Heirs Of The Fisherman: Behind The Scenes Of Papal Death And Succession

Rating:
Summary: Good for the mind, good for the funny bone.
Review: "Heirs of the Fisherman" was a pleasure to read, both for its intellectual and entertainment and value. In fact, I am torn over whether I like the fact that almost exactly half the book is appendices and notes, since those provide a great body of reference material for my library, or whether I would prefer sacrificing such facts for more stories from the history of the papacy. Any narrative that includes such characters as Charles the Fat, Stephen III (IV) through Stephen IX (X), and various "antipopes" can't fail to amuse. Anyone who has even a touch of a morbid curiosity will savor Pham's outline of the established protocol at the pontiff's passing as well as his detailed accounts of what caused each pope's death. No one will be able to close this book in the middle of his retelling how one quack completely bungled both the final days and embalming of a recent Pope, nor will they be able to turn their eyes from tales of cadavers being fished out of rivers or exhumed during various renovations. For those who have a fascination with pomp and royalty, Pham's attention to the details of each person's official title and the meaning of various symbols and gestures will delight. I myself am trying to memorize the nine titles of Pope himself, something to bring up at the next dull party. Pham's book is a serious one, though, and devout Catholics who read this book should stand in awe of the orderly nature of current papal proceedings relative to past anarchy, the vast stretch of history embodied in the workings of the Vatican, and the profound mystery of Jesus' legacy. Likewise, those readers who have no relationship with Catholicism but recognize the real power wielded by the Pope and the non-trivial nature of naming his successor will receive a rich education in this process and its history. Pham's book is a must-have companion for the moment this event is broadcast into our homes again on live television.

Rating:
Summary: A Much Needed Resource
Review: For most Catholics - to say nothing of non-Catholics - the world of the Vatican is shrouded in mystery. Ironically, it becomes even more secretive just when it receives the most attention during the period between the death of one pope and the election of another. Even professional observers are generally at a lost given the arcane way that clerical world operates. Now John-Peter Pham, a former insider in this strange world, lifts the veil ever so slightly, presenting a balanced, historical perspective on events that will be closely followed by millions. This long overdue account will be the resource as the days draw near when John Paul II will meet his Maker and all the camera lenses of the world will focus on the Eternal City.


Rating:
Summary: Provocative...
Review: I'm not sure I agree with all the author's conclusions, but he writes well and his work is definitely provocative. It certainly deserves more careful attention than some of the readers have given it, especially the predictably hypocritical self-appointed defender of Catholicism who hides behind the name of a dead cardinal ("F.X. Nguyen van Thuan") to throw ad hominem attacks at the author rather than have to intellectual courage to engage the argument. But then again, the author predicted as much.

Rating:
Summary: The History We Didn't Get in Catechism Class
Review: More than the story of what happens when the pope dies, Pham has written a dramatic telling of the history we didn't get in catechism class. Here it all laid out: holy popes, sinful popes, greedy popes, political popes, courageous popes, even possibly a few actively homosexual popes. Having been brought up with the idea that all churchmen were good and roughly disabused of that notion by the scandals of recent years, it's refreshing to read a history of the Catholic Church that doesn't whitewash, but accepts the reality of human nature as both noble and ignoble.

While the second half of the book is a virtual reference library, the first half is a very accessible narrative that ought to be read by every Catholic who wants to know the history of his or her church as it is in all its humanness.

Rating:
Summary: History and More
Review: Pham manages the amazing feat of compressing nearly two millennia of historical complexity into an easily accessible read while sacrificing neither the narrative thread nor the overarching themes - a rare accomplishment in any historical field, much less the minefield of church history. Even more amazingly, he manages to maintain a balance, joining neither the shrill critics of the Roman papacy nor its amen chorus of apologists. This book is recommendable to all audiences, Catholic and non-Catholic, liberal and conservative, scholar and lay. I predict this book is destined to be "the" spectator's guide as Pope John Paul II's days near their end and the world once more focuses on the mysterious rituals that will play themselves out in the Vatican.

