Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life

Rating:
Summary: Typical "Woe-Is-Me, The Misunderstood Writer" Fluff
Review: This book has received rave reviews from many writers. I have often seen it written up as a "must-read." I disagree. While Anne Lamott writes well and is entertaining, there is really no useful information in this book.

Like many writing books, this one basically says, "I don't know what it takes to be a writer. I don't know how writing happens. It just does. And if you want to be a writer, just sit down, start writing, and the muse will eventually come." And, while that is true, it's not anything new and it is certainly not helpful to a new writer.

If you are a writer looking for empathy, you'll probably like this book--especially if you are the stereotypical misunderstood writer who has never really fit in. If you are a writer looking for practical advice about the craft, this book is not the one you're looking for.

I also got bored with the author's apparent lack of self-esteem. It got old fast.

Go to your local library and get this one. It might be good to read once, but it's not one that you'll want to refer to over and over again.

Rating:
Summary: More Than a Starter Book
Review: Three years, two books, and umpteen articles ago, I entered the crazy world of writing. My agent suggested I read Bird by Bird. Her recommendation was a gift.

Ann Lamott shares the good, the bad, and the ugly parts of writing, and she does it with incredible humor. I would not use some of the vocabulary she does, but it works for her. She is obviously a unique individual, and she calls it like she sees it.

After my first book was published, I pulled out Lamott's book and read it again. The second reading was even more enjoyable than the first because I had a frame of reference to build on. One of these days, when I need a treat, I'll read it again.

Rating:
Summary: Step by Step
Review: This book is a great tool. It gives new writers some beginning directions, and provides continued advice for continuing writers. The book is conveniently broken up into five parts to help you find your way back to your level. In addition to the highly credible instruction that is provided the anecdotes and analysis will help motivate you to the next level. This step by step approach is exactly what you need to help you get started. Anne cuts through the mystery of a lot of aspects of writing and lays it all out there for everyone to see.

Rating:
Summary: Caution: Good Read Ahead
Review: Want to write? Read this book.
Want to not write? Read this book.
Enjoy thinking, smiling, laughing? See the pattern?

Did not relish finishing this little book. It was an oasis
of clarity, good humor and widely applicable instructions
for.....well, lots of things. Finishing it was like saying
"Adios" to a friend I knew I'd miss.

Are you breathing? Read this book.

Lee Fredrickson