<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Little Truth, but much warmth
Review: Although this book is sweet, it is not plausible what happens in the end. The book creates a setting for a young boy who is not able to talk, who is suddenly able to speak after six years of silence. The book portrays a Christmas story. I would not use this in my classroom, only because it is so unreal. Being a special education major has made me see that a book about a child with a disability needs to be straight forward. These children are just like anyone else. This book, however, does not show that and seems unreal.
Rating: 
Summary: I bought 8 copies for friends
Review: this book has been an annual christmas favorite with my 11 children. It teaches a strong message of patient waiting for prayers to be answered.The young boy is unable to speak but through his father learns how to love others as the Savior would. The story of the Nativity is acted out through a young couple in need on Christmas Eve . Because of faith and the Fathers concern for others two Christmas miracles happen in the valley that year. A great book to teach others to remember Him at Christmas time.
Rating:
Summary: Family Favorite
Review: This book is a family favorite. We read it aloud nearly every Christmas, along with "A Christmas Carol," "Gift of the Magi" and "Whistlin' Dick's Christmas."
I can never read it without choking up, and my kids end up finishing it for me. A real heart-warmer.
Rating:
Summary: Family Favorite
Review: This book is a family favorite. We read it aloud nearly every Christmas, along with "A Christmas Carol," "Gift of the Magi" and "Whistlin' Dick's Christmas."
I can never read it without choking up, and my kids end up finishing it for me. A real heart-warmer.
Rating:
Summary: I bought 8 copies for friends
Review: this is a great story .... I read it to the Rotary Club members several years ago and all felt the Spirit of Christmas.
Rating:
Summary: A gentle Christmas story.
Review: This is such a gentle, old-fashioned little book that it is a small miracle it's still around. It's about Jamie, a mute boy who lives with his sisters and widowed father in the hollows of Appalachia. The boy feels like he can't do anything and isn't special in any way, until Christmastime, when a teacher offers him a chance to be a shepherd in the school Christmas pageant. This is the most exciting thing that has ever happened to him. But then the pageant is cancelled because of a blizzard, destroying his dream. In the end, a poor, traveling couple appear. The woman is about to have a baby, and they are looking for any place, even a barn, to spend the night, but so far no one has had any room for them (Sound familiar?) Jamie's family gives them shelter, the woman has her baby, and finally Jamie gets his chance to be a shepherd -- he shows up in costume to bring the new baby a gift, and to speak his very first words. A Christmas miracle! One of the things I love most about this book is the fact that Jamie is far from a perfect little boy, but the author obviously loves him and makes us love him and recognize that his anger and tantrums come from frustration over his handicap. No one yells at Jamie and tells him to behave. They find ways to help him behave. There is a Christian spirit of love and generosity coursing through Rebecca Caudill's portrait of this child. An earlier reviewer was offended by how "unrealistic" the ending seemed. I don't think that's really true. Early in the book, Jamie's father talks to a doctor, who tells him that Jamie is physically capable of speaking, but he needs help learning to do so, help the family can not afford. Jamie's inability to speak seems to be more a matter of trauma (his mother died giving birth to him) than anything physical, and so it does not seem remotely unrealistic for him to be healed when something in his life gives him a sense of importance. He simply has to speak to this miraculous child! But more than that, this is a Christmas story. And if we can't make room in a Christmas story for miracles, when can we?
<< 1 >>
| 
