Sacred Art of the Earth: Ancient and Contemporary Earthworks

Rating:
Summary: Seeing the world through the places that mean most to us.
Review: Our relation to the earth, to particular places, is an important element of our identity as individuals and as a country. Northrop Frye once asked: "Where is here?" Maureen Korp provides an original and stimulating route to exploring that question through an examination of how some artists confront the land. In clear and frequently witty prose, Korp explains first how the works of some artists in and around Ottawa and Hull opened her eyes to new ways of looking at "ordinary" places, which turn out to be not so ordinary. The artists' careful compositions guide the viewer to something beyond the immediate space. A chapter on Jennifer Dickson's photographs of gardens takes a further step towards sites where "there have been events of passion and intellect; the sites have history and they have names." This observation leads to considerations of "built spaces", such as Saskatchewan's Moose Mountain Medicine Wheel and other North American native earthworks, as well as six massive contemporary earthworks. Korp skilfully lays out a path that leads us to glimpses of understanding why some places strike us as significant, why simply being there we can be overwhelmed by their power by simply being there, and sometimes experience visionary states. They center us to the earth; they point our ways home. This book produced many flashes of recognition. It helped me make sense of my reactions when I first returned to my birth place, and of my responses to other places that have been important to me. Such spaces help us find ourselves in that world; that is why they have a touch of the sacred. Sacred Art of the Earth opened my eyes in marvellous new ways. Maureen Korp addresses profound issues in a wonderfully down to eath voice.

Rating:
Summary: Seeing the world through the places that mean most to us.
Review: Our relation to the earth, to particular places, is an important element of our identity as individuals and as a country. Northrop Frye once asked: "Where is here?" Maureen Korp provides an original and stimulating route to exploring that question through an examination of how some artists confront the land. In clear and frequently witty prose, Korp explains first how the works of some artists in and around Ottawa and Hull opened her eyes to new ways of looking at "ordinary" places, which turn out to be not so ordinary. The artists' careful compositions guide the viewer to something beyond the immediate space. A chapter on Jennifer Dickson's photographs of gardens takes a further step towards sites where "there have been events of passion and intellect; the sites have history and they have names." This observation leads to considerations of "built spaces", such as Saskatchewan's Moose Mountain Medicine Wheel and other North American native earthworks, as well as six massive contemporary earthworks. Korp skilfully lays out a path that leads us to glimpses of understanding why some places strike us as significant, why simply being there we can be overwhelmed by their power by simply being there, and sometimes experience visionary states. They center us to the earth; they point our ways home. This book produced many flashes of recognition. It helped me make sense of my reactions when I first returned to my birth place, and of my responses to other places that have been important to me. Such spaces help us find ourselves in that world; that is why they have a touch of the sacred. Sacred Art of the Earth opened my eyes in marvellous new ways. Maureen Korp addresses profound issues in a wonderfully down to eath voice.

