deal of information about Grant, but at the same time presents it in a stale and not very insightful style. There is a wealth of unwarranted speculation that does little to forward a view of Grant Green, and instead of "Rediscovering the Lost Genius" of Grant Green, the reader feels more as if the author feels a need to validate Grant Green. For that, just pick up "Idle Moments" or "Matador" or any of the other great Green recordings. This validation seems a bit irreverent and at times, didactic.

That being said, the subjectivity of the book lends a viewpoint that is worth noting and there is a vast amount of information regarding Grant collected in the book, though at times it is less than completely accurate (eg. At one point, the author refers to Grant's "I Want to Hold Your Hand" recording as a collection of Beatle and other pop tunes. In fact, the title track is the only pop tune on the LP). The book's discography approaches a comprehensive survey of the recordings available, and the reviews offered at the end of the text are particularly helpful. If this book were part of a larger literature devoted to Grant Green it would be a valuable addition, but as the only extant source for info on Grant Green it misses its mark.