Rating: 
Summary: sad but great
Review: this book rocks! It's about Marty a boy who lives down south and
wants a dog. when he stumbles acros Shilo he's overwlemed. but when shilo's abusive owner won't give him to Marty, Marty will go to any lenths to get him back? Will Marty get Shilo or will HIS abusive owner Judd? AND then shilo is almost killed or is he dead you'll have to read to find out.
Rating:
Summary: Keeps Readers Howlinng For More!!!
Review: I put off reading Shiloh because I thought I hated dog stories. Then, after enjoying a similar book, I read it and loved it! It's about a boy, Marty, in West Virginia, who's desperate to save runaway dog Shiloh from his abusive owner. A great book that allows you to relate with the main character and gives you a chance to really think.However, for those of you who dislike "sappy" books or have a problem with saying I want a beagle too! at the end of it, this is not a book for you. On the other hand, if you like those types of things and are dying to know if Marty gets Shiloh, read and discover...
Rating: 
Summary: A very good book
Review: The title for my book is Shiloh. It is a good book. It is a good book because it talks about dogs. The book is about a dog that comes to a boys house. The boy's name is Marty. He builds a pin for it. He don't won't to give the dog back to the owner because he mistreats it.
Rating:
Summary: Incredible
Review: The first time I heard about this book was I overheard my 4th grade teacher say it was a GREAT book. So I thought i loved Because of Winn-Dixie which is a dog story and I saw Shilohs book cover and said I will be reading this. I read it complety and Phills did a charming job.GREAT,GREAT,GREAT BOOK IT IS FILLED WITH SOME LAUGHS AND ALOT OF HOPE AND SADNESS IN THIS BOOK. If there was more than 5 stars for rating I would have rated to the top top. I recommend Because of Winn Dixie and Shiloh GREAT BOOKS.
Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: Marty fell in puppy love the first time he saw a Redhound. What he didn't know was it was Judd Travers and that he mistreats his own dogs. The second time he saw it he took it home and took care of the dog. He built a pen on the hill for him. It wasn't a secret for long until the Bakers' dog chewed him up. Marty had named him Shiloh and Marty tries to save his live. This book is a happy and sad story and a good book.
Rating:
Summary: A Kid Who Risks His Life For A Dog
Review: The main character is Marty. He loved the dog when he first saw him, and he named it Shiloh. His family wouldn't let him keep Shiloh because it was Judd's dog. I like this book because it talks about dog's having a big friendship with human's. The part I didn't really like is when some people abuse their dogs only because they do not obey their orders.
Rating: 
Summary: shiloh
Review: I read the book Shiloh and I fell in love with it.Now I am always
reading it.I encourage you to go check this book out in your
library and I promise you will love it.n"
Rating:
Summary: shiloh
Review: Shiloh by is Phyllis Reynolds is a beautiful book. My favorite part is when a guy hides the dog named shiloh, when the other dog called sherman sheper fights shiloh and brakes his arm. I bet you'll love this book too!!!
Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: If you want to read a great book by Phyllis Naylor,
you have to read Shiloh. Our class really enjoyed this
novel about a beagle and a great main character that
show courage and determination. The book made you think
about what is right and wrong,and we all "got our eyes
opened some." Get your teacher to teach this novel.It
could change your heart!
Mrs. Bigsby's 4th grade class
Rating:
Summary: A Great Read for the Younger Set
Review: Although this is a "boy loves dog" story in the truest sense of the term, "Shiloh" adds the dimension of animal abuse that is a contemporary concern of all that love animals. Marty is a compassionate soul whose "hunting" is more of the investigative nature than the actual killing of an animal. This aspect of the boy's character is one of the strengths especially in light of the stereotypical view of all young boys in rural America having a passion for killing. Showing that it is just as "manly" to have concern for animals, as it to hunt them, is a concept that Ms. Naylor has cleverly presented. By having the characters speak in the language and manner of the West Virginia hills, Naylor has added authenticity to her prose. The conversations between the respective personalities are both insightful and entertaining. As I read the book, I felt as if these were real people speaking to me in their natural manner. Even though the principal is a boy, I am sure that all children, regardless of gender, can relate to this boy's courage and ingenuity. Marty's devotion to the animal is certainly an attribute that all should aspire to have for others. Because of the dog's presence in the family, there are subtle changes in the family. Mother and father discover maturity in their son that hey had not seen before; the boy becomes closer to his younger sisters; and Marty realizes that he possesses perseverance and resourcefulness that would benefit him for the rest of his days. Even an "enemy" of Marty becomes a respectful acquaintance. When I first began reading the book, I thought that it would take me through familiar territory. However, I was pleasantly surprised at its originality. I cared for this boy and his dog. Children will also have these same feelings.
| 