Rating:
Summary: Excellent discussion of environmentally oriented artworks
Review: There are areas on the earth recognizable as important, even powerful. They have been spoken of as sacred by some, "resonating" by others.Many years and several careers ago, while waiting for my Masters Thesis on a Quaternary topic to be signed off, I played around with studies of environmental perception. I did not, however, find an objective explanation for this phenomena of "sacred" landscapes. My own experiments consisted of tachistoscopic viewing of a large number of photographic slides. I asked fellow grad students to rate each slide, 1 to 10, as it was projected. I had previously measured each of the photos for percentages of color as well as features such as water, sky, vegetation, etc. The photos were, for the most part, of natural landscapes. I don't recall getting any meaningful results and the professor suggested that all I really wanted to do was show off my photography. Maureen Korp has done a much better job than I of analyzing such landscapes. In her new book, _Sacred Art of the Earth, Ancient and Contemporary Earthworks_ (Continuum, 1997 ISBN 0-8264-0883-4), she presents criteria for recognizing locations of "power" through analysis of a particular type of art, earthworks. For those of you unwilling to approach religious topics, don't be misled by the title. This is not a theological text. If you wish, think in terms of aesthetics rather than religion. Feelings of awe and wonder associated with "sacred sites" can and are experienced by atheists, agnostics and the devout; only the words used to describe such experiences vary. In the book, such dichotomies are discussed in terms of sacred and profane, cultural perceptions of art, the concept of "Mother Earth" and more. It took quite a while for me to get a copy of this book, but I finally did through a Barnes and Noble outlet (Amazon has it cheaper). My first reaction was that Maureen Korp has an excellent command of written language and if I wasn't careful I'd gulp it down in a single sitting (it's only 146 pages less the notes). After reading the first two chapters I'd realized there was much I needed to ponder in detail. Since then, I worked through the book in small bites. An analogy to fine whiskey may be appropriate here, it can be taken in a shot (at the risk of being overwhelmed) or sipped. One of the first points that made me pause was some terminology. I'd been with the US Army Corps of Engineers for some years and came to associate "earthworks" not with art but with such things as rivetments, canals and dams. She states: "...the earthwork. It marks the landscape, shapes our perception of the earth as a landscape. It creates a geography".(p19) This is not inconsistent with those engineered items I was familiar with albeit they were/are rarely considered aesthetic (except perhaps by engineers). Next, this use of the word geography. "Geography" has always been, for me, an abstract noun. During my graduate days, the definition I came to prefer was actually a verb, "geography is what geographers do". These are not particularly important points except that they helped cause me to read much slower. What I believe is central to this book is the idea that people have, from the earliest times to the present, recognized places that are somehow special. Different cultures in different times and places mark these areas in a variety of ways, denoting their power and significance. I thought one of the more intriguing points dealt with the variation between cultures with open horizons as opposed to those indigenous to closed or forested areas. Maureen Korp has this to say about the commonality of sacred sites: "..., like all other ancient sacred sites, share a set of common physical attributes that comprise the descriptors needed for a morphology of sacred place."(p102) The question then is what are these attributes. After the introduction, she takes us on a tour of European gardens. These gardens are seen through the eyes of Jennifer Dickson, an artist who interprets "sacred sites" with a camera. I pondered the applicability of this chapter in reference to the overall stated purpose of the book and was constantly drawn to an Ansel Adams print I have on my wall. Dickson takes photos of physically constructed landscapes whereas Adams' photo (this particular one is the 1944 _Winter Sunrise, Sierra Nevada, from Lone Pine, California) is a natural landscape. I was long puzzled by what appeared to me to be an incompatibility in definition of "sacred" landscapes. I could not accept that an artifactual garden could be sacred but the naturally majestic Sierra Nevada were not. The answer lies in Korp's view that the landscape is not naturally sacred, it is the combination of the artist's vision, the execution or realization of that vision along with the natural characteristics of the site that create sacredness. Photography is thus an appropriate medium for creating sacredness. I would still maintain, however, that such art as Adams' and Dickson's are not strictly speaking "earthworks". The inclusion of Dickson's work in this book thus becomes somewhat problematic. I do think, however, that such inclusion is justifiable in that examination of this art helps illustrate just what characteristics of landscapes are to be considered as significant. Discussion shifts to other, what could be termed, physical installations or "proper" earthworks. Korp discusses the siting of these works, the materials of their construction, reactions of visitors and a host of other factors pertinant to each. Leaving it to the reader to decide which if any of these works should be considered sacred. She states: "By no means are all contemporary earthworks sacred endeavors. Some fail. The artist may lack talent, or talent equal to the artist's vision. The artist may lack the simple opportunity to do the work. Some earthworks are just what their sponsors claim them to be - land reclamation projects, gardens, parks, playgrounds, or other sorts of outdoor sculptural installations." (p129) Further on, she provides this synopsis: "The sacred place is described generally as an architectonic space that is enclosed or set aside in some way; it is a place that has a point of entry, requiring the visitor to go from here to there along some directed path. The sacred place is animated: it is a site where something important happens, where our everyday sense of time and place collapses." (p130) Included in this book are examples of ancient New World sculptures: the serpent mounds near Cincinnati, Ohio and at Rice Lake, Ontario; various petroglyph sites; and ancient astronomical observatories. She takes us on a visit to the Moose Mountain Medicine Wheel, in Saskatchewan. She has drawn extensively from the writings of Mircea Eliade and a wealth of others. There is an extensive bibliography provided and the book is indexed. The single most significant omission that comes to mind is the lack of discussion of Frederick Law Olmstead, perhaps America's most important landscape artist. Many of his works, I feel, fulfill the requirements. There is a point along the road from Yosemite Valley to Tuolumne Meadows, named after this man, that is well known for creating feelings of awe and wonder. Finally, Maureen Korp has provided us with a work of art, in its own right. This is a book about a form of art, a book about cultural expression, a book about the dicotomy of religion and aesthetics. It is also an important book about living with as well as on the earth.