Phoenix: Dawn

Rating:
Summary: Excellent work, insulting translation.
Review: Fans of Osama Tezuka know what to expect -- a wild imagination driven by the shock and anger that drove many post-WWII storytellers.

Phoenix, billed as Tezuka's crowning achievement, does not disappoint a fan. Once again, Tezuka primarily seeks to comment on the human condition. This time, he uses a post-apocalypic future to examine the faults of man.

Surprisingly, this time Tezuka manages to manage an amount of optimism, as this story seems to hold at its core a hope that these faults can someday be overcome, even if history testifies otehrwise. A powerful story even if you border on burning out of Tezuka's typical issues.

Rating:
Summary: Excellent work, insulting translation.
Review: First let me start off by saying that Tezuka's Hinotori is a masterpiece of illustrated storytelling, and anyone would do well to pick it up, even if they aren't into comics. However I do truly wish that there a better translation for you to read. Dadakai has unfortunately shown that it has no respect for the audience's intelligence with their translation. They began by adding a text "narration" to the sequence of the volcano erupting at the beginning. The writing of these scenes is inept and overblown, if I hadn't already read the book in French, I would've probably given up on it there. These text boxes add nothing to the story, and actually take something of it away, because besides being poorly worded, they also cover up some of the artwork that Tezuka-sama meant for us to see! I suppose some changes are acceptable, such as making Guzuly "EmDee", but the most intelligence-insulting gesture, which made me throw the book across the room, was in the character of Saruta. American readers encountered Dr. Saruta in the "first" volume of Phoenix (actually the second), and since we American readers can't obviously concieve of the characters of Saruta and Sarutahiko being connected (probably by reincarnation) they chopped the -hiko off the end of his name so as not to confuse us. Dadakai doesn't respect its audience, and hence I don't respect their work. You'd probably be better off buying the French or Japanese version and
translating them yourselves.

Rating:
Summary: Good? Confused?
Review: I liked this story, but I will understand if you do not. Let me explain.

Dawn is a compelling story of a boy, Nagi, who is taken as a slave from his home, after watching the army that takes him kill every man, woman and child in his village. In a Mountain of Fire near the village lives the Phoenix. Nagi wants to kill the Phoenix and drink her blood, which gives immortality. The trouble is, many other people are also hunting the phoenix.

It is possible that much of the story was lost in translation. Tezuka supposedly considered this series to be his masterpiece, but at times the writing seems awkward. The story deals with death in a very blunt way. At no time is the bloodshed gratuitous, but it can be disturbing. At the same time, Tezuka tries to break up the devestation with missplaced comic relief.

Overall, the story is compelling, and leaves you wanting more. But there is an underlying awkwardness that makes me hesitant to give five stars.

Rating:
Summary: A DYING EARTH
Review: In the year 3404 A.D., the earth and its civilizations are on their last legs. There are only 5 human cities left and those have moved underground where, in an effort to stem despair, they have been dubbed the "eternal capitals". Enter Space Patrolman Masato who is in love with a shape-shifting and mind altering alien named Tamimi. Her race has been outlawed on Earth because the authorities fear that humans, if subjected to the moopie dream state, will become lethargic lotus eaters.

Masato is ordered to kill Tamimi but refuses and flees with her to the surface world where they run into the hermit Dr. Saruta, a brillant scientist whose vision of a flaming phoenix might just hold the future rebirth of a new Earth within it. In the meantime, Masato's old boss, Roc, becomes obsessed with hunting down the fugitives.

Some of the blurbs on this book refer to it as "mind-blowing" and "awesome" etc., like the effect of a psychadelic drug. While I wouldn't go that far, Phoenix does go a long way past 99% of comics being produced today. While it takes a bit to get used to the cartoonish figures within, it really grabs a hold of you. Tezuka is trying to craft an almost future history of the Earth with deep philisophical themes which make the characters at the beginning of the book seem almost trivial. On the other hand, it strengthens the relationship between Masato and Tamimi by showing the fragility of human life when compared to the life of a universe.

I admire Tezuka for attempting to grapple with such deep issues in a comic form. This book is actually the 2nd volume of a 12 volume series which is only just now being published in America.

Rating:
Summary: Undescribably buetiful
Review: Osamu Tezuka amazes me, I'd throw everything away just to be like him, words short of god fail to describe him. He is a master of his art, invoking feelings from sadness, to hope, to despair, to joyfulness, and back again. I'm a guy who has gone through pain unlike what you could most likely imagine, at the very least I've hardened to the point where I couldn't care less, to do this to me, to make me feels exactly what the characters are feeling as they are feeling it, is beyond indescribable. I don't know japanese or french, if what they say is true, then that just means I'll have to create my own masterpieces in english.

Rating:
Summary: The Future is hopeless - but there is hope.
Review: Osamu Tezuka is a household name in Japan, often refered to as the God of Manga. He started work in the late 1940's and personally invented virtually every part of the visual and storytelling style that are now part of the Manga basic language. He's the Shakespeare of the artform.

Well maybe not. He's was not the greatest true artist out there and sometimes his characters and dialog-tone are too similar from one book to the next. He produced litterally 10 pages per day for many years, and such amazing output makes these foibles more understandable.

But what he does contribute more than anything else is real situations, with suffering and death and unexplained chaos. There's no way to tell where a Tezuka story will move, just like real life. He's not writing with a formula, or writing 'just so' stories where things have to balance. He's far better than that. His people are often shallow, but they have real emotion and convey it very simply and with great precision.

