Rating: 
Summary: Obvious and not-so-obvious
Review: After one writes that, with the publication of Project Girl, Janet McDonald has thrust herself into the company of James Baldwin and Angela Davis, then one must consider what other associations suit the book. It is easy to read but so hard to forget. The writing is pellucid. One gets an incredible sense of who McDonald is and what she has been through, without detecting any of the artifice that people usually call "style". Her style is her voice, simple as that. McDonald's book, a memoir, in coming out in the memoir-rampant post-Angela's Ashes era, has been criticized for being just another up-from-the-bottom story. Yet Frank McCourt himself wrote that Project Girl "should be placed on all high school and college reading lists and offered to anyone looking for a book beautifully written." Leafing through Project Girl for one more of the countless times I have searched it for some morsel of understanding or attitude, I discover once again that each sentence is no more and no less than a small portion contributing to the entirety of this beautiful, difficult, yearning story. It does not matter that the story is true. That it is true should make us shudder. But how do we Americans classify the book? McDonald lives in Paris now, and she might shudder to know. Project Girl does not rest on the shelf. It sticks to the mind. You can't shelve it. Every time you think you have the story down ("okay, she grew up in the Farragut Houses projects in Brooklyn, got it, terrible things there, strong family, okay-this experience-some racism, off to college" etc.) a sticky part in the story such as her brief foray into the world of the child prophet Guru Maharaj Ji will throw you off. She is an incredible person and her genius just to pull herself up time after time-a necessary genius to the chronically voiceless-is, if only commended and admired, the victim this time of condescension. It is as difficult to say what this book really is as it is difficult to deal with the seething, subtle and not-so-subtle problems that are chronicled within it. But it is also warm, forgiving and funny. It will resonate with the reader's experiences long, long after s/he has put it down.
Rating:
Summary: Projectgirl by Janet McDonald
Review: As a member of McDonald's audience, I have realized, since reading this book, that its title may be ambiguous to some, if not, most. She is not a project manager climbing a corporate ladder. Nor is she a project, a work in progress, though aren't we all, really? McDonald is a product, a complex survivor, of the Farragut housing projects in Brooklyn, New York. One of seven children whose parents migrated north from Alabama in the 1940s to stake their claim to some small part of the Promised Land, McDonald is the only one who found the will, means, and drive to navigate prestigious educational systems at Vasser, NYU, Cornell, and Columbia, ultimately, to obtain a law degree and practice in her field in Paris, France. Not bad for a projectgirl, now is it? Perhaps the most compelling aspect of McDonald's memoir is the way in which she vascillates between elevating her deserved sense of self-esteem and sliding dangerously to depths of contemplated suicide; and the sea of confusion that surrounds her abilities to succeed and excel amid her siblings' sorrowful weaknesses and failures. McDonald tells her story with gripping honesty, transitioning to a journal-entry format after she is cursed by a traumatic, haunting, and life-changing event. As she struggles toward wholeness, her writer's voice comes full circle. From beginning to end, we follow the heroic arc of her life experience to date, rising and falling, sinking and swimming through it all, always right by her side.
Rating: 
Summary: Uncanny similarities
Review: I came across this book by chance and couldn't believe the number of similarities between the life stories of Janet McDonald and Debra Dickerson, author of _An_American_Story_. Both writers came from extremely humble beginnings and rose to great heights, both studied and mastered foreign languages, both were raped. The parallels go on and on. Ms. McDonald's story does an incredible job of illustrating how much of one's success in life is related to one's own hard work, and also to one's luck (her getting the job in Paris, for instance). This book should be required reading for everyone in public housing and/or those who are convinced that achievement is beyond them.
Rating:
Summary: Engrossing read
Review: I finished reading this book a few days ago and I am still feeling the after effects. It took me longer than usual to complete this book because it left me feeling depressed so I would put it away for a day or two. It seemed when the author took one step ahead, something would happen that would put her two steps behind. But I would get angry at her sometimes because as her mother said she had book smarts and brains but no common sense. I don't know if the maginitude of her intelligence (she qualified as a MENSA member) made it so she could not deal with mundane details. But I cannot blame the fact that she came from the projects for some of her trials and tribulations. As one previous reviewer said, Ms. McDonald had more going for her than alot of kids from her circumstances, namely an intact family with loving parents particularly a father who embraced education. How many kids from the ghetto could cut classes, use drugs, and have run-ins with the law and still graduate from ivy league schools and work for major law firms and fit in easily in Paris? Not many, I would think. But it would seem that she was doomed-- government set-ups, assault, etc. Some reviewers disparaged Gwendolyn Parker's "Trespassing: My Sojoun in the Halls of Privilege" (See my review)for having a smooth ride. Her story as an upper-middle class black women traveling down the some of the same roads as McDonald is a contrast but oh how similar. They both experienced racism in college and cooperate America. Though I was often frustrated with the author (I wonder if living in Paris now has vanished her guilt, anger, suicide, and homocidal urges) I gave this book five stars because it deserved it for it's insightful journey and the bravery the author has displayed that could have brought down Kennedy.
Rating: 
Summary: Project Girl is worth reading but it left me with questions.
