Rating: 
Summary: The plot thickens.
Review: Finally, after many volumes, we get some real exploration of Rin as a charater. Both 'On Silent Wings' and 'On Silent Wings II' deal with Rin's inner struggle. In this volume, Rin describes the rest of the events that occured the night her father died. It is both a sickening and an illuminating scene. This scene is very telling about several members of the Itto Ryu - some of them are even worse than they seem, others prove themselves more worthy than Rin would be willing to admit. This series is really begining to flesh out. The question raised by the On Silent Wings story arc is, what will Rin do? She can't seem to stop killing the men she hates, yet deep inside she knows it to be wrong. One thing is for sure, Rin is tearing herself apart with self-loathing and doubt. Meanwhile, Manji is becoming more protective of her, but at a loss as to how to help her.As to the artwork, it is beautiful as always. One picture that I particularly enjoyed was one of Manji holding the unconcious Rin in his arms, looking at her with the most boyish expression I've seen on his face so far. It is a beautiful moment, and Samura captures it perfectly. Another interesting moment in the artwork is Rin's dream, which marvelously illustrates her feelings of doubt and anger, as well as her growing respect for Anotsu. A great manga series. I think everyone should read it, especially those of you who think that 'comic books' are kids' stuff. The intricate plot, the detailed, realistic artwork, and the fascinating characters all contribute to make this one of the best books I've ever read
Rating:
Summary: Among the best books ever written
Review: First, I want to say that "Blade of The Immortal" is a masterpiece. If you haven't bought book one yet, stop reading my clumsy review and buy it already. It's like nothing you've ever seen before. If you buy it and don't like it, you have my permission to send me a nasty e-mail ^_~. That said, on to my review of "On Silent Wings." This paperback holds the first half of the "On Silent Wings" story arc. The book pretty much starts out with Rin finally meeting her adversary after two years of searching. Unfortunately, Rin's hurt pride over a bad training session with Manji leads her to try and fight him alone. This confrontation reveals a lot about Anotsu's character. I found myself really warming up to him. Also, due to Samura's attention to detail in facial expressions, you can see Rin's awakening admiration and respect for her hated enemy as well. This episode, culminated with Makie's admonition in "Dreamsong" add to Rin's growing difficulty with her chosen path. Is she really justified in seeking revenge? This story line marks a turning point for Rin as a person; she's begining to question her own motives. Unfortuately, I think part of her problem is that, without revenge, what has she got in life? It's tearing her apart inside. While Rin's spiritual battle is going on, we are introduced to yet another kenshi from the Itto-ryu, Kawakama Araya. Apparently, Rin has some special reason for hating Araya, but she's not forthcoming with the information. This story ends in a cliffhanger, to be concluded in "On Silent Wings, part 2." So how do I rate this book? Very highly. If this were a volume of Samura's artwork alone, it would be cheap at twice the price. But with Samura's intricate and twisting storyline, I'd have to say it's priceless.
Rating:
Summary: Among the best books ever written
Review: First, I want to say that "Blade of The Immortal" is a masterpiece. If you haven't bought book one yet, stop reading my clumsy review and buy it already. It's like nothing you've ever seen before. If you buy it and don't like it, you have my permission to send me a nasty e-mail ^_~. That said, on to my review of "On Silent Wings." This paperback holds the first half of the "On Silent Wings" story arc. The book pretty much starts out with Rin finally meeting her adversary after two years of searching. Unfortunately, Rin's hurt pride over a bad training session with Manji leads her to try and fight him alone. This confrontation reveals a lot about Anotsu's character. I found myself really warming up to him. Also, due to Samura's attention to detail in facial expressions, you can see Rin's awakening admiration and respect for her hated enemy as well. This episode, culminated with Makie's admonition in "Dreamsong" add to Rin's growing difficulty with her chosen path. Is she really justified in seeking revenge? This story line marks a turning point for Rin as a person; she's begining to question her own motives. Unfortuately, I think part of her problem is that, without revenge, what has she got in life? It's tearing her apart inside. While Rin's spiritual battle is going on, we are introduced to yet another kenshi from the Itto-ryu, Kawakama Araya. Apparently, Rin has some special reason for hating Araya, but she's not forthcoming with the information. This story ends in a cliffhanger, to be concluded in "On Silent Wings, part 2." So how do I rate this book? Very highly. If this were a volume of Samura's artwork alone, it would be cheap at twice the price. But with Samura's intricate and twisting storyline, I'd have to say it's priceless.
