The Reaper

Rating:
Summary: A Slight Trying of the Patience
Review: 'The Reaper' is a very well-written book, not that long to read, and evokes its desired ambience of a quiet English village quite satisfactorily. The plot is well executed. It's the characters that did it in for me.

The book is not, in my estimation, a mystery, though that is where I found it at my local booksellers. There is murder and mischief aplenty, even some suspensful moments, but we know from the very outset whodunit. This puts it in the 'Columbo' league, where we know the identity of the killer, and the fun is supposed to be watching them squirm. While I enjoy that genre of suspense, it is not done as well as it could be in the case of 'The Reaper'.

The story concerns young and handsome Reverend Otis Joy, who has newly come to preside over St. Bartholomew's Church in Wiltshire , England. The first chapter shows him murdering Bishop Glastonbury, and the subsequent disposal of the body. There are certain mysterious elements regarding Joy's past which come up, but then they are discarded for a little too long before being picked-up later on in the novel. A young, unhappily married woman named Rachel Jansen attends Joy's congregation, and is in love with him (in her own convoluted way). Their relationship makes for the bulk of the story. I say "their relationship", whereas it is more Rachel's inner thoughts regarding the ever-murderous Reverend Joy.

And that is what bothered me the most about this book. There was no protagonist. No one to "root for". On one side we have Otis Joy, who murders people as though he were swatting flies, and then Rachel Jansen, who is overly-obsessed with the reverend to be of any sympathetic interest to the reader. She borders on being flaky, and I found it hard to readily embrace a book with a remorseless killer and an in-love flake as its protagonists. *This also, by the way, differs 'The Reaper' from being completely like a Columbo, as in Columbo, the star is the protagonist, the anchor to the ship, as it were. There really isn't such an anchor in this book.*

'The Reaper' does serve up a surprise or two (one very big one, as a matter of fact), and it is written well. I just wish that there had been a driving force of good somewhere in it - a Holmes, a Wimsey, a Poirot, a Marple, a Dalgliesh.... heck, even a Columbo.

Rating:
Summary: A great read for one and all
Review: I can only say that THE REAPER is a great fun thriller full of parallels and comedy.And I must mention "OJ" but read the book and you will see what I mean. Great characters and fun cheering for the wrong team. Peter's books are all brilliant and easy reads, you fall in love with his characters also, won't be able to guess what happens next. Many Turns and twists, plots and subplots as well as a giggle on every page. What more can you ask for when reading? I started this book at 8am and finished it at 8pm the same day, only stopping when my eyes needed a rest. In my opinion is a great book. ENJOY and thanks to Peter once again, I highly recommend BLOODHOUNDS

Rating:
Summary: Great fun
Review: The Reaper is a humourous, but elegantly written story of a homicidal rector who somehow secures the reader's approval while radically culling his flock in a Wiltshire village. His first (?) victim, Bishop Glastonbury, is found in a deserted quarry with a naughty girlie magazine close at hand. The Bishop's last telephone call was to a 'Miss Whiplash' hotline. Meanwhile, Otis Joy, the guilty rector, is disturbed by Rachel Jansen, a parishoner, as he parades around his home dressed only in an apron! Getting the picture?

This book is a great fun read as the bodies begin to pile up and the reader is the only one who knows who's doing it. There's no mystery involved - Otis Joy is guilty of more deaths than the bubonic plague. We even learn Reverend Joy's motives. What holds the reader's attention is the lasting question, will he be caught? People are getting suspicious, and tongues begin to wag. And, of course, there's Joy's possible relationship with Rachel Jansen after her husband suddenly 'dies'... Will it happen? Can it succeed?

My only reason for not giving 'The Reaper' a five star rating, is because I felt we weren't given quite enough characterization of the main roles. If there'd been a four-and-a-half button, I would have pressed it. Nevertheless, 'The Reaper' earned Peter Lovesey the Cartier Diamond Dagger award and should not be missed. His other books (over twenty of them) include 'Rough Cider' and 'The Vault' - also well worth space on your bookshelf.

Rating:
Summary: Top Notch!
Review: THE REAPER is one of the funniest novels I have read in a long time. Although it scarcely qualifies as a mystery (the only mystery is, "Will he get away with it?") the book certainly meets the highest standards for light well-crafted fiction with a lovely nasty streak. Be warned, however: it is impossible to put down.