Review: I just finished reading Project Girl. This book was very inspiring to me as a single mother, battling circumstances of poverty as well as my final year of law school. However, I believe that Ms. McDonald failed to consider one point. That is, the professional workforce includes a substantial number of African-American, first-generation, college graduates, with less impressive educational credentials and family support than what Ms. McDonald enjoyed. This demonstrates that "arriving," at least for African-Americans, does not depend exclusively on educational background but also, perseverance, know-how, and ambition. Yet, throughout her book, Ms. McDonald explained that she lacked these qualities. On Ms. McDonald's resume are a felony criminal conviction (based on her own confession), hospitalization in a mental institution, consistent poor college grades, a profound lack of interest in the law, and disdain for the legal profession. Thus, I can only guess that Ms. McDonald's educational and professional accomplishments are due to pure luck as there is no way that an individual, no matter their race, gender or economic status, having these experiences can become a New York corporate attorney in a high profile law firm as Ms. McDonald apparently did.
Rating:
Summary: Helpful for a White Country Girl
Review: I really enjoyed Janet McDonald's writing ability, and her story. This book is great for anyone who wants a better understanding of what it is like to be from the Projects, and raised my understanding of being a victim as well. BUT, I would not recommend this book for anyone who has been the victim of violence, and still has unfinished struggles - it's too real and to close to home.
Rating:
Summary: rollercoaster ride
Review: I'm not sure how to react to Project girl. I was torn between cheering the author's resilliance and smacking her upside the head for wasted opportunities. For reasons I can't figure out, I resented the way she appeared to bounce in out of colleges almost at will. Her emotional termoil is told from the inside; you can almost see the process. I felt that the ending was a bit rushed (wait - where's the rest?!!), but overall a very good read.
Rating:
Summary: Readable, compelling account of McDonald's struggle.
Review: Janet McDonald's book, Project Girl, is a wonderfully readable account of her youth and young adulthood as she travels from the projects in New York City to Paris, with many stops along the way. Written without sloppy sentimentality or maudlin self-absorption, the book details her development as a gifted child through the trials of family life and education as her intelligence opens exciting doors for her at the same time it separates her from her family and neighborhood. McDonald charts her own course through unknown territory, often quite painfully, writing with a wry, and sometimes dark, sense of humor and compelling passion. Easy to read, hard to put down, this is a perfect book for young women coming of age. For those growing up with lots of opportunities and support, it is an eye-opener of what life would be like without those gifts. For those struggling with race, poverty, or difficult families, it is an inspiration, based on the reality that you can fail, sometimes over and over, and still perservere until you reach a safe and happy place. I encourage everyone to read this remarkable book.
Rating:
Summary: Thrills, tears and inspiration
Review: Project Girl. There are millions of us, but very few will ever experience the convergences necessary to get our story in print. Some of that has to do with our rush to forget the trek from grits-to-Gucci, an understandable if sad price to pay for living life as a corporate makeover. But thank God, Janet MacDonald didn't forget a thing. And her buzz saw of a mind sent chips flying to hell and back to present us with a story so gripping, I often found myself holding my breath long after the sentence had ended. Even the most casual reader can understand this tale of wars: the one where Janet constantly squares off against her self; the one where she jousts interminably with the self she showed to others; the wars with forces beyond, as well as those completely within, her control. Sometimes vanished, sometimes victor, she never asks you to feel sorry for her even when she faces the horror every woman on earth lives in fear of. And, yet, the only time she sinks to a blame fest is when she repeatedly skewers some mental health practitioners of arguably questionable skill. PROJECT GIRL is a straight ahead rendering of one brilliant black woman's mottled life in these United States of America. And that is, perhaps, the most incredible gift of this outpouring: not MacDonald as Role-Model-for-All-Corporate Wannabes, not MacDonald as Queen-of-the-Up-by-My-Boostraps-Crew, not MacDonald as some Over-the-Rainbow-See-How-I-Slew-my-Demons-all-by-Myself, but MacDonald as human, flawed, honestly laying out a personal, story of race, gender, class, and, yes, politics. In fact, that's precisely how PROJECT GIRL escapes being "just a memoir." It is so refreshingly clear and purposefully disturbing as it peels back the layers of race, class, gender and power that make up all our daily life. By the time MacDonald is through with us, we are completely exhausted and all we did was watch. In the end, we have peeped the inner workings of a whole range of hallowed institutions--from the nuclear family, to wealthy college campuses, to elite workplaces, to the criminal justice system, to the mental health industry. MacDonald's is an irreverent, relentless, priceless eye. PROJECT GIRL is a triumphant beginning. The rest of this story has yet to be told and is definitely worth waiting for.
Rating:
Summary: a book every woman should read and pass on to a friend
Review: Sometimes a book comes along which speaks directely to you. You feel as though certain lines are written not to but about you. Janet McDonald's PROJECT GIRL is one of these books. The very personal account of her life, which allows the reader to trace a woman's painful and triumphant journey, includes simple passages which stirr up complex and tangled emotions in the reader. Being one of the priviledged white girls McDonald writes about in the first part of PROJECT GIRL I was at first scared that I wouldn't be able to relate to her experiences completely. But this book manages to cross over the very boundaries which it describes. If only more women posessed McDonald's couarage of sharing their stories, spoken loud and clear for the world to hear and recognize! Hers is the kind of book which carries with it the hope that one day we will all be brave enough to tell our stories. As McDonald's life demonstrates again and again, even the most devestating experiences can be overcome. This is the kind of book which one should give to mothers, girlfriends, and sisters. We all have dreams and nightmares which don't let us go. But Janet McDonald's PROJECT GIRL will wake you up and make you realize that you are not alone.
|
