Rating: Summary: More, More! Review: One of the best books on art in recent years, this little volume is packed with insight into the painting in question and a marvelous tale about the painting's subject. This book is a page turner in a different way from a suspense novel, yet the author engages you in the life of this girl to such an extent you must find out how it all ends. One of the most entertaining items I have read for some time. One can only hope this author is not done exploring the Dutch masters and perhaps other artists as well!
Rating: Summary: Vivid evocation of 17th century Netherlands Review: If words are like brushstrokes, then Girl With a Pearl Earring produces just the right touch to the canvas of Vermeer's city, its imagined inhabitants, and finally to the enigmatic Vermeer and his portraits. A story based on the imaginary servant girl in Vermeer's household and in the portrait who is unwittingly caught between the contrary whims of that household, the expectations of her society, and allowing a small space for her soul to flourish. If you only have time to read one book right now, make it this one.
Rating: Summary: Save your money ....buy another book Review: This book was a BIG disappointment.The author's depiction of seventeenth century Delft is interesting and it's decently written but her characters are one dimensional and oh so boring.The main character, Griet, is an oh so clever sixteen year old. She knows the BEST way to: perform every household chore; handle young children; manipulate lazy wives; grind paint for Vermeer; find a pawn shop; bargain with butchers, and fend off inappropriate sexual advances. She's a big snore. Vermeer is the artist incarnate burning with inspiration and passion but lacking any discernable personality - an ephemeral flame. If you like the following excerpts, this book is for you:"I should have begged him not to ruin me." (page 195) , "Never so much trouble with a maid before. Lord love us!" (page 149), "Just before I fainted I thought, I have always wanted to wear pearls." (page 201).
Rating: Summary: Absolutely wonderful Review: I loved this book--the spare prose, the lovely imagery, the compelling way the plot unfolded. I found it utterly charming, and unlike other historical novels, understated in a way that illustrates the writer's familiarity with the period but doesn't use pretentious prose to make her point. Bravo!
Rating: Summary: Poignant and beautifully written Review: I found this story to be very absorbing and wonderfully written. To fully enjoy this book, I recommend looking at Vermeer's work on the web since that will greatly enhance your appreciation for Ms. Chevalier's simply beautiful tale.
Rating: Summary: YOU KNOW THE STORY Review: Young pretty girl forced to toll unmercifully as a maid to support her destitute family in the home of a brooding artist. There's the jealous wife, bossy mother in law, nasty servants, lots of bratty kids, lecherous art patron, a little dilly dally with the butcher boy. This book was not as dark as some of the works of Vermeer and the writing extremely well done. Except for the little twist at the end, predictable but enjoyable to read.
Rating: Summary: WHAT WERE PEOPLES ATTITUDES IN 1664? Review: The author met her goal for me by creating a good story in an era foreign to us all. I thought the way of life then was expressed quite well and a touch of the differences between protestant and catholic was well done, though minor in the story. When a crisis in her life happened you surely wondered which which one she would take, though it was not difficult to determine beforehand. This was superior to "Hyacinth In Blue," another book about Vermeer that didn't do it for me.
Rating: Summary: Girl With a Pearl Earring Review: This book enabled me to do something I have wished to do for nearly thirty years: enter the house and the studio of the Dutch painter Johannes Vermeer of Delft. All the hopes I had for this book were realized. Ms. Chevalier has made good use of the limited sources available regarding this reticent 17th century artist who has left us little more in the way of information about himself beyond his magnificent and magnificently crafted paintings. Ms. Chevalier has woven a believable and entrancingly charming tale that brings to life the painter himself, his family, and the maid Griet. Vermeer is portrayed much as I always thought he might be, moving quietly in and out of the shadows of narrative -- a consummate craftsman, artist, and enigma. The drama unfolds in such a way as to captivate the reader and make us want to see what will happen next to Griet and what more we might learn about Vermeer, while preserving the quiet, myserious ambiance that imbues those wonderful and simple interior scenes, I have come to love. The story is a simple, domestic one, as befits the tone of much of the artist's work and will appeal most to those who are fascinated by Vermeer's presentation of ordinary people in their domestic environments -- a great departure from the epic religious and historic scenes which were the fare of nearly all artists prior to the seventeenth century. Yet, like the paintings with their subtle symbolic messages, the story Ms. Chevalier tells is universal and important to the human experience. Yet, I must confess that the greatest enjoyment for me in reading this book was re-entering that house and being with those people; seeing the artists studio, "touching" those familar studio props and "meeting" the models I've seen in quiet afternoon poses for so many years. Usually, a book I really like is a book I cannot put down. In this case I made myself put it down periodically in order to prolong the experience. Yet, when I was finished, I found that it still wasn't long enough. However, Ms. Chevalier has my heartfelt gratitude for providing me the time machine I've always wished for in order to enter that "View of Delft" and pass through the door of that wonderful house on the Oude Langendyck.
Rating: Summary: Great Read Review: I really liked this book. If you'd like a similar read, try I, Juan de Pareja . It's a young adult book that has won the Newberry award, but great for any age. It has the same artist- servant relationship motif.
Rating: Summary: A Too Perfect Girl Review: Although I was quite anxious to get my hands on this book, I must admit I came away disappointed. For me, Griet's perfection rendered her unbelievable. All men found her irresistably attractive; she worked very hard with no resentment and knew every trick doing whatever task she approached perfectly -- her wash was the whitest; she was an ace at bartering for the best cuts of meat; she intuitively understood the psyches of those who surrounded her; she ground the purest colors, and even knew better than Vermeer what a painting needed. It was just too much! Though I very much appreciate the inspiration for this book and the depiction of Delft in the time of Vermeer, his portrait depicts a girl with profound humanity, not the angel genius described in this book.
|