Holy Saturday: An Argument for the Restoration of the Female Diaconate in the Catholic Church

Rating:
Summary: Superb considerations
Review: I read Holy Saturday after reading about the Adopt a Bishop campaign for it in the National Catholic Reporter. It's a terrific book that fully lives up to its hype, and I'm surprised that no one is commenting on how the book has reshaped the conversation about women in the priesthood. Until recently, you had basically two camps -- the side that argued against women's ordination on the basis of longstanding practice and tradition, and the side that said women should be ordained because women are equal in other areas of society. In Holy Saturday Zagano is taking up the question of the one side with the methods of the other, so both sides can have grounds for discussion. It's the first time in years that we're seeing real conversation about women as deacons. According to Zagano, the Vatican regards the question of women deacons as still being under study and review. If they are willing to say publicly that it's an open question, then conversations can actually lead to mutual learning and real change. I liked the book very much, but I like even more the way it's having a real effect on the way people think and talk about the question, and the way people are willing to discuss it frankly and fairly. Good for Zagano! I wish we had more writers like her.

Rating:
Summary: Changing the nature of the debate
Review: I read Holy Saturday after reading about the Adopt a Bishop campaign for it in the National Catholic Reporter. It's a terrific book that fully lives up to its hype, and I'm surprised that no one is commenting on how the book has reshaped the conversation about women in the priesthood. Until recently, you had basically two camps -- the side that argued against women's ordination on the basis of longstanding practice and tradition, and the side that said women should be ordained because women are equal in other areas of society. In Holy Saturday Zagano is taking up the question of the one side with the methods of the other, so both sides can have grounds for discussion. It's the first time in years that we're seeing real conversation about women as deacons. According to Zagano, the Vatican regards the question of women deacons as still being under study and review. If they are willing to say publicly that it's an open question, then conversations can actually lead to mutual learning and real change. I liked the book very much, but I like even more the way it's having a real effect on the way people think and talk about the question, and the way people are willing to discuss it frankly and fairly. Good for Zagano! I wish we had more writers like her.

Rating:
Summary: Clear, readable, trustworthy
Review: If you are looking for a book trashing everything about the Catholic hierarchy and its traditions, this is not the book for you. The author suggests that you don't have to go outside the tradition to find a place for women as deacons, because the most faithful response to tradition is to have women serving in the diaconate. Unlike so many people claiming to write about the Catholic Church, the author is a real authority on the matter and has written on women deacons for a number of religious journals. This book should be a manifesto of sorts for anyone interested in what ministry in the church means, but this manifesto discusses, it doesn't shout. Think of it as the Common Sense of the women's movement within the church.

Rating:
Summary: Superb considerations
Review: The ordination of women to the priesthood is a hotly debated issue within the Catholic Church and is currently banned according to church teaching. Ms. Zagano limits the presentation of her information to argumentation concerning the ordination of women to the diaconate, and has developed some compelling issues for serious consideration by the Catholic faithful, Catholic church hierarchy and non-Catholics struggling with the acceptance of female ministers.

Rating:
Summary: Challenging vision for the future of the Church
Review: This book is very challenging. The cover promises a book about women's ordination as Catholic deacons, and the book delivers on that promise. But it's not written in the usual prophetic tone of books like this. At first I found the highly logical tone a little heavy. Then I became fascinated by the argument. Zagano has really uncovered a *lot* of interesting information about the rules for ordination, the history of ordination, and other details that most books don't provide. For anyone wanting a full range of discussion about the place of women in the Church, I'd recommend reading this book alongside a more prophetic book like Elizabeth Johnson's She Who Is. They form sort of bookends for highly intelligent and informed discussions about the future of the church.

Rating:
Summary: Challenging vision for the future of the Church
Review: This book is very challenging. The cover promises a book about women's ordination as Catholic deacons, and the book delivers on that promise. But it's not written in the usual prophetic tone of books like this. At first I found the highly logical tone a little heavy. Then I became fascinated by the argument. Zagano has really uncovered a *lot* of interesting information about the rules for ordination, the history of ordination, and other details that most books don't provide. For anyone wanting a full range of discussion about the place of women in the Church, I'd recommend reading this book alongside a more prophetic book like Elizabeth Johnson's She Who Is. They form sort of bookends for highly intelligent and informed discussions about the future of the church.