Rating:
Summary: I am impressed
Review: I am really impressed by the capacity of Mr. Samura to change pace on a story. If you have read already the first three books of Sword of the Inmortal then you would be surprised too when you read this one. The first two books centered on conflict, Rin wants revenge and she gets it with the help of Manji, an inmortal samurai who has to kill a thousand evil men in order to rest. This two books are full of blood and flashy fighting scenes i really liked. But in the end you just got your classical story of the good guy versus the evil guys. That's until Dreamsong, the third of the books in the series, here you find a girl who is an "evil" minion of the "evil" master sent to kill Manji, the surprise is that she is not so "evil" as we would like to believe and in the end you cannot stay on Manji's side when they duel. Then it comes "On Silent Wings" and you start wondering if you really need another duel or gross decapitation to buy the following books. At first i only saw the conflict, but after reading OSW i began noticing that Mr. Samura is more concerned for the moral dilema than the physical one. This book tells us a story where Rin is the central character; no more Manji stealing the scene, we get to know her best and really love her, she meets face to face the man she has sworn to kill and discovers that he is not so wrong in doing what he did and does to this day, she is suddenly thrown in a conflict where she cannot find the righteous anger she had so far. Throw in the story a mask maker who wants to leave his past behind, a past that involves the reason of Rin to claim vengeance and you are just left wanting for more. Definitively a must buy, i want to show this book to anyone who thinks that comic books or manga books are not well thought; just a word of caution, buy this together with the second part On Silent Wings 2 or you will be running to the computer to order it after reading the first.
Rating: 
Summary: Ignore the volume listing at the top of this page
Review: I bought this book from here at Amazon, thinking that it was first in the series because it says 'volume 1' on it. That is NOT true. This is in actuality volume 4 or 5--it is the first of two PARTS called 'On Silent Wings', but it does not start the series. Now, due to a mistake, I must go back and get the other books before this one so I can have some understanding of what is going on. This looks to be a good series, and I look forward to reading the rest of it, but it would have saved me some hassle if I had known that this is not actually volume 1.
Rating:
Summary: An exciting, thought provoking series.
Review: I stumbled onto "Blade of the Immortal" translations in comic book format. Attracted by the art, and the unusually deep dialogue between the opponents (as dramatic as Kazou Kioke's "Lone Wolf and Cub", but much more up-to-date in sensibility and subject matter) I immediately began looking for back issues, which was difficult. Many retailers don't seem to order many issues of this book. Fortunately the trade paperbacks started coming out soon after. "Blade of the Immortal" starts off as a fairly typical samurai revenge story, with some unusual horror movie twists. We meet Manji, a guilt-ridden outlaw and expert swordsman, who is cursed with an odd form of immortality. No matter how grievously he is injured, he cannot die. Manji makes a deal with a magical buddhist nun. He will gain the release of death, if he slays 1000 evil men. Soon we meet Rin, a young girl, the daughter of a swordsmanship teacher who witnessed the horrific murder of her parents at the hands of the Itto-Ryu, a renegade sword school. Tortured by nightmares, she seeks revenge, but realizing she has no hope of surviving a direct confrontation with even one Itto-Ryu swordsman, she convinces Manji to serve as her bodyguard and stand in. Taking up Rin's quest seems a perfect confluence of both of their desires: her need to put her parents memory to rest, his to earn his redemption. The stories take you through dramatic encounters with various members of the sword school. All are dangerous swordsmen with unique styles of combat. Some are quite literally monsters. Each has a unique story, an unique reason for having become a renegade, and this becomes the source of much thought provoking drama before, during and after the battles. All are memorable characters, in particular Shimuzu (Book Two: "Cry of the Worm"), a fellow immortal and Maki, a swordswoman forced into prostitution who fights like the wind (Book 3: "Dreamsong"). Harioki Samura has great timing, the panel layouts make the fight scenes breathtaking and exciting. Also wonderful is the developing relationship between Manji and Rin, a kind of older brother, little sister dynamic that lends the book much humor and necessary warmth (given the bloodiness of the battles). Beginning with "Rins Bane" (Book 4) Rin's internal debate about the morality and human costs of her quest, takes center stage, and make this one of the deepest and most interesting books to cross the Pacific in years. There's still plenty of action, and the relationship between Rin and Manji continues to deepen, but it's the debates about the sanity of the bushido code, about memory, about filial duty, and hints of political intrigue to come, that make this book an thought provoking and engrossing read. If you have any taste for the high drama and action, as well as the deeper issues running through comic books like "the Authority", you have to give "Blade" a try. This is the best dramatic manga translation I've read, and it compares favorably with "Lone Wolf & Cub" and "Neon Genesis Evangelion". I really don't think you will be disappointed.
