The Future of the Past

Rating:
Summary: Can the Past and Future Coexist?
Review: "Stille takes us on a whirlwind tour of the world's natural and cultural resources, from the most prominent, such as the Sphinx and pyramids of Egypt, to the exotic, such as word carving in the East Indes. He shows that perhaps more than ever societies around the world are being forces to come to terms with the past, what it means, and how they want to preserve it. Approaches to historic preservation have been as diverse as the problems. The one commonality seems to be a heightened urgency of the problem. As societies have adopted some degree of capitalism and modern technology, they have often experienced a growing anxiety about the loss of tradition. As technological change has made available previously unimagined tools for the preservation and stuffy of the past, it has also brought about unprecedented potential to destroy natural and cultural objects. Social and geographic mobility has also had a profound effect. As Stille points out, 'Paradoxically, the rootlessness of contemporary society has created a tremendous yearning for a connection with ancient or vanished civilizations.' He illustrates with numerous examples how this 'double-edged nature of technological change' (p. xvii) is playing out around the world.

"Stille's stories demonstrate the common thread running through the debates about both environmental protection and cultural preservation: he realizes that 'some of our notions about nature [are] deeply related to issues I was dealing with in the chapter on monuments and museums' (p. xviii). For example, he looks at the debate over who controls 'endangered' resources or artifacts. Who decides what gets protected and what does not? The ever-present irony in these debates is that the Western preservationists, environmentalists, and art historians alike, concerned about preserving the past and diverse cultures and societies, often seek to impose their own Western values on the very cultures they purport to be interested in 'saving.' It seems that the modernist idea of perpetual change leading to progress has been replaced by an equally postmodernist view that all change is bad and that preservation is the only good. Trying to implement such preservation strategies has often brought Western activists into conflict with the very peoples and cultures they claim to be helping, raising a question about whose interests conservation actually serves: the conservationists or those whose culture is being 'preserved'?"

--

Excerpted from a review essay, "Can the Past and Future Coexist," by Matthew Brown, in "The Independent Review," Winter 2004.

Rating:
Summary: The Past is still Present, barely!
Review: Fascinating! Couldn't put it down. I found out alot about conservation, past and present, good and bad. Did you know that copying in China is an honorable profession and that Somalia is noted for its poetry? This is just two of the chapters. The writing is not pedantic at all, but reads like a good mystery, one page after another. Hated to see it end.

Rating:
Summary: The Past is still Present, barely!
Review: Fascinating! Couldn't put it down. I found out alot about conservation, past and present, good and bad. Did you know that copying in China is an honorable profession and that Somalia is noted for its poetry? This is just two of the chapters. The writing is not pedantic at all, but reads like a good mystery, one page after another. Hated to see it end.

Rating:
Summary: Fabulous Book
Review: It's hard to put this great book down. Each chapter is more fascinating than the prior one. A must read.

Rating:
Summary: classical encounter
Review: overall excellent book though author digresses in last chapter with minimal basis, e.g., implying - through other thinkers - that internet is more of an echo chamber and likely leads people to be less politically involved. every other chapter is a gem unto itself ~ a fascinating work!

Rating:
Summary: The Future Has a Past
Review: Stille's work is fabulous, insightful, intelligent...whether you have just acquired a taste for history and preservation, or whether you are a seasoned professional in these subjects, there's something for you in every one of the essays that make up this fascinating--and often disturbing--book. Neither pandering nor mired in technical jargon, this book will satisfy amateur and professional alike.

Stille's experience ranges from one corner of the world to the other and his reportage demonstrates that no matter how disparate the cultures, all are struggling with the insistent presence and immense pressure of The Past.

I've gone back to this book over and over since first reading it and I anticipate that it will remain a permanent fixture of my library.

Highest recommendation!

