Madeline's Christmas

Rating:
Summary: A BIG disapointment
Review: I never read Madeline books as a child and was captivated by them when I started reading them to my child. I was very excited to make this book a part of my holiday book collection. However I should have read this one before buying!This one makes no sense, its hardly about Christmas at all and the usual charming rhymes are not there. Check this one out at the library before buying!

Rating:
Summary: A BIG disapointment
Review: I never read Madeline books as a child and was captivated by them when I started reading them to my child. I was very excited to make this book a part of my holiday book collection. However I should have read this one before buying!This one makes no sense, its hardly about Christmas at all and the usual charming rhymes are not there. Check this one out at the library before buying!

Rating:
Summary: The other reviewers missed the boat on this great book!
Review: It's not so much the story here as the activities! It has reuseable vinyl characters (like Colorforms) that kids can use to create their own stories--tons of games and holiday worksheets. I must disclose that I own a bookstore that stocks this title, but I am VERY selective about the items I stock--especially for kids. Enjoy!

Rating:
Summary: MADELINE'S CHRISTMAS DOESN'T LIVE UP TO BEMELMAN'S OTHERS
Review: Madeline's Christmas was a disappointment. Stick to the other Madeline tales!!

Rating:
Summary: Skip this one.
Review: Madeline, Madeline's Rescue, and Madeline and the Gypsies are all fine books, but Madeline's Christmas is a dud. It doesn't have the same cadence as the others, and the plot is not as appealing.