Home :: Books :: Comics & Graphic Novels  

Arts & Photography
Audio CDs
Audiocassettes
Biographies & Memoirs
Business & Investing
Children's Books
Christianity
Comics & Graphic Novels

Computers & Internet
Cooking, Food & Wine
Entertainment
Gay & Lesbian
Health, Mind & Body
History
Home & Garden
Horror
Literature & Fiction
Mystery & Thrillers
Nonfiction
Outdoors & Nature
Parenting & Families
Professional & Technical
Reference
Religion & Spirituality
Romance
Science
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Sports
Teens
Travel
Women's Fiction
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

List Price: $4.99
Your Price: $4.99
Product Info Reviews

<< 1 >>

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: wow - what a fun read!
Review: I've had little experience with graphic novels, but this piqued my interest - 4 legends of 19th century literature brought together to combat another legendary villian of the same era. I am not ashamed to admit I love it!

The characters themeselves are all true to their 19th century personas - Willhelmina (Mina) Harker (of Dracula), Allan Quartermain (of the Lost City of Gold), Captain Nemo (the Asian Indian intended by Verne), H.G. Wells' Invisible Man, and of course Dr. Jekyll - each with their foibles (Quartermain is an opimum addict, Jekyll a hopeless coward, the Invisible Man a letch ...) which makes them all the more real.

I was impressed with the artwork - the detail was remarkable, which oftentimes caught my attention more than the story line (which also is quite good.) But what really cinched it for me was the little literary tidbits sprinkled throughout - for example, there are references to James Fennimore Cooper's "Hawkeye" (aka "Natty Bumpo"), Charles Dickens' Oliver Twist (look for the Artful Dodger ...) and others. I saw it as sort of an inside joke, and I loved it. Its a great story, fabulous art, and an interesting premise.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: A Great Book!
Review: If you like classic books like , 2,000 Leauges Under The Sea, or The Adventures Of Quatermain and the Solomon Goldmines, then you'll love this book. It involves all of the old classic characters like Dorian Grey and Captian Nemo in an action packed adventure book. They have to stop this man called The Phantom before he takes over the world. He is trying to start a world war but the characters must stop him at all costs. It is a very interesting book. It's that kind of book that you can read on a weekend or save it for a rainy day. I really hope you buy the book, unless you are a comic book fan then buy the comic.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: This is the movie's screenplay
Review: If you want to read Alan Moore's work, do not get this! The screenplay has a storyline that is very different than Moore's original graphic novel. Reasons to get this version

1) You want to relive the movie

2) You are a big fan of Dorian Gray (who is not in Moore's original)

3) You like Siberia depicted in comic books.

4) You are not interested in edgy mature graphic novels like Moore's.

Personally, I found the storyline of Moore's original much more interesting and have no plans to want to relive the movie.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: Not the Comic
Review: Please note that this Adobe Reader book is a text novelization by Kevin Anderson, not the actual comics novel by Alan Moore.

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: The league of Extraordinary gentlemen: a fan fiction??
Review: The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: the ultimate fan fiction

" The league is set and the game is on." This isn't the typical league, but the league of extraordinary gentlemen. (LXG by J.K. Anderson ) This book seems like the ultimate fan fiction. Combining from well know and well loved books into one novel. From the deserts of Africa , to the wastelands of Siberia, to the leadgudary ship, The Nautilus. This book has everything, down to James bond's own grandfather!! But Really, this book stays true to the original characterization. The Victorian classics are back and revamped. (pardon the pun.)

Just who is in this League?? Well... Allan Quatermain, the hunter and leader (from King Solomon's Mine.) Rodney Skinner, the "gentleman thief" and invisible man . ( he stole the invisibility potion from the creator ,Dr. Hawley Griffin, and wasn't in the original book.) Mrs. Mina Harker, vampire and chemist. ( from Bram Stoker's Dracula) Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde , the scitzo ( from the book of the same name) Dorian Grey , the immortal ( from The Picture of Dorian Grey) Tom Sawyer , the gun-man ( from Mark Twain's adventures) and Captain Nemo , the engineer ( from 20,000 leagues under the Sea)

A mystery man, simply known as "M", selects 5 legendary characters to prevent WWI, stop the bad guy, and save dozens of German scientist and their families from his headquarters. The twists in this novel never end. Romantic tension, bizarre betrayals, misjudgment of a loyal character, death, murder, and every plot twist imagined.