Rating:
Summary: classical encounter
Review: This book was well written, informative, and contains captivating stories that draw you into the dilema the author laments: "Modern technology, usefull and keen as it may be, is unintentionally destroying the past." From historical sites to modern day primitive peoples, the past is eroding right before our eyes. Pollution and tourism kill off monuments and rare species. The tape recorder adn the typewriter are replacing the bard. People are trying to become more modern for 'being modern's sake'.

The reader will enjoy the first hand accounts of the author as he tells his sad, yet hopefull story. What you won't find alot of in this book, outside of the intro., chapter 11, and the conclusion, are more academic style essays on anthropology.

This isn't a book on how we are becoming post-human, or how we should all recycle or anything like that. It's about how our (human)cultural heritage is in danger of losing its value, its wealth of knowledge, beauty, and depth.

Rating:
Summary: An important book for all academics and laymen alike to read
Review: This book was well written, informative, and contains captivating stories that draw you into the dilema the author laments: "Modern technology, usefull and keen as it may be, is unintentionally destroying the past." From historical sites to modern day primitive peoples, the past is eroding right before our eyes. Pollution and tourism kill off monuments and rare species. The tape recorder adn the typewriter are replacing the bard. People are trying to become more modern for 'being modern's sake'.

The reader will enjoy the first hand accounts of the author as he tells his sad, yet hopefull story. What you won't find alot of in this book, outside of the intro., chapter 11, and the conclusion, are more academic style essays on anthropology.

This isn't a book on how we are becoming post-human, or how we should all recycle or anything like that. It's about how our (human)cultural heritage is in danger of losing its value, its wealth of knowledge, beauty, and depth.

Rating:
Summary: Should be Required Reading for all Students
Review: This is an extraordinarily informative and entertaining book that sheds light on the problems and differing worldwide attitudes toward conversation and preservation. The author decries the rapid disappearance of historical landmarks, statues, buildings, art and sculpture - as do most of us. The modern effect whereby observation leads directly to degradation he has named the "Heisenberg" principle, based on the German scientist's observation that the very act of viewing affects the properties of light. Moisture, oxygen, germs, exposure - all of these are detrimental agents and all are associated with people.

He also decries the loss of those items that are elusive - tribal customs now recorded in any medium that have been passed from generation to generation for thousands of years, languages such as Latin, even - and surprisingly - outmoded technology. It is estimated that an enormous collection of data in the National Archives is for all intents and purposes lost since we have lost the technology required for viewing/hearing such data.

The differing cultural views on preservation were examined, from the rather recent Western one whereby objects remain in their natural state to the Oriental practice of repeatedly copying (in detail) ancient objects to the oral history of Africa. He rightly recalls that this process has been recurring since mankind recognized ancient works as something different.

But this book was also a personal journey since the author became intimately involved with the participants of this saga. From taking Latin classes in Rome to visiting Chinese and Italian scholars to reviewing the new National Archives and the Vatican Library, this is a "hands on" book that reads like a labor of love.

Our prosperous culture has created such sins as urban sprawl, deforestation, pollution, crowding, fast food - all of which directly affect not only the objects of the past but our view of the importance of past people's and events. It is this latter problem that seems all the most disturbing. A close reading reveals that the modern urge to preserve is directly related to the rise of industrialism.

What the book lacked were definitive solutions and perhaps that is not by accident. What is NOT needed are quick fixes or top down solutions. One of the things he has documented with sorrow is the repetitive nature of socialist dictatorships to screw things up with top-down solutions - whether it be Egypt, China or any number of African countries. Solutions should be from the ground up and must be in accordance with the wishes of the inhabitants of the affected area.

Not only cultural but religious views have affected our past. How much knowledge was destroyed when the library in Alexandria was burned or how much religious statuary was destroyed in the first five centuries of Christiandom? And how many hundreds of thousands of paintings and statues have followers of Islam defaced or destroyed in the recent past? Rare is the culture or religion that demonstrates reverence for alien peoples and the products of their culture.

The final chapter sums up what we know, what we don't know and where we go from here. An important book that should grace the libraries of every literate American. Get the book, contemplate its message.