The Sicilian

Rating:
Summary: A Little Disappointing
Review: This is a good book, but it does not measure up to the Godfather (what does?).
Salvatore Giulliano is an agressive young and very idealistic (and intelligent) young man who finds himself doing battle simultaneously with both the Italian government and the most powerful Don in Sicily. Giulianno's idealism (his desire to save his homeland) is very engaging and leads the reader to root for his success. However, his intelligence notwithstanding, Giuliano is far too wise for a man in his low to middle twenties, and he is far too perceptive of his place in the grand scheme of things. This takes away from what is an otherwise realistic story. Further, Puzo added too much "armchair psychology" of the kind where Don Corleone (in the Godfather)was able to percieve the true intentions of his friends and foes alike. It is just a little overdone and Giuliano is just a little too young to be so perceptive.

The cameo appearance of Don Coreleone makes for a nice ending, since true Puzo fans will be delighted to see their old friend once again. However, I must disagree with how Puzo portrayed the Don here (How dare I?). I believe the Don's admonition of Michael would have focused on family as opposed to self-interest. When you read the book you will see what I mean.

I did enjoy this book and I will read it again someday.

Rating:
Summary: A true story, Puzo shows his passion for MY land...
Review: This is the story of a legendary man which I should have learnt about at school since he personifies the true values and flaws of my country. The book reveals the origins of the criminal organisation and social phenomenon that is ruling the world and very sadly shows why that is never going to come to an end.
Deeply rich characters, charming descriptions, explains our society in a way I can hardly recall anyone doing in the recent past. Sequel to the Godfather? No, it provides the perfect background.
Brilliant job Puzo !


Rating:
Summary: Sadding
Review: While this book was great from beginning to end; I only read 1 other book from Mario Puzo the omerta but this is even better, the plot the detail in each way and the ending is the best. If you like any mystery I would recommend you get this book.