The Ayn Rand Cult

Rating:
Summary: Ad Hominem 101
Review: Walker succeeds in making his point in spite of himself. That his only goal in writing this book was to show that Objectivism has become a cult is a little hard to believe given that most of the book consists of personal attacks on the people involved. He might as well have drawn some horns on the photo of Rand on the cover. However, I do believe the case has been clearly made, here and elsewhere, that it is a cult. Probably this has a lot to do with the fact that to almost all but the true believers the cultish quality of Objectivism is painfully obvious. Walker's viciousness throughout only works to destroy his credibility. His use of quotes from ex-objectivists, neo-objectivists, and current objectivists to support his claim, while at the same time using them against each other to question the credibility of all involved doesn't exactly make for a strong case either. A large group of liars spreading gossip about each other doesn't usually qualify as hard evidence. I found myself wondering quite a bit about Walker's history and possible connections to the movement. Who put the bee in his bonnett? Nevertheless, the book makes for a fascinating look at the Objectivist movement and the personalities involved, albeit a very biased look. If you hate Rand, you'll love it. If you're somewhat indifferent, as I am, you'll be entertained. If you're a true-believer...well, you've probably already been alerted to avoid this one.