Rating:
Summary: Don't Miss the Point of this Excellent Book
Review: Readers shouldn't miss the point of this excellent book, something I'm afraid the other reviewers on this site have missed. Yes, the Catholic Church, past and present, has consisted of both saints and sinners. For every Mother Teresa of Calcutta who selfishly works for the poor and downtrodden for the sake of the Kingdom of God, there's a Cardinal Law of Boston willing to betray the young and innocent for the sake of the House of Mammon. On that much I - and every right thinking Catholic - agree with the previous reviewers. And, yes, while Pham's book duly recounts its share of shady clerical dealings, that's not the point of his book. Hence, I hope this book doesn't get torn in shreds in some sort of tug-of-war between fractious Catholics. The true point of this fine work of scholarship is to present, truthfully, objectively, and with great precision and balance, a complex history that has never been adequately recounted, much less in such accessible terms. It does so admirably to both academic and general readers. Kudos to the author and, please, for goodness' sake, leave the intramural polemics aside.

Rating:
Summary: An Indispensable Reference Despite the Flaws
Review: The author has carefully gathered a prodigious amount of historical material - much of it inaccessable to all but a few polyglots, some of it entirely inaccessable because of the sources in the church hierarchy or archives. While his presentation of all this raw matter and, above all, the length of this work are not the most felicitous, there is no doubt that this book is destined to be the indispensable reference. Down the road others will perhaps produce out of this mass one or more reader-friendly volumes, but they'll all have to start with this foundational work.

Rating:
Summary: Informative and Subtly Provocative
Review: The reviewers on the dust jacket are right. Not only is this book "very readable," but it's the "most complete one volume explanation" of the obscure topic of how popes have been chosen. All that is enough to make this book a worthwhile read. However, I think there's more to this insider's guide. While the author doesn't come out and say it, there is a provocative conclusion to be drawn from his detailed description of the papacy's historical imperfections: The institution itself needs to be radically reformed in order to tap back into its spiritual roots and to keep in sync with its faithful. Maybe the author is too diplomatic to say it, but the conclusion is obvious from his fascinating narrative.

Rating:
Summary: Disappointing
Review: This book is brimming with details, sources, stories, tables, long quotations, and speculation about past popes and present crises. It surveys Vatican diplomacy internationally, with a wide angle lens on the third world. All of this sounds very promising, yet readers are confronted by a prolix style that forces them to wade through dense prose and tediously prolonged narratives. Perhaps we've been spoiled by the insight and readability of John Allen. In any case, this book attempts too much. Readers quickly suspect Pham of posturing for expert-status and media attention, which is bound to come on the heels of the death of the presently ailing pope. If that is his intention, however, this book falls way short. What is the problem? It is hard to say for sure. My impression is that Pham, like many other young authors who are also academics, has tried to force two books into one: the first is geared at a popular level, brimming with secrets and insider gossip, undoubtedly designed to draw the media limelight; the second aims much higher, with the scholarly apparatus to impress his senior colleagues and tenure committee, by resorting to seven appendices, hundreds of endnotes, and an overweight bibliography. Unfortunately, the end result is a profound disappointment, for both groups.

Rating:
Summary: A Fascinating Historical and Political Analysis
Review: When Pope John Paul II dies, the election of his successor will have a tremendous impact not only on the more than one billion Catholics around the world, but perhaps even more far-reaching impact on the rest of the world than many analysts appreciate. Not only will the next Pope lead his coreligious, but he will have a significant role to play on the world stage. Despite this import, the way that the Roman Catholic Church goes about selecting its head are a mystery to most outsiders - and probably the majority of its own members.

Consequently, I am delighted that John-Peter Pham has written a book that, prescinding from the purely spiritual internal matters that are not the province of outsiders like me, presents a fascinating history of this electoral process and a thoughtful analysis of its current political dynamics. In this light the best part of the book is, in my opinion, the middle section where the author takes the reader through the conclave process step by step and gives fascinating historical anecdotes to illustrate his points. It's first rate political writing.

My only criticism of this excellent book is that its length - the professional reviewers are more than correct in noting that it will be the definitive work on this subject - may be daunting to many readers and the scholarly apparatus (seven appendices plus notes and bibliography) may be overwhelming.