The Sole Spokesman : Jinnah, the Muslim League and the Demand for Pakistan (Cambridge South Asian Studies)

Rating:
Summary: Mr Jinnah was a secularist
Review: Indeed, the premise of the book is correct, Mr Jinnah was a SECULARIST! However, by 1946, did he still want a unified India? I dont think so.

By the way, the guy who wrote the first review.. I am afraid, Bias aint gonna get you anywhere.

Rating:
Summary: Excellent book on the history of Pakistan
Review: This is a excellent book on the history of Pakistan. Ayesha Jalal has done her home work and has presented the facts in a very logical fashion. I find this book among the few honest assesment on India and Pakistan division.

Rating:
Summary: Attn Tom Greensburg
Review: You say Moderate and secular Congress :

I say : "Mahatma" Gandhi and "Pandit" Nehru? Is this secularism?

You say Poisonous fruit of their efforts "A Nuclear Rogue pakistan"

I ask you which country detonated the nuclear device first? Gandhi's so called secular India or the Nuclear Rogue Pakistan?

Kindly tell me where you acquires such biases... have you even tried to read the book? Have you read about Mr Jinnah? Why is it that people like yourself wish to propagate the same false myths again and again, and not salute people like Ayesha Jalaal who have done an extremely good job in bringing out the facts..

Ayesha Jalaal mentions a very important fact... the Muslim Extremists and fanatics like the Ahrar were actually in alliance with your Mr Gandhi and the "secular Moderate Congress Party". Indeed Gandhi brought all fundamentalists and religious fanatics together regardless of religion caste or creed. Truly secular!