Rating: 
Summary: WOW
Review: I dont want to sit down a write a huge review like some of the other fans so il simply say. BEST MOVIE EVER. hope that helps!
Rating:
Summary: the greatest story of all time
Review: I eagerly awaited this movie, and wasn't disappointed; there is nothing negative I can say about this movie. It was absolutely breathtaking. At the end, I just sat in the theatre, stunned. When the dvd was released, I heard that an even better version would be released in a few months and that is what I waited for. It was worth the wait. I enjoyed seeing the additional footage, and seeing all the extra "goodies". This edition might be a little more expensive, but was well worth it.
Rating:
Summary: Almost endless fun
Review: I enjoyed "Fellowship" at the cinema in 2001, and I'm enjoying, and enjoying, and enjoying this feature-packed extended edition even more in 2002.Others have already commented on the extremely gratifying addition of seamlessly-grafted additional scenes, complete with new music; and on the amazing wealth of commentaries and special features. I hope the success of this special DVD set encourages the studios to create more like it. Anyone who liked the movie, even just a little, and who likes knowing about the inner workings of filmmaking, will find this great set an astonishingly good value. Oh, and a certain comment by Ian McKellan--about Ian Holm's appearance as the aged Bilbo in Rivendell--is one of the funniest and most unexpected things I've yet encountered in a DVD commentary. Wonderful DVD release, offering virtually endless viewing enjoyment.
Rating:
Summary: Vast Cinema Experience
Review: I enjoyed Lord of the Rings immensely. The acting was very good but it is the scope of the movie that impresses me more. The special effects are fantastic, the settings are inspiring but it is how the whole film is woven together that makes it deserving of five stars. When one contemplates how this was filmed in conjunction with the other two parts of the Trilogy it defies imagination how complex that must have been, and yet to produce a film of such quality demonstrates an attention to detail by Director and Producers alike. The movie is long, but so is the book. It leaves you hanging at the end, but so does the book. Criticism of these two points is not really justified when one appreciates Peter Jacksons efforts at being true to the original written works. Highly recommended.
Rating:
Summary: Like the DVD Even Better.
Review: I enjoyed the film in the theatres, but must say I enjoy the extended version DVD even more. A film to savor and the nice little additional touches have rounded the film out just where it needed. Having seen the Two Towers now, I am even more impressed with what Jackson has accomplished here. This is fine movie-making and a film-lover's delight. If it all holds up through the 3rd film (which it is showing every indication of doing), we are well on the way to a masterpiece. I am again so thankful it was all done at once, with the same cast, crew, and unifying vision. It is going to make all the difference when seen in its entirety. I am not a huge fan of fantasy, but this is such quality film-making I have been completely caught up in its story and magic! I never read the books, so the nitpicking I see is the same old stuff when someone has to translate literature into a motion picture. They have to make changes folks! As to the extras on the DVD, they are wonderful. I don't often watch a lot of the extras as I find them tiresome at times, and I often don't want to know how the magic is done. The over 6 hours of extras here, however, were fascinating as you get a real look at the devotion and fanatic attention to detail that went into the production. Likewise, I found it enlightening as to how much non-CGI in the form of elaborate sets etc. went into the making of the films. That all the real and cyber stuff is so seamlessly meshed, as well as the added capability of later further tinkering made possible by the computers, I found engrossing. It's the best extras package I've seen. All in all, it presents a fuller film version and a tribute to the hardworking folk that labored so mightily to bring this beloved epic to the screen. Well worthwhile.
