Rating: Summary: Yes its cliche but GIVE IT A BREAK Review: Sure, all you english know it alls can go off and tell us about how cliche the book is. You're completely right! The book is a total cliche, but not every single piece of literature must be bursting with new well thought out philosophical ideas and exciting new story lines. The kid wrote it when he was 15. 15! In my opinion that is an amazing thing to accomplish. You can't expect a Tolkien level book from a 15 year old kid who hasn't even been alive as long as most well known authors have been writing. Sure there are tons of ripped off names and ideas (i.e. Tronjheim. Ever heard of Trondheim, Norway?) but that does not make this a bad book! I personally like just sitting down to read an entertaining story, and this did just that. All you cynics need to calm down and appreciate the story for what it was written for. I doubt the author set out to change the world of Fantasty writing when he began this, and the book should be judged accordingly. In my opinion: not a waste of my time.
Rating: Summary: great effort! Review: Young Mr. Paolini has a bright future as a writer should he decide to take some formal instruction. While he is obviously blessed with a fertile imagination his prose are weak and descriptions need work. I am more surprised at a publisher such as Knopf for editing the work in this fashion and question whether this was a marketing experiment geared at young readers. Nonetheless, it should not be compared to the writing prowess of authors such as Rowlings or Dhal. It is just another episode of a Hercules-like adventure. A lot of fun, but I dare to see him study at college, then read him when he has a greater command of writing. Goodluck.
Rating: Summary: Its good, really good Review: I finished Eragon on Veteran's Day. We had off of school! Yeah! It is one of the best I have read in a long time! I am a big Robert Stanek fan and Eragon is just as good. I would give this book 5 stars any day. I personally didn't like Harry Potter but I would recommend it to Harry Potter fans and anyone who enjoys a good read. I would also recommend the books by Robert Stanek.
Rating: Summary: Entertaining Review: Christopher Paolini, I believe, has a bright future. His first book, "Eragon", is probably the best opening book written since "Magician" by Feist, offering really lovable characters, vast and still unexplored world, a classic struggle between Good and Evil, well-described battle scenes, challenging magic system and leaving the reader hungry for the next one. Well done, Chris.
Rating: Summary: All or Nothing Review: It's odd that the reviews of this book all seem to be either glowing praise with 5 stars, or complete disappointment (1 star).I'm about half way through this book, and let me tell you, absolutely nothing interesting has happened yet. Paolini's writing is full of promise, but in this book it is clumsy and boring. Character interaction feels forced, and there is no chemistry. The worst part is the pacing. This book is a terribly slow read. I cannot imagine the story needing to continue over a part II and part III. I will read the remainder of this book to see if it improves. But at this point, I have to admit, the positive reviews puzzle me. This book is not what those reviews promised it would be.
Rating: Summary: New fans of Saphira, Eragon and C. Paolini Review: I bought this book for my 13 year old son. He has devoured all the Tolkien, Rowling and McCaffrey, Pullman etc at our disposal. As usual, I read it too, what fun! The characters are well rounded and the pace is wonderful. If we were reminded of Middle Earth at times - all the better, as we felt we "knew" the landscape already. This is a wonderful story, we are looking forward to the sequel. Quite an accomplishment for such a young author. An inspiration to other young writers.
Rating: Summary: I think I'll like Eragon better than Harry Potter...... Review: What happens when you want to read something full of magic, but absolutely dislike Harry Potter books? Eragon is the solution. Being it full of magical tales to tell, Eragon, a poor farm boy finds a polished blue stone when hunting in dangerous woods and thinks it might be valuable. When he finds it hatches, it almost destroys his life a few months later. His uncle, the only person who looks after him is killed by the mysterious people who are looking for the egg. He goes on an adventure with a storyteller named Brom to hunt down the evil, but Eragon finds out a lot more than he wished too.. Pros -Action, and suspense to every chapter -The authors type of writing inspires - MAY TEACH YOU A LESSON IN LIFE.... -A teenager wrote the book, HOW FABULOUS Cons -The author explains too much of the gory scenes I give the book 5 stars because it is inspiring, action and suspense is included in every chapter, and a teenager wrote it. Most of all though, it is because it may teach you a lesson in life. This book is definetly better than Potter, because it is something different, and life doesn't always turn out well. Plus, what would an adult know about a teenagers life. I'm still trying to figure that out. I am waiting for the sequel, Eldest Inheritance II which comes out sometime in 2004. The reason, BECAUSE THE BOOK IS GOOD!
Rating: Summary: JORDAN Review: Eragon Book one of Inheritance is about this guy who happens to find an egg walking in the woods one day. It happens to be a Dragon egg. One day it hatches and Eragon touches it and a surging pain goes through his arm. Eragon dosen't know that his destiny is to become a Rider.
Rating: Summary: a good read Review: Eragon was a very good story and I will definitely read part two when it comes out. I think that it is great that a sixteen year old wrote this but don't consider it children's fiction. It was a little too violent for kids. You can tell that he is a big fan of Tolkien and I like stories in that vein too. It is not as much of a Lord of the Rings rip off as say Sword of Shannara but there are similarities in his world and Tolkien's. I do like the relationship between the boy and the dragon. It is a great concept. I do hope that Christopher Paolini isn't too busy promoting Eragon that he hasn't started part two!
Rating: Summary: Hotter than most veteran writers Review: This young man has the spirit of Anne mccaffrey flowing in him. I read a lot of books and a lot of garbage and this young man has incredible potential. I won't comment on the book cause you can tell from the editorial review what it is about. I can explain it no better. This young one is hot. I am waiting for eldest book 2 to come out, cause for a person of 15 years to what write what people twice his age do and not quite this good is sad!! Don't get me wrong I love my anne Mccaffrey I consider her one of the best writers. I just want it known that christopher paolini is hot young and coming up. This book WILL keep you interested. I give Chris mad props.
|