Rating: 
Summary: chasing vermeer
Review: "On a warm October night in Chicago, three deliveries were made in the same neighborhood. A plump tangerine moon had just risen over Lake Michigan. The doorbell had been rung at each place, and an envelope left propped outside."
Is it a coincidence that Ms. Hussey, the sixth-grade teacher at University School, challenges her class to think about letters that changed lives? This book is filled with coincidences, ones that sixth-graders Petra Andalee and Calder Pillay think may not be coincidence.
Why do the pentomino pieces that Calder carries seem to give him messages? How is it that Calder has a box with a reproduction of Vermeer's The Geographer that also hangs in the home of Mrs. Louisa Sharpe, whose book by Charles Fort Petra has found at Powell's Books, and why does Petra dream about Vermeer's Lady Writing? Is there any connection with the theft of that painting from the Art Institute of Chicago, and what about the odd things Calder's friend Tommy writes to him about in a pentomino-based code?
Described by the publisher as "a puzzle, wrapped in a mystery, disguised as an adventure, and delivered as a work of art", this "children's book" delighted this adult. Truly about the importance of seeing things new ways, reminding one of Holmes' comment, "you see, Watson, but you do not observe", Chasing Vermeer will have you looking at the world, at patterns, at coincidence in ways you never did before.
And there really is a puzzle for you to solve, hidden in Brett Helquist's black-and-white chapter illustrations. (You can go to the book's website for the solution if you want, but it's much more fun to figure it out on your own.)
This book had the extra attraction for me of being set in my neighborhood. It was great fun to have part of it take place at one of my favorite used book stores, and to know which buildings Balliett renamed. It was a bit of a shock, though, to look at the map in the front of the book and find that a church has been replaced by a Post Office, and that some other landmarks seem to have disappeared!
Rating: 
Summary: Paintings were never so mysterious!
Review: Balliet writes of Ms. Hussey's teaching: "This year was beginning to feel either like something very right or very wrong--it was hard to tell which." My experience reading "Chasing Vermeer" felt remarkably similar. Unfortunately, a story which at times felt so right was steered off course by endless, muddled coincidences leading to an improbable, bolt-from-the-Blue resolution. Balliett's writing, like Ms. Hussey's teaching, follows the formula of "we're-in-this-together-and-it-might-be-dangerous." Indeed. Dangerously disappointing.
Rating:
Summary: Mystery and Discovery
Review: CHASING VERMEER is the delightful first book by Chicagoan and former Lab School teacher, Blue Baliett. The plot revolves around the growing friendship of sixth graders Petra and Calder as they work together to solve the mystery of, A Lady Writing, a Vermeer painting stolen en route the Chicago's Art Institute. Baliett creates children who are unashamedly eccentric and intelligent and are multi-ethnic in way that seems natural and uncontrived. Calder keeps pentominoe tiles (tiles in a variety of shapes that all include 5 squares) in his pocket and Petra connects words and circumstances. The story will draw younger readers in by its mysterious plot and the opportunity to do a little code breaking of their own to translate letters Calder receives from his absent best friend. It is the kind of book that might draw students into and interest in art, math and logic and could be used by an enterprising teacher to discuss all three. The resolution of the tale feels a bit sudden but is not unsatisfying.The use of Chicago and Hyde Park landmarks is particularly delightful (the names of some of the buildings on the University of Chicago campus have been changed). It is clear that illustrator Brett Helquist (Known for the images he created for the Lemony Snicket books) visited or had pictures of the lovely Hyde Park architecture to work from as some of the illustrations closely match buildings in the neighborhood, a nice detail for Chicagoans. Helquist's drawings provide an additional layer to the story as they also contain a code for readers to solve. CHASING VERMEER is a tale of mystery and discovery that children of many ages will enjoy and I look forward to seeing more work by Baliett in the future.
Rating:
Summary: Finding Vermeer
Review: Chasing Vermeer was an excellent mystery book. I enjoyed reading this book because the main characters were close to my age and it was suspenseful. The tow main characters, Calder and Petra were veryi interesting. Before this Vermeer mystery, they had never been friends and hardly spoke. While they were solving this mystery the became very good friends. They also used their combined knowledge to figure out clues and hints. This book demonstrates that two minds are better than one. The twists and turns of the plot make the book a page turner.
Rating:
Summary: "NOT ON EVERYONE'S 'V' LIST ??"
Review: Here is a book heralded by much publicity; one to put on your "Vermeer List" ... It will appeal to young mystery readers & kids who relish being considered 'above & beyond' the generic middle school student. This has the lure of PENTOMINOES (for a pronunciation aid, think "dominoes") which are diagrammed in the book and even avaiilable to *move* on your computer screen after accessing the website given in the book ... plus the challenge of clues encoded in the illustrations. The hero Calder invents a secret code based on the above, and his new friend Petra discusses happenings that may or may not be coincidences. In a book full of clues I wonder whether the author is dropping hints that a future book may revolve around the art of Alexander Calder and/or the artifacts of Petra, ancient city in Jordan. I was hoping Balliett's convoluted tale(as all good mysteries are?) would involve some action inside Chicago's ART INSTITUTE but perhaps in the future the author will use that setting, with a mystery about the unforgettable Chagall stained glass. This book could open up discussions about art critics and art history *experts* ~ also fads in all the necessities of life, including art. The young people are students at the Univ. of Chicago's lab school, where they have an open-minded but nervous teacher; also in a 'leading role' is an elderly eccentric neighbor. The star, of course, is the painting "A LADY WRITING" by Johannes Vermeer. It disappears between the National Gallery in D.C. and Chicago. Mysterious letters are delivered and demands made. Your reading will speed up with the chase scenes. All ages are involved as players in this drama and that may ensure an audience of a wide age range. REVIEWER MCHAIKU predicts good fun for readers in the 4th-8th grade range, more discussion in classrooms & increased sales of Pentominoes ~ ~ & some of these are definitely works of ART !