Rating: 
Summary: Looking Forward to December 2002
Review: I enjoyed the movie. It wasn't "true" to the first book of Tolkein's trilogy. Arwen played too large an on-screen role (not surprising, given the casting), as did Sauron. Galadriel came off as far less regal than in the book. Bree, Rivendell, and Lothlorien were given short shrift. Significant matter was lifted from "The Two Towers" -- I suppose in order to maintain a single timeline -- and cut from "The Fellowship of the Ring" -- doubtless to satisfy studio cheeses who assume anything over 3 hours will die at the box office (can you say "Kenneth Branagh's 'Hamlet'"?). There were a couple of unnecessary "dramatic" moments and a couple of equally unnecessary moments of slapstick. The effects were very good, though the director seemed too attached to a couple of them. The "forced perspective" made the hobbits appear comically small. (I am sure that Tolkein describes Frodo as "tall for a hobbit" or some such, giving the impression that he was nearly 5 feet tall.) The Watcher In The Water is overplayed, as are Saruman's orcs, and "arrow cam" was worn out by the end of "Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves." On the other hand, Gandalf's fireworks at Bilbo's party were truly spectacular, and the Balrog and the scene at the river ford were well worth the wait. The music was generally good, as were the sound effects. I thought the casting (other than Liv Tyler, though she did fine in the role manufactured for her) was generally good, and heartily disagree with the other reviewer about Boromir and Aragorn. I think both were well played. Ian McKellan was a bit bumbling early on, but then so Gandalf appeared in FOTR. Ian Holm seemed a bit off his game as Bilbo. Elijah Wood was quite good, if seeming a bit young for the part, and Sean Astin was a stout Samwise Gamgee. If you are looking for a literal reenactment of Tolkein's "The Fellowship of the Ring," you may be disappointed. If you are looking for an enjoyable movie that should leave you anticipating its sequel, go see it.
Rating:
Summary: A beautiful movie
Review: I enjoyed the original release of this movie, so of course I needed to get the directors extended version. I wouldn't necessarily say that the extended scenes make the film better, but they do add information to the story line which might make it easier for people to understand the movie. A nice added bonus to this movie is two DVD discs which show the behind the scenes for this movie. It was very entertaining to see how this movie was adapted from the novel and how the created all of the visual effects.
Rating:
Summary: Great movie even if you have read and love the book!!
Review: I enjoyed this movie immensely. It was beautifully crafted with superb acting. They were able to bring parts of the book to life (i.e. the balrog) that they could not have done 10 years ago, in a satisfying fashion. The special effects get an A+. However, as a devoted Lord of the Ring/Tolkien fan I must admit that I was disappointed when something was left out, changed (i.e. Arwen being the horse rider), or made "darker" than it was intended. I especially was disappointed at not seeing the tender get together when they surprised Frodo with their intention to join him no matter what! I thought this was a critical part, as it expressed the deep friendship they had. Then, I missed not seeing the wonderful characters of Tom Bombadil and Goldberry with their adventure through the old forest. I thought they made Elrond's character a bit rough and stern. My harshest criticism would be how they portrayed Galadriel and Lothlorien. It was all so "dark". Noone contradicted Gimli when he said Galadriel was a witch. They made Galdriel out to be almost demonic. I was very uncomfortable with the scene when she had the ring. Also, my husband who has not read the book could not tell that the elves were singing a lament. He thought it was just part of the soundtrack. I sorely missed the emphasis on music, poetry, and singing that is such a crucial part of the book. Other than these two actors I thought everyone else was a great portrayal and looked like I thought they would. I understand that they can't put everything in, BUT they did spend precious movie minutes on stuff that wasn't even in the book, such as the fight between the two wizards. There was one scene, however that was a great addition: the scene of Aragorn and Arwen when they were pledging there love for each other. That was pure magic! Overall, despite the latter comments, I would recommend this movie even to Tolkien fans. I know I enjoyed seeing much of the book come to life. It is a "feast for the eyes and heart" with the superb visuals and acting.
Rating:
Summary: A Wonderful Movie Experience
Review: I enjoyed this movie thoroughly. It is very well paced and extremely well casted. Peter Jackson did a wonderful job directing this movie and the actors did a wonderful job at bringing the characters to life. Although it is a long movie, it did not seem so at all. As I said above, it was very well paced. I was not prepared for the movie to end as I was ready to continue my adventure with the Fellowship. I found the movie to be extremely enjoyable and it was quite an adventure. I am so looking forward to The Two Towers in December.
Rating:
Summary: Enjoyed it
Review: I enjoyed this movie. It moved at a good pace. It deserves the positive recognition it has received.
| 
