Rating: 
Summary: 165 minutes of quality time
Review: I won't get technical in my review but I'll tell you this, if you want to learn a good bit about history in a very entertaining way then buy this DVD. It's not too lengthy but doesn't end when you feel that you want more either. The story telling is good and systematic and easy to follow. The pictures and scenes are well acted and shot.They even have men posing as the real characters, and they're very convincing too! Don't laugh, but for a while I was wondering how did they get to know how did the characters look like to be able to generate such a true-look image of them! LOL Hmm, I hope that this remark doesn't diminish my credibility after all! LOL
Rating: 
Summary: Low Budget Pulp
Review: Lot's of dramatic music, words like "astounding", "astonishing", "amazing" and endless close-up shots of ancient pottery, trees blowing in the wind, armour hanging on walls etc makes this a boring DVD. They obviously had a low budget. The idea of telling the story of the Greeks is good but this DVD doesn't do it any justice. Skip it.
Rating:
Summary: Low Budget Pulp
Review: Lot's of dramatic music, words like "astounding", "astonishing", "amazing" and endless close-up shots of ancient pottery, trees blowing in the wind, armour hanging on walls etc makes this a boring DVD. They obviously had a low budget. The idea of telling the story of the Greeks is good but this DVD doesn't do it any justice. Skip it.
Rating: 
Summary: Great, but should have been called "Athens".
Review: My only complaints are that it only covered Athens and I wish it had covered a larger time frame. It covers from Athens revolutionary conversion to Democracy thru the death of Socrates. I wish it had continued through to the Roman conquest, but what can we expect for just under 3 hours. I'm glad I bought it.
Rating:
Summary: Very good, but not perfect
Review: The Greeks: Cruicible of Civilization is an excellent documentary giving a good basic overview of the Classical Greek Civilization. However, there are certain shortfalls in the video. The narration, visuals, live action sequences, recreations and interviews are all used skillfully to move forward the story in an understandable language. A particularly useful item was the use of three actors playing the parts of Socrates, Themosticles, and Pericles of Athens. These actors do not have any speaking parts; instead they stand while narration moves around them. This allows you to be able to visualize this character, giving life back to someone who could easily be just an old name about a time long ago. I felt that was beautifully done. But it's not perfect. The video seems to focus almost completely on Athens. At the beginning it is stated that Athens was but one of 1000 city-states of Greece; the director seems to forget this point very quickly. Other cities are forgotten and only mentioned when, and if, they come into contact with Athens. This short changes the other cities, such as Thebes, Cornith, Argos, and Sparta which made up and influenced the Greek civilization. There also is almost no mention of the Greek colonies, or the nations that were comtemporary for the time such as the Persians, Egyptians, or Etruscans. Now that said, it can also be understood. If there is one place that is most identifable with influencing what we percieve as civilization, as society, as deomocracy, then it must be Athens. But still the city did not exist in a vacuum, it was part of a larger civilization. I have to say that this is a good, basic introduction to Classical Greece. An excellent way to begin the study of the past.
Rating: 
Summary: Not so good
Review: The series "The Greeks" is not particularly good. The series concentrates entirely on Athens. It is slow-moving, and has little actual information. Mind you, it does have some pretty pictures. The actor for Socrates really looks the part! There are also some nice pictures of the Parthenon. This, however, cannot compensate for