Rating:
Summary: More depth for the characters, and great reading for us.
Review: In this, the fourth installment of the Blade of The Immortal series the focus is rarely on the "immortal" mentioned in the title. Instead we learn more about Rin and her ability to deal with challenges and adversity when she learns, much to her dismay, that her fighting abilities are not what she would like them to be (or rather, need them to be in order to actually survive a fight). Much of her personal introspection and growth comes after an encounter with the man whom she is sworn to kill: Kagehisa Anotsu. It is an encounter that at first Rin would rather have not had, but as the book continues on we see that speaking with Anotsu has changed Rin and her view of what she is doing with Manji and this quest of hers . . . at least it seems to have. The book ends on a mild cliffhanger that leaves you wondering just what the hell is going through Rin's mind, and what she's going to do next. This book is outstanding; either by itself or in the context of the larger series it is entertaining and interesting. Being not quite so heavy on the action as the previous three books it might seem as though it would drag, but the character motives and movement keep you interested right from the start. To be honest it would help if you have a working knowledge of the characters and their motivations as they are put forth in the previous books, if for no other reason than to reread them after you've finished On Silent Wings. Even though I am a big fan and feel like I know the story pretty well I still went back and reread the other three books, and I found that a little fore-knowledge really opened up the story. I can't wait for the fifth installment! Yeah, actually that's something else you may want to have on hand as well before you pick this one up, because you're going to wonder what the hell is going through that girl's head too!
Rating:
Summary: A pivotal volume of Blade of the Immortal
Review: The art: you will simply not find anyone better today than Hiroaki Samura; few are even comparable. If you've seen his work, you know why; if you haven't, you should, for you will never look at black and white pencil-and-ink work the same again. Having reviewed several volumes of Blade, it's hard to say much more about the art than that. In terms of story, this is a pivotal moment. This volume contains two arcs: in the first, Rin chances upon Anotsu, the leader of those who murdered her parents. She finally gets the chance to look him in the eye, and she is terrified, for she sees something other than she expected. In the second, Rin is caught up in rage and sorrow when she spies a maskmaker at a fair. The cause of her rage is only hinted at here; the cause of her sorrow is what she saw in Anotsu. This arc will be continued in the next volume, Silent Wings II. There is no real let up in Blade; every story arc has many virtues and few flaws. As with all of Blade, this is not a story for children, not so much for its violence--which are certainly inappropriate for children--but for that fact that it is far too intelligent for most kids.
Rating:
Summary: Beautiful art with an intellectual twist
Review: The first time I looked at the Blade of the Immortal series, I seriously thought "Oh wonderful, another cheesy, gore ridden series with no plot and ... artwork." However, upon reading it I was taken aback by how wrong I truly was. The art is beautiful in its own way, unique and sketchy looking with no possible way it could be turned into an anime and still look as gorgeous. The story is also very nice, there is blood, but there is a good intellectual plot with the occasional twist of witty humor. It is an interesting mix of fact and fantasy, real and surreal all mixed in a historical setting. This series is set apart from others and I don't believe that I have any others quite like it. It never gets old. I highly recommend that, no matter what you're interested in, you should at least give this stunning series a try.
Rating:
Summary: It's Samura, is there any doubt?
Review: The night her parents were murdered before Rin's eyes, Kawakami Araya raped her mother. Now she meets him again, but has he changed that much since that night? Samura delivers the followup to another bloody story of revenge, as Rin seeks out the men who killed her parents. With the help of Manji, an immortal ronin, she might just accomplish her task. As usual, Samura delivers magnificent artwork, interesting characters which I cared about, and unrivaled drama that I love in Blade of the Immortal. With an excellent translation to increase the quality of the manga, On Silent Wings II will not disappoint any fans of the series, or any new comers to the manga.
|