Largely due to Tezuka's influence over other writers and artists Manga became a major Japanese cultural export to the entire East Asian region. He was by far the most famous person in his artform for many decades and when he died in 1989 the whole Japanese nation mourned his passing.

These Mangas, especially the Pheonix series which was written for adults, make a an over-arching statement about the nature of the world & how he sees a cycle of hope and destruction and rebirth. One reads Tezuka and automatically thinks 'this is about something deeper than what's on the page..what is he trying to say here?'.

In this book, which documents the end of the world and humanity and then it's rebirth in the very distant future, the Phoenix takes her chosen human servant on a journey through the microverse and the macroverse, showing it to be a place of vibrant life and spiritual energy.

It was both incredibly ambitious and very moving - I felt transformed by reading it - that this wasn't just a comic - that this was a worldview that was real and which could be conveyed successfully through this artform.

Although many artists have since come along who are more gifted than Tezuka and a few of his more recent Manga peers are at least his equal in other ways (Hayao Miyazaki), I can think of none who would pursue such an unusual and central human theme in this way, with such directness and with the talent to succeed. That's why he's the God of Manga. He will be in print for centuries to come.

Rating:
Summary: GREAT!!!
Review: Rumiko Takahashi is probably the most celebrated voice of the
last twenty years in the field of manga. These are the same twenty years in which manga has suffered a gradual but steady
decline, resulting in a state where even the best manga is mostly
unreadble, intentionally obtuse and "deep" in a shallow short of
way. The reason is that there is currently no one to match the
sheer power and majesty, not to mention the utter simplicity, of
Osamu Tezuka: the God of manga. Hinotori is undoubtedly his best
work. It is subtle and deep; and fulfills the promise that manga
has always made. This story, though the second in the series, is
also the last chronologically. It tells of the end, and rebirth,
of history. Unfortunately this edition suffers from two problems:
First is the size of the edition. The Japanese and French versions of this comic are presented in much smaller books,
hiding flaws of the work and making the work look more detailed.
That's lost in this full-size presentation. Viz also inexplicably
decided to release the second volume first; dulling a great deal
of the impact we get from the series. The first volume was the
beginning of history, the second volume is the end. This also
makes the end sequence suffer because readers won't understand
that they are seeing the events of the first volume take place
in the next incarnation. I still highly recommend buying this
book despite these reservations. And we can only hope that Viz
will release the rest of the volumes, especially the ones set in
the past, which tend to be the best of the series.

Rating:
Summary: GREAT!!!
Review: This book is outstanding. The characters are really life like in the minds eye. The main characters and minor characters burn themselves into your mind. The book has a lot of action in it to keep you in suspense!

Rating:
Summary: Manga of Humanity
Review: This is a very special manga and a piece of literature. First of all, for those who have never read a Tezuka manga, you'd be distracted by the inferiority of the artwork by today's standard. By if you can ignore that, you'll find the storyline is one of the greatest achievements in literary history.

The entire series is shifting between past and future. And the interval between time will become smaller and smaller. For example, the story started from pre-historical Japan, then shift to circa 3000 AD in the future, but the jump between time will become shorter as it goes.

The series is incomplete, due to Tezuka's untimely death, though in other sense, it's completed because I think Tezuka probably knew he probably didn't have time to finish it, so the last published chapter already nailed the point that you can't really miss.

Each episodic story is clearly told, but once you began try to link the point of each story, you'd realize it's actually a collage of pictures with a repeating theme that tries to tell you about this vicious cycle of life. Every story is essentially the same, about how human being overwhelmed by their own greed and do stupid things over and over, disregard the passage of time.

So what's the main conflict? There are some side stories, but all the core stories are united with this Phoenix figure, which essentialy the god figure of the story. The Phoenix is immortal. According to the legend, anyone who drinks her blood, will become immortal as well. That's our conflict. People will do stupid things and kill each other just to become immortal (or become god-like).

Anyways, the original title of the series is called "Hi no Tori", which literally means Bird of Fire in Japanese. The Bird of Fire symbolizes sun in East Asian culture and sun is the source of life. It's highly ironical that the source of life is also the source of death. The translated title "Phoenix" isn't too far off, because there are chapters in the stories that will refer to the immortal bird as the Phoenix when the story is set in China (as that's the Chinese name for such bird).

The story transcends time. One of the chapters is about human cloning (not yet translated into English at the time of this review). Now that's something everyone should read about before one go gaga over this cloning issue that's hotly debated right now. It's about how a Reality TV show ran out of ideas, so he started this new show about clone hunting. Now, I'll let you guys read the story. Keep in mind this story is decades old. That's how ingenius this series is and no wonder Tezuka is called the God of Manga.

Major Spoiler now:

You may at some point feeling lost why Tezuka kept the stories going even though they just repeat itself despite of cosmetic changes (rather similar to life, as I see it). Well, just keep on reading to the end of the last published chapter, things become much clearer (as shift of time become narrower and therefore, more focused). The Phoenix will reveal she is sick and tired of being immortal as she will have to oversee human repeat their stupidity, doing a greedy but pointless quest. If you can see it from this way and draw a parallel to our own existence, you'd be enlightened. It's essentially the same enlightenment Buddha is trying to tell us, but Tezuka was smart enough to make another story that's easier to digest than Buddha's teaching. (btw, Tezuka also have a manga called Buddha, but that's a historical fiction about Buddha's life)

It's a masterpiece no one who is interested in humanity should miss. BTW, EmDee stands for MD. It's an in-joke made by Tezuka, because Tezuka was a medical doctor before he abandoned it to become a manga artist.