PT 109 : John F. Kennedy in WWII

Rating:
Summary: How John F. Kennedy became a war hero
Review: "PT 109: John F. Kennedy in WWII" was first published in 1961, after Kennedy took office. But I first read this book at that end of that decade, when the Second World War and the New Frontier had given way to the Vietnam War and Sex, Drugs and Rock-n-Roll. John F. Kennedy always pointed out that he only became a war hero because the Japanese happened to sink his boat. Robert J. Donovan's book continues this practice of letting people other than Kennedy tell the story of his heroism. That heroism comes out as much in the fact that the second born son of one of the richest men in America not only volunteered for military service but decided to serve on those fragile little PT boats, as what happened when PT 109 was sliced in half by a Japanese destroyer in August 1943. Ultimately, the parts of Donvoan's book that deal with Kennedy's war experiences before and after the loss of his boat are equally interesting and serve as a reminder that heroism exists in the less spectacular efforts of men at war. This is a worthwhile story even if the man did end up being elected President. Donovan tells his story as a historian, not a hero-worshipper, which is as appropriate to telling this tale as it is effective.

Rating:
Summary: Classic American History!
Review: As Daniel Schorr in the new forward to this book suggests, World War 2 brought out the best in many men, and the ones who manned the motor torpedo boats were among the bravest, setting out in small plywood boats to fight an enemy in often large ships. The ordeal that Kennedy and his crew went through after PT-109 was destroyed is a story of courage that will last the ages. It is obvious that Robert Donovan was very careful to get the facts straight as he wrote this book, it is a great war story. For me it was a page turner, written in an easy to read, flowing style. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this, a gem of a book about a small piece of American history, a fascinating account indeed. Kennedy is portrayed, and rightly so, as a compassionate and intelligent young man.

In a very fine afterword to this 40th anniversary edition, Duane Hove give us additional details of Kennedy's military service, and also interesting text on the history of the PT boats before, during, and after the war, and also where you can see PT boats on display today, only a few of these magnificent boats remain with us.

Rating:
Summary: The writing is bland but the story is incredible
Review: Human beings are capable of incredibly noble acts when they are faced with the most terrifying circumstances. Such was the case with Lt. John F. Kennedy in command of PT 109 in the South Pacific during WWII. Faced with the alternative of action or death he rose to the occasion and was able to save the lives of his shipmates through great physical trauma and hardship.

Without going into the details of the incidents described, I would merely say that this is a good example of what the best of us are capable of doing when forced to think and act or face death. If stories of this kind interest you, this book will gratify your desires.

Rating:
Summary: great to see this new edition
Review: I was about 10 when the Saturday Evening Post ran a serialized version of Donovan's book. I'll never forget coming home from school the day the next edition was due, and dropping everything to read the next installment. With the passage of 40 years, and a rather older perspective, I can see that the book isn't perfect. Other reviews pick on the flaws. But it's great regardless. If you've never read the story, or like me want to relive a bit of the past, I recommend it highly.

Rating:
Summary: great to see this new edition
Review: I was about 10 when the Saturday Evening Post ran a serialized version of Donovan's book. I'll never forget coming home from school the day the next edition was due, and dropping everything to read the next installment. With the passage of 40 years, and a rather older perspective, I can see that the book isn't perfect. Other reviews pick on the flaws. But it's great regardless. If you've never read the story, or like me want to relive a bit of the past, I recommend it highly.

Rating:
Summary: John F. Kennedy and PT-109
Review: The 40th anniversary edition of PT-109 is an enjoyable read despite its many flaws. The story is true and sheds light on a young John Kennedey and a small part of naval warfare in the Pacific during WWII. Yet, Donovan's writing is simplistic at times. It is somewhat obvious that when he wrote this book he did so under the gun, or in other words under a very tight deadline, something he admits in the beginning of the text. Another point of contention is his glossed over view of Kennedy. I guess when he was writing of the then sitting president it was hard to escape, but Donovan praised Kennedy at virtually every turn of the page. Something that frankly gets in the way. It would have been better to tell the story of Kennedy -- flaws included. What young man at war is --or is-- expected to be perfect? Nonetheless, PT-109 is a worthy read for WWII buffs. If you enjoy reading about the war in the Pacific, this will help carry you through the other obvious downfalls of the book.

Rating:
Summary: John F. Kennedy and PT-109
Review: This was an exciting book on John F. Kennedy. It had lots of action, and suspence. John F. Kennedy had a lot of willpower, that was surprising. The bravery was outstanding in this story. If you like action and adventure I could not recommend a better book. I gave this book a five star rating, because it was truely a good book. Even though this was an old book, it was exciting. This would be a very good book for kids, because there was not a lot of hard words.