Shiloh

Rating:
Summary: shiloh
Review: It was a good book becouse it was about a boy who liked a dog so much he would do anething for it. The only thing i did not like is when judd would kick or misstreat the animals.

the best part is when marty got to keep the dog by blakmailing judd for killing the dear off seasion.

when he said you are killing off seasion and gits in a fight with judd. or when the doctor tells marty how shiloh is after stiches

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: I think Shiloh is a good book because it has some action. I liked the part where Marty was working for Judd Travis so he can buy Siloh. Judd was mean to Shiloh so Marty wanted to buy him.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: I liked the book a lot because it has excitement and dogs. But they should add more action, and should put in more lessons for kids. They talked about Marty way too much.The book is suppose to be about Shiloh, even if he was a small skinny beagle. I liked the woods for the setting, It is a calm, peaceful place for a setting. I liked the part where Marty found Shiloh.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: Shiloh is a great book! Judd Traverse is really mean to his dogs. He whips them and yells at them. Marty, is the kid that finds Shiloh at the Shiloh Schoolhouse. I don't like the parts of the story when Shiloh gets shot or kicked by Judd Traverse.
Shiloh is a good book I recommend it to people who are dog lovers.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: I liked the book a lot because Marty is taking care of Shiloh by bringing Shiloh food every day. Shiloh kept running away from Judd Travers because he was staving him and hurting him. Judd was geting suspicious about Shiloh being at Marty's house because he hears barking at night. One day a dog jumps over the fence and bits and scatches Shiloh and so Marty and his dad have to take him to the vet to get him looked at. Marty's dad calls Judd on the phone and tells him that Marty's had him. Marty ask Judd if he can work for him and after a while buy Shiloh from him and take him home with him.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh in one word
Review: INCREDIBLE! OUTSTANDING! SUPERB! GREAT! Ok, so that was more than one word, but this book is incerdible. Shiloh, by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor, is a sad true story. I first read the book probably...when I was about nine. I saw the movie when I was probably about six or so. The movie is sad, and I loved it, just as I loved this book. Marty Preston, 11 years of age, finds a beagle and wants to keep it. The thing is, his parents won't let him, so Marty secretly keeps the dog. Marty feeds the dog table scraps, eggs, whatever he can find seeing as how his family doesn't have much money. The young beagle belongs to an abusive owner, Judd Travers, who also happens to be an acholic. This is why Marty refuses to let him go. The book is for all ages, even thought it does say 9-12. It deals with a lot, and that's why it's great.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: Elvis Florentino 4/11/2004

There's nothing eleven year old Marty preston enjoys more than spending time up in the hills behind his home near friendly, West virginia. But this time is different. This time Marty sees a young beagle on the road past the old shiloh schoolhouse. Marty feels sure the dog is being abused by his owner. When the dog turns up at Marty's house, Marty's parents say he must take him back. But it hurt's marty secretly decides he'll do anything to save the dog he names shiloh. !This book is sad! I rate this book a four because is a very beautiful story and it explains the sadness the kid had for the dog.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: Have you ever wanted something so bad but it just seems impossible? Well young Marty Peterson from West Virginia finds him self in this situation in this book Shiloh By Phyllis Naylor.
Phyllis Naylor takes you through the eye of Marty Peterson in this Newbery Award winning book Shiloh. Young Marty Peterson is desperate to take home a dog that he has found and is sure it has been abused. But his dad won't let him have it so Marty finally decides he will do any thing to save the dog. But if won't be easy when his dad refuses to let Marty have the dog. So finally he decides to hide the dog in an old shed that he has fixed up. But it still does not work. One day when Marty and his dad are taking the dog home he decides he will work for the dog at the dogs owner's house, Jud Travers. But the work is not so easy but he is sure he will not give up for the love of the dog Shiloh.
To find out how far Marty will go for the dog Shiloh You will have to read this great Newbery award-winning book Shiloh by Phyllis Naylor.

Rating:
Summary: Great Book
Review: This is a sad story but the book is very well-written. I highly recommend this tragic story about a boy and his dog. Great plot and characters.

Rating:
Summary: Shiloh
Review: I think that Phyllis Reynolds Naylor did a great job writing Shiloh. I realy enjoyed the way she expresses how much Marty loves Shiloh and that he'll do anything to get Shiloh even though he's Judd's dog. You can see this when Marty was willing to stand in front of Judd Travers who is a mean guy who will kill anything that moves and does anything he wants when he wants. When he gets shiloh back he will kill him for running away. Marty made a deal with Judd Travers, Marty wouldn't tell anyone that Judd killed a dear and he would work for him to earn 40$ enough to buy Shiloh.