Rating: 
Summary: An American Experience
Review: American Idol is a show that brought people joy for a couple of months. It was nerve racking and fun watching someone get eliminated each week hoping that your favorite was voted to stay in the contest and have their dreams come true. It was corny sometimes and it had it's commercialism, but if you ever actually watched the show you also know that it had it's sincere, unstaged moments that were true to heart. When a show comes along and sweeps over a nation, touching and inspiring those who watch, who cares about it's corny moments? Every tv show has them and this is no different, but it's a great show to watch and as someone who DID watch it, I can see why people would wanna own this DVD and relive the fun and anticipation all over again. For those of you who seem to have a problem with the show which seem to be alot of you since you seem to be so passionate about it that you would have to write a negative review, my advice is to seek a life and live it and not worry about what others are doing. For those of you who actually care about this DVD, I would suggest getting it. I think it's basically just the final episode with a bunch of special features and extras added. A great collection in every American Idol fanatic's collection. Keep your eyes peeled for the American Idol's Greatest Hits Collection October 1st, 2002.
Rating: 
Summary: SIGH...
Review: The "music"(more like product industry) just won't quit dragging out mediocre talent to the masses and making money of them, will they? "American Idol" was the final straw in the totally corporate state of music. These people aren't groomed to have their old identity or sound or individuality but more so have to fit a standard. And the standard wasn't even high. Except for Tamyra, none of the vocalists were anything above average background vocalist level and for Pete's sake, this show was damn CHEESY!!! "American Idol" comes off like a microwaved "Star Search" with a little "The Weakest Link" ( both shows voted people off with a sharp-tongued British host never running out of snide remarks to make) thrown in. Like most terrible gimmicks in America, the public ate it up. The judges (Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, Randy Jackson) were everywhere and the show became ultimate reality-television water cooler discussion (along with past reality franchises "Survivor", "Fantasy Island", and countless other programs). "AI" winner Kelly Clarkson quickly released a generic single in a week's time to capitalize on the "craze".
"AI" revels in everything that's wrong with mainstream America:
there's no emphasis on music but looks, greed, and most strikingly: MONEY!!!
Rating: 
Summary: It's all about Nikki
Review: This amazing DVD is a must have for American Idol fans. As for me, I'm not much of a fan but I purchased it as a novelty collector's item. I got it primarily because of lovely Nikki McKibbin (my favorite finalist with amazing eyes and dazzling killer smile.) I recommend this DVD to everyone! And also, thanks for voting for Nikki - close, but top three ain't bad!
Rating:
Summary: Seriously, Who Would Buy This?
Review: I honestly can't fathom who would be the market for a DVD like this. Couch potatoes who long for the glory years of "Star Search?" Or masochists who want to torture themselves even further by watching these tragically inept performances? "American Idol" is another nail in the coffin of pop music, endorsing the belief that it's not about how talented you are, but how cleverly you're marketed. Oh, I am begging you. Please do not get this DVD. Please. It looks atrocious.
Rating:
Summary: Excellent look back!
Review: This is a excellent chance to look back at a great summer show, and to see all your favorites again. I'm glad that talent won over flash for once. I'm sure all the final ten will do well, and it looks like the WINNER Kelly Clarkson is well on her way! I don't agree with the review above me by the way, because it sounds like sour grapes. Some people love a show UNTIL their pick doesn't win, and is voted off. A dvd to enjoy for sure!!
Rating:
Summary: Worth it if you want the memories
Review: If you want the funny outtakes and the memories of the show, buy it. Definitely don't take the advice of bitter fans that think someone else should have won. The show is over, the Idol has been chosen. Enjoy everyone's journey to get there, especially if you missed it the first time.
Rating: 
Summary: Sweet holy moses, will the commercialism never end?
Review: As fascinating and compelling as AMERICAN IDOL occasionally was on television, is anyone (over the age of 14, mind you) willing to shuck out the price of a new DVD to listen yet again to Ryan Starr, Nikki McKibben and the rest slaughter every tune they sing? Frankly, the contest was over eight weeks before the final episode -- and it should have been Tamyra Gray, not admirable-but-second-placer Kelly Clarkson -- who took home the prize. If you're the type who finds Simon Cowell's scripted insults the height of watch-it-again hilarity, this one's for you. On the other hand, if you have a brain and a heart, it ain't. Spend your money elsewhere, teenypop fans!
Rating:
Summary: I sure wish I could be on there, don't you all?
Review: I think American Idol is such a cool idea. We all know that we secretly wish we were on there ourselves. So for all of you people judging, think of what it took for all of the singers to get that far. They even inspired me to sing myself, I bought a voice lesson Cd off Amazon- Voice Lessons To Go by Vaccarino, and I am listening to all my favorite artists and singing all the time. A group of my friends got together for Karaoke the other night- cool place- rented the room out, and I promise you I impressed. These singers are awesome. And learning to sing myself is teaching me how hard they really do work.
Rating:
Summary: One of my favorite DVDs
Review: In the words of Randy, this DVD, "Did it's thang dawg!" I absolutely loved it. I only have one complaint about it. First, this movie didn't show many of the performances by the singers (they don't show ANY of EJay's and Jim's performance, not even in the extra features). They should have a section of EVERY performance by all of the singers, even in the Top 30.Overall, this DVD was absolutely amazing. Brain was extremely funny in many sections of the show. I loved that section with the judges (I think it's called "When Judges Attack."). Wonderful! But there's one more thing, why don't they have Season 2 and Season 3???
Rating:
Summary: The Search For A Superstar
Review: I bought this d.v.d. a couple of years ago and I really loved it.The only problem was I was expecting the whole season and I didn't get that.That's why I only gave it 4 stars!It is the length of 1 episode.I love the bonus features and the bonus disk!They really rock!It has amazing performances from:Kelly Clarkson,Justin Guarini,Nikki McKibbin,Tamyra Gray,Christina Christian,and Ryan Starr!It's worth the cash!I wish they would create a d.v.d. like this for seasons 2 and 3!
|
