Rating: 
Summary: freedom of speech or slander?
Review: If this book was written based on the "accounts of survivors" than that would explain the lies presented in this book. Since when does a communist tell the truth? This book is riddled with lies (and doctored photos) or at best, gross inaccuracies. If there is even one lie, why should we believe any of it? There were independant international journalists present during that time. Why didnt any of them report this alleged atrocity? Imperial Japan had only one division in Nanjing - 5000 soldiers armed with swords and lousy bolt-action rifles. If they really wanted to kill alot of Chinese, why didnt they take their machine guns there? Most of the residents of Nanking (population est. at 150,000) fled the city before the Japs arrived. To say few thousand Chinese were killed in Nanking is believable. Freedom of speech is a right in America, but not slander.
Rating:
Summary: This is written based on the fablicated crime.
Review: .
What called "Nanking Massacre" was fabricated in the International Military Tribune for the Far East.Chang's claim of 300,000 murder is based on the Chinese Community Party's statement on the population in Nanking as follows; Dec1937 - Jan1938 - Mar1938
500,000 - 250,000 - 170,000 while the record by the International Committee of the Nanking Safty Zone says; Dec1937 - Jan1938 - Mar1938
200,000 - 250,000 - 270,000 I highly recommend to examine the different views on this problem by yourself, reading "what really happened in nanking" or "the alleged 'Nanking Massacre'".
.
Rating: 
Summary: Forgotten holocaust
Review: Ignore the controversy...rebuke the critics...forget what you have heard...read this book. Any American student knows about The Holocaust...that terrible time during the 30's and 40's were over six million Jews were tortured, raped, and eventually, slaughtered. However, this holocaust has a sister. In the 30's, during the Sino-Japanese War, the civilians of Nanking were terrorized, tortured, raped, and killed. Ask any American student...they probably won't be able to tell you where Nanking is, let alone what happened there. I suppose there is a triplet as well. The third holocaust takes place in the present...it is historical genocide. The world has forgotten these atrocities, and the graves of Nanking's victoms are beging spat upon daily. I beg you...the victoms beg you, to read this book. It may be exaggerated (key word is "may"), Iris Chan may not be the greatest writer of all time...but you will never see the world in the same way after you know these secrets. Don't allow this auora of ignorance to seep into our future generation...
Rating: 
Summary: Why are the japanese the ones who are offended of this?
Review: i think this is a wonderful book. who cares about the pictures? i believe that she made her point accross, and i've been thinking exactly what she has even before i've read this book. she is a terrific writer and THE REASON SHE WROTE TO BOOK is because everyone talks about how horrible the holocaust was. yes it was devastating, but the chinese did their share of suffering as well! maybe even worse, yes that was the japanese in the PAST we know not every japanese is that way. we are not accusing or trying to say that japanese people are only barbaric and nothing more. iris wants everyone to remember this CRUEL history, to prevent it from every happening to ANY COUNTRY again. today is a different day, that was history... but it's good just to be know more about it for a better making in the future.
Rating:
Summary: Are you fair?
Review: -- If you think you are always fair or hoping to be fair, I recommend you to read "The Alleged Nanking Massacre" or "What really happened in Nanking" so that you can judge which is the truth. It is said that there are 170 historically incorrect descriptions and photographs are modified or forged in this book. Really important thing is not what she is trying to describe in this book, but why she wrote this book.
Rating:
Summary: The Rape of Nanking
Review: The book, The rape of Nanking by, Iris Chang is mind boggling, but keeps your attention from start to finish. It is definitly one of my favorite books. The way Iris Chang writes about the events in Nanking is so intreging because she writes the story from every different point of view. I highly recommend this book. It is repulsive but interesting.
Rating:
Summary: great and extensive evaluation of the hidden WWII horrors
Review: The book is great, it takes the story from three perspectives and in a very historically correct and concise recreation of a forgotten story. I was brought to tears many times while reading this book, a must read. Strongly recommended. A+
Rating:
Summary: Another forgotten holocaust
Review: The slaughter of Nanking, like those of Cambodia, Ukraine, and the Congo, is just another example of non-European genocides that are conveniently overlooked. "The Rape of Nanking" is a descriptive detail, taken from the accounts of survivors, documenting the systematic murder, torture, and rape carried out by the Japanese Imperial Army in the 1930's. What's sad is that this book could've been written today about Rwanda, Chechnya, Sudan, or a number of other places of which foreign intervention to prevent such atrocities cannot take place without the "legitimacy" of the UN. Oh, except if it takes place in Europe. Then suddenly the UN can be sidestepped and NATO approval is sufficient. "The Rape of Nanking" is just one small sliver of the horrors unleashed by the Japanese Army across Asia and the south Pacific. Due to post-war politics and the rise of Communist China, these war crimes were overlooked and unpunished. This book will depress you considerably, but it is a book that needs to be written to educate people to what happened.
Rating:
Summary: A volume of terrifying power
Review: This is arguably the most powerful piece of nonfiction that I have ever read, period. It documents some of the worst atrocities to have ever been inflicted upon human lives since the Dark Ages. Truly, the Massacre of Nanjing was and forever shall be the "Forgotten Holocaust", and it is so only because the cowardly Japanese, even now, refuse to admit to such terrible warcrimes. Even the Nazis, unlike these inhuman barbarians, had the courage to admit wrong and submit to justice. Japan is a country without honor, and they shall be shamed for all eternity.
Rating:
Summary: all political leaders should read this
Review: In research for my own book on the causes of war, hate and terrorism, I read The Rape of Nanking. This book should be required reading for every school age child and politician in the world - no exceptions. The truth of our own human potential for evil drips from each page like the blood from a Japanese bayonette just thrust into the body of an innocent young man. The lesson I got from this timless masterpiece is that our potential for virtually indescribable cruelty and evil exists in each person and all of civilization at every moment. Hell, as the Chinese experienced, is not some place after death, but is found in this world. We are heading in that very direction right now. For this reason, it is vital that our leaders teach peace. We don't need any more experts in killing. We don't need any brilliant minds poisoned by the misplaced values of aggression and death spun out by War College. What can we learn from the Rape of Nanking? War is evil and it begins in the hearts and minds of men. As far as I'm concerned the Rape of Nanking happened yesterday. Enough is enough!
| 
