Ultimate X-men Vol. 3

Rating:
Summary: Great Edition, but the story isn't quite 5 stars
Review: I'm lovin' the Hardcover Editions of Ultimate X-Men! I'm a bit old (and tight on money now that I'm an adult) to be spending all of my hard earned cash on single issues and then boxing them etc - so having 12 issues(!) collected in a well bound hardcover just like a book is the best! It goes on the shelf and looks all snazzy next to the other HC books I have. Not to mention, it's a lot harder to damage.

Now lets talk about the 12 issues for a second, this edition reprints Ultimate War #1-4 and then Ultimate X-Men #26-33 (Return of the King storyline). Also, they skip all of the extra stuff like the titles on the first splash page of each issue and replace it with a tasteful single page at the beginning. It makes for a much cleaner look and a real novel feel for the book.

Now the stories themselves didn't impress me as much as the first two HC editions of Ultimate X-Men (or first 4 trade paperbacks) but thats just me I guess. They're still good, but nothing beats seeing Magneto go crazy in the first story arc of Ultimate X-Men.

So, highly recommended and if you're looking to start reading Ultimate X-Men deffinantly go for the hardcover editions which are all available thru Amazon.com.

Rating:
Summary: Los mutantes recontados
Review: La idea del Universo Ultimate que tan bien le esta saliendo a la Marvel, es adaptar sus historias clasicas al entorno actual con la finalidad de atraer nuevos lectores. Es decir, todos sabemos lo geniales que son los mutantes de Stan Lee pero reconozcamos que no atraen lo suficiente a nuevos lectores.
Asi, esta version Ultimate incorpora varios cambios menores que al final hacen un gran cambio, por ejemplo en las personalidades de los personajes, su origen, etc. Y todo eso hace una gran lectura. El escritor es Mark Millar, la actual estrella de la editorial Marvel que ademas ha escrito a los geniales Ultimates y los dibujantes son los hermanos Adam y Andy Kubert que se complementan muy bien el uno al otro. En resumen, buenos autores logran una estupenda historia.
Este tomo de tapa dura tiene los primeros 12 numeros de la coleccion Ultimate X-men:
- del #1 al #6: Tomorrow People, como se reclutan a los nuevos X-men y la pelea contra la version mas malvada de Magneto que se haya visto.
- del #7 al #12: Return to Weapon X, con la aparición estelar del Ultimate Samuel Jackson, perdon, quise decir Nick Fury.
Altamente recomendable para quienes pensaron que no se podian hacer nuevas historias de mutantes, para quienes no tienen nada de los X-men en su coleccion y para quienes llegan a los X-men por la pelicula.

Rating:
Summary: Keep it real
Review: The creators of Ultimate X-men did a very smart thing. They started all the way over. Considering Ult. X-men starts off anew, they can do what they wish with the story. Unlike X-treme and New X-Men which have plots so Twisted, it doesn't feel like the X-Men at all. They changed a few things in this series, like how Wolverine joined. Also Colossus and Storm take Angel's place as one of the first X-men. Making a team of 6 instead of 5. Magneto and the Brotherhood are pretty much the same. These books are solely based on story. Theres action, but its kinda far between.

Rating:
Summary: New generation of writers out to destroy comics....
Review: These new stories by Millar contain terrible Kubert drawings and story plots that go no where. They play more like a video game rather then a comic and are the work of people who are more like internet geeks then serious writers. No wonder comic book sales are dead and less then 2,000 comic book stores are still open nationwide.