Divinity and Diversity: A Christian Affirmation of Religious Pluralism

Rating:
Summary: The one and the many
Review: Marjorie Hewitt Suchocki challenges the old assumptions of religious pluralism on many levels in her text, 'Divinity and Diversity: A Christian Affirmation of Religious Pluralism.' As she states in the preface, once upon a time religious diversity in America largely extended to the different varieties of Protestant churches, and the one Catholic church (and, maybe, if the town was large enough, a Synagogue). As Judeo-Christian thought shares a common history (if not always a happy one), the pluralistic aspect didn't involve much more than looking beyond various shades of gray. Today's situation is vastly different, with the number of world and home-grown religions in many communities reach double or even triple digit proportions.

Suchocki asks the question, how do we deal with this phenomenon as Christians? Through various discussions of creation, radical incarnation, and the image of God in Godself, Suchocki argues that both the created world and God call for pluralistic understanding. The world was not created in a monotone manner - there was diversity from the very start. God in Godself is not monotone, either - the doctrine of the Trinity is used to explore the relationship of diversity within divinity, as a model for there being unity and diversity held in creative tension. Suchocki's treatment of the Reign of God is as a model for appreciating and protecting the 'stranger in the gates', as that stranger includes everyone in creation.

Various theologians (Rahner, Tillich, Kung, etc.) have sought to preserve both the primacy or normativity of Christianity while respecting the values of other religions. Scholars and philosophers beyond the strict discipline of theology (Troeltsch, Hick, etc.) tried to explore 'grand unification theories' or historical underpinnings that might make Christianity a relative commodity. Suchocki lays out four responses to the issue: exclusivism, inclusivism, pluralism, and transformation. Being a process theologian, Suchocki will of course opt for the final option - transformation. Using process ideas and tools, Suchocki explores the underpinnings of current thought religious and beyond to draw together a theology of diversity.

Suchocki concludes with a look at salvation and mission, and calls upon Christians to adopt in the twenty-first century world and beyond a new model of mission, that of friendship. 'Friendship requires forthrightness about who we are, and an eagerness to listen to who the other is.' Friends do not force or coerce, but they can and do share. Friends discuss, and often persuade. This draws us into the peaceable kingdom of God.

For those who subscribe to the framework of process theology, this book is a wonderful excursion into the topic of pluralism. Not definitive and doctrinaire, it instead invites readers to continue the process of discernment of the issues of pluralism with questions at the end of each chapter, and various pieces of poetry, lyric or narrative story to spur the thinking on a different plane.

For those who are not familiar or not comfortable with process theological ideas, this book presents a challenge to look at the issues of exclusivity, inclusivity and pluralism in a new way, and to explore what transformation might be like. Perhaps some of the ideas found herein may also fit other theological frameworks, at least as food for thought.

Rating:
Summary: A "Christian" affirmation of anti-Christian thought.
Review: That's what it really is. I recommend reading Gordon Clark, Vincent Cheung, and Carl Henry instead.