Rating: 
Summary: Jack's review (bloopers)
Review: I would like to state that I am a Civil War buff so to speak and have made dozens of trips to Gettysburg over the years. I have also watched "Gettysburg" dozens of times as well.In watching the movie, I have picked out some "bloopers" that I'd like to share with you. These all take place in tape #1. 1). Watch the roof of Lee's Headquarters. There's an antenna on it. 2). Take note of the patches on Chamberlain's shoulders. He suddenly changes rank after Little Round Top! 3). Immediately following the first day's battle, The Chamberlain Bros are walking into camp where Lt. Chamberlain talks to 3 prisoners. Look at the sky as they enter that scene and see the jet trail in the sky. 4). During the scene where Gen. Longstreet is introducing his Generals to the English visitor, watch Darnell's positioning. As the Generals are being introduced he switches from Longstreets side to Pickets side time and time again.
Rating: 
Summary: Should be seen by every High School Student
Review: I usually have little good to say about Ted Turner, but I will always have a soft spot for him because of his production of "Gettysburg." It portrays the charactors in a way that makes them real. Children do not study history today, and Gettysburg brings to life a part of our history that few of them understand. The charactors are done so well that most children who see the film care about them,and lean more about the Civil War period. This particular set has several additional scenes that add to the movie.
Rating:
Summary: Fantastic Recreation
Review: I think that this is a fantastic recreation of the battle of Gettysburg. I know this because I have read 20 books on the subject. I also enjoyed the fact that it showed the battle from both sides this helps you understand what happened from a more broad perspective of the battle. The final battle scene is astounding the special effects are fantastic. So in other words I think this movie is great.
Rating:
Summary: A Change Of Heart
Review: Not until I watched Gettysburg on TNT the first time, was I even interested in the Civil War. After seeing this epic on television, I immediately ran out and purchased the video. Soon after that, I began reading just about every book I could find on the battle, and discovered that the filmakers did their homework on this one. What makes this film so realistic, is that they shot on the actual battlefield or close by in many cases, and used re-enactors for many of the battle scenes, not just a group of extras dressed up for the parts. Although Martin Sheen overworks his characterization of General Robert E. Lee, the others do an excellent job. You actually find yourself feeling General Pickett and General Longstreet's (played by Tom Berringer) pain and frustration when the battle begins to go against the South. The only thing I didn't like about the movie was when Ted Turner (the TNT mogal) placed himself in the movie as one of the leaders of the Virginia contingent, and dies very badly when his time comes. Other than that, you become mesmorized by the strategy that both armies worked to win this campaign, and the actual battle footage is so realistic, you wonder if any of the re-enactor soldiers playing in the movie didn't get hurt (there's one scene where a cannon shot goes off right in front of a group, and blows them back in to the ranks). Even my young sons have watched this 2 or 3 times with me, and has got them to ask questions about the war. If a movie can do that to kids that are usually more interested in the lasted fad these days, then this is a keeper. You'll find that even the least informed history fans, will discover that this movie has a plot line that is easy to follow, and will keep your interest throughout the length of the film. Also, get your hands on the soundtrack, as its quite enjoyable to listen to.
Rating:
Summary: A little long but what the hey
Review: Monumental effort to recreate the Civil War battle. It rivals 'The Triumph and the Glory' and "War of the Rats" as the most effective film or book dealing with the darkly glorious aspects of battle.
Rating:
Summary: A very good movie, certainly worth seeing
Review: Gettysburg is a good movie, quite faithful to the book "Killer Angels" on which it is based. The author of "Killer Angels" states in his book that his work is NOT intended to be a precise historical reference. Instead, it is a great story, based on historical events with a fair amount of poetic license. The movie is a great visual experience. Literally thousands of volunteer re-enactors participated in the making of the film. These fellows would be the first to tell you that the movie is a "historical novel" and not a precise re-enactment. But, that said, no movie I have ever seen is Gettysburgs equal on the subject. Perhaps "Glory" comes close. I recommend this movie to all.
Rating: 
Summary: Long, violent Civil War movie
Review: This would be a lot better movie if it wasn't so long. There is only so much violent warfare that I can take in one sitting, and this movie has about one hour more than my limit. The movie is also a lot more sympathetic to the North than the South. This movie certainly makes me glad that I didn't have to participate in the Civil War.
Rating:
Summary: Great film, very good history
Review: I have read all of the reviews here and find that both the fans and critics of "Gettysburg" make valid points. The critics seem to focus on Sheen being a poor Lee, certain elements of the battle being underplayed (Culp's Hill, the role of non-Virginia units, the role of other units in the defense of Little Round Top, etc.) or overplayed (Lee's mysticism, Longstreet's logic, the friendship between Armistead and Hancock, etc.). These are valid points. As is the comment that the music could be overbearing at times. STILL, we need to balance our desire for this to be perfect HISTORY against our desire (and the producer's need) for it to be a watchable film. As history, the film stayed fairly close to the historical novel, which was researched and written so well by Michael Shaara. The key characters are well represented, and the PARTS OF THE BATTLE CHOSEN TO BE SHOWN are well portrayed. As has been pointed out already, no movie could show all of the critical parts of the battle. Also as history, it was a little heavy handed during the conversation between Chamberlain and his adjutant. As a film, I loved "Gettysburg." It has a good balance of action and background, of emotion and logic. The acting is good, and I cared for most of the characters. MOST IMPORTANTLY, the fim will open the eyes and stir the interest of people who might not otherwise have ever given a thought to this critical part of our history. And isn't that a measure of a great film, that it moved people to think more or learn more? Go to the battlefield at Gettysburg and take a personally guided tour with one of the great guides at the park (inexpensive!). And then walk the ground. Quitely and alone.
Rating:
Summary: RE-RELEASE THIS MOVIE IN THEATRES NOW!!!!
Review: This movie *MUST* be re-released! DO IT NOW! Everything about this movie was spectacular; the battles, the acting, the accuracy...everything. What I liked most, would have to be the soundtrack. Randy Edelman provides what is arguably the best motion picture score ever. You should buy it right now! I guarantee you will love this score. ACTING - 10/10. General Amistaed was absolutely magnificent! The same goes for Martin Sheen, Jeff Daniels, Tom Berenger, Sam Elliot...get the picture? Wait..."get the picture?" GET IT NOW! MUSIC - 10/10. Buy it now. You will not be disappointed! Casting - 10/10. What else can be said? Three things for you to do: 1) See the movie 2) Buy the movie 3) Buy the soundtrack special note: PUT THIS MOVIE BACK IN THEATRES!
Rating:
Summary: Gut wrenching and wonderful! I loved it!
Review: "Gettysburg" is a wonderful but gut wrenching movie that should be seen by anyone who needs to put the most pivotal battle of the Civil War into context. This movie will appeal to both Yankee and Confederate hearts, and will get the point across that war is hell. I went to Gettysburg and stood at the statue dedicated to the Army of Virginia. As I looked across that open expanse to the "angle" I could only stand there and weep. For a moment I was transported back to a time when men were slaughtered because they believed in a cause who's time had come and gone in America. And I could feel deep inside me the same cold fear that I'm sure many soldiers felt as they waited for the command to move forward. Mr. Death waited for many of them on Cemetary Ridge. But they went and did their duty. You need to watch this video with your children. Perhaps afterward you could discuss with them the importance of the battle and its impact on our nation's most terrible moment. I would also strongly suggest that you plan a trip to Gettysburg Battlefield after seeing the movie. It will be well worth your time.
| 