Rating:
Summary: Good Reading for Ages 9-12
Review: I you love mysteries and enjoyed "From the Mixed up Files..." and "Nancy Drew," then you will like Chasing Vermeer. Two 6th graders join forces to solve the mystery of a stolen painting. Using their unique perspective of childhood, they uncover clues that has left the FBI stumped. This book also features some special illustrations that give clues not included in the text. Wild Bill recommends this book to any 9-12 year old, as well as other mystery classics such as Holes, Something Upstairs, and Abby and the Bicycle Caper.
Rating:
Summary: Chasing Vermeer
Review: Petra and Calder are ordinary sixth graders at University School. They don't know each other very well. When the famous Vermeer painting, A Lady Writing, is stolen, they work together to find the thief and where it is hidden. Using Calder's pentominoes and Petra's smart brains, the place of the painting becomes clear. During their journey, Petra and Calder become very good friends. This book is very adventurous and has dangerous parts, but that makes the book even more exciting. Chasing Vermeer and The Da Vinci Code are similar, but this book is better. I highly recommend it!
Rating:
Summary: It's that good.
Review: Secrets, lies and mysteries surround the work of one of the greatest artists of all time. Moonlit chases, hidden hiding places, and even a secret code help to solve the mystery. Is this the new sequel to THE DA VINCI CODE? Nope --- it's an equally entertaining novel for younger readers. CHASING VERMEER encourages kids to use all their creativity and problem-solving skills to tackle a real-life mystery surrounding the elusive painter Johannes Vermeer. Calder Pillay and Petra Andalee are both a little odd. Their intellectual curiosity and their unique hobbies fit right in, though, with their eccentric families and with their creative classmates at the University of Chicago Lab School. When three mysterious letters show up in their neighborhood and seem linked to the theft of a famous Vermeer painting, a chain of coincidences brings Calder and Petra together to help solve the crime. First-time author Blue Balliett seems to enjoy playing with coincidences, both plausible and far-fetched, and the theme of chance and coincidence cleverly runs through the novel. The novel, with its high-profile crime of a well-known painting (secretly reproduced on the book underneath the dust jacket), also seeks to inspire young people to appreciate art as both dynamic and relevant to their lives. "Children were thinking about Vermeer, too. They were comparing, writing, and visiting museums with friends. Many said that they hadn't realized how cool old pictures could be." The novel's illustrations breathe almost as much life into the book as the text does. Illustrator Brett Helquist (best known for illustrating Lemony Snicket's Series of Unfortunate Events) includes a full-page illustration for each chapter. Pay attention! Some of the drawings reveal a secret that careful readers can help uncover. With its emphasis on puzzle-solving, CHASING VERMEER is reminiscent of classic novels like THE WESTING GAME. Its focus on connections and coincidences will remind many of HOLES, and its art-related mystery calls to mind FROM THE SECRET FILES OF MRS. BASIL E. FRANKWEILER. In other words, CHASING VERMEER deserves a spot alongside many well-loved children's books. It's that good. --- (...)
Rating:
Summary: More accurate than The Da Vinci Code
Review: This may not be The Da Vinci Code for kids, because it seems that the scholarship and research in Chasing Vermeer are more accurate than that in The Da Vinci Code. However, it's a clever marketing technique, and it seems to be working. Having read The Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew, The Boxcar Children, and all sorts of "simpler" mystery novels as a child, this really was refreshing. I wish something like this had been around (or that I had known of it) when I was in 6th grade. Even for an adult, it's an interesting, provocative work, with excellent pacing and sure handed writing. And any book that increases interest in art, thinking, or ideas has automatically hit a home run for me. Aside from the terrific storytelling and infectious plotting, I was very intrigued by the two main characters. Both are "hybrids" - a far cry from the typical Caucasian heroes we see everyday. Bravo to the author for the varied ethnicity! It's also a pleasure to read a book written "in" Chicago. Too many novels take place in New York, or L.A., and believe me - Chicago is culturally rich enough to support many more stories of this nature. The hidden clues were fun to figure out. I've never had much of a brain for puzzles, so even one aimed at kids between the ages of 9 and 12 challenged me. It took me a while to puzzle the clues out, and when I did, I discovered that there isn't only one solution! There are two, equally valid solutions - the one on the website, and the one I found. And yes, there really are two - even though I don't possess a proclivity for this sort of thing. I'm already anxiously awaiting Ms. Balliett's next book. As she is a teacher in the Hyde Park area of Chicago (which is as rich and culturally diverse as it gets here), I hope to see even more of this magnificent city!
Rating:
Summary: Something for everyone
Review: What a fun mystery. There seems to be something for everyone.It has secret codes, mathematical puzzles (pentominoes), a dash of art history and good characters. There is even a coded message/puzzle in the Bret Helquist illustrations. Codes are always interesting to kids. I think this book will be very popular with middle grade readers. I can see Calder and Petra collaborating on future mysteries. Kids who enjoyed The Mysterious Matter of I. M. Fine by Diane Stanley, will be happy to have a new and interesting mystery to read.
|