The thorough characterization are better then any other books about the same old, dusty characters. They act and react like normal 20th century people. Not untouchable, unrealistic, stiff characters they are sometimes. They are heroes in the own right, but they also have the same behaviors, bad habits, and downfalls everyone has. For example: Dorian is arrogant , Allan has lost faith in his country, Tom talks too much, Mina still has feelings for Dorian, Nemo prides his ship, and Jekyll has paranoia.

The plot , a typical adventure, has weaknesses. In some places it seems that Anderson is just setting up for his next book. Like the way he sets up relationships and sets down the characters. The plot also evolves around massive fight scenes, sense this is a movie tie-in it really does not work. The fights are climatic thou , but made for a movie, a big downfall for the reader.

Language is oppsoleete in this novel. The diction of the characters don't make their personality. Except for Sawyer, who uses American slang and terms, like "shucks" or "darlin'" . The British characters never use British phrases like "Ticky-boo" or "bloody".

This novel can't be assigned a rating too quickly. It comes from a well written comic book . The reader should definitely check that out first, this novel is hardly it's equal! If the reader is a fan of Dracula ( or any of the other books) they may not like this book. If the reader loves movies, then they may love it. It depends on the person reading it. It's hardly a Pulitzer , but it is a great, original idea. Check out Allan Moore and Kevin O'Neil's graphic novel of the same name.

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: The league of Extraordinary gentlemen: a fan fiction??
Review: The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: the ultimate fan fiction

" The league is set and the game is on." This isn't the typical league, but the league of extraordinary gentlemen. (LXG by J.K. Anderson ) This book seems like the ultimate fan fiction. Combining from well know and well loved books into one novel. From the deserts of Africa , to the wastelands of Siberia, to the leadgudary ship, The Nautilus. This book has everything, down to James bond's own grandfather!! But Really, this book stays true to the original characterization. The Victorian classics are back and revamped. (pardon the pun.)

Just who is in this League?? Well... Allan Quatermain, the hunter and leader (from King Solomon's Mine.) Rodney Skinner, the "gentleman thief" and invisible man . ( he stole the invisibility potion from the creator ,Dr. Hawley Griffin, and wasn't in the original book.) Mrs. Mina Harker, vampire and chemist. ( from Bram Stoker's Dracula) Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde , the scitzo ( from the book of the same name) Dorian Grey , the immortal ( from The Picture of Dorian Grey) Tom Sawyer , the gun-man ( from Mark Twain's adventures) and Captain Nemo , the engineer ( from 20,000 leagues under the Sea)

A mystery man, simply known as "M", selects 5 legendary characters to prevent WWI, stop the bad guy, and save dozens of German scientist and their families from his headquarters. The twists in this novel never end. Romantic tension, bizarre betrayals, misjudgment of a loyal character, death, murder, and every plot twist imagined.

The thorough characterization are better then any other books about the same old, dusty characters. They act and react like normal 20th century people. Not untouchable, unrealistic, stiff characters they are sometimes. They are heroes in the own right, but they also have the same behaviors, bad habits, and downfalls everyone has. For example: Dorian is arrogant , Allan has lost faith in his country, Tom talks too much, Mina still has feelings for Dorian, Nemo prides his ship, and Jekyll has paranoia.

The plot , a typical adventure, has weaknesses. In some places it seems that Anderson is just setting up for his next book. Like the way he sets up relationships and sets down the characters. The plot also evolves around massive fight scenes, sense this is a movie tie-in it really does not work. The fights are climatic thou , but made for a movie, a big downfall for the reader.

Language is oppsoleete in this novel. The diction of the characters don't make their personality. Except for Sawyer, who uses American slang and terms, like "shucks" or "darlin'" . The British characters never use British phrases like "Ticky-boo" or "bloody".

This novel can't be assigned a rating too quickly. It comes from a well written comic book . The reader should definitely check that out first, this novel is hardly it's equal! If the reader is a fan of Dracula ( or any of the other books) they may not like this book. If the reader loves movies, then they may love it. It depends on the person reading it. It's hardly a Pulitzer , but it is a great, original idea. Check out Allan Moore and Kevin O'Neil's graphic novel of the same name.

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: Careful, the other reviews are a little deceptive.
Review: The tacking reviews of the original graphic novel to the movie tie-in novelization. It can easily mislead unwary buyers into thinking Kevin J. Anderson's potboiler writing in any way compares to Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill's work, or even -- god forbid -- deserves to ride piggyback on the same ratings and reviews.

My suggestion: skip the movie and the tie-in altogether, and save your cash for the graphic novels.


<< 1 >>

© 2004, ReviewFocus or its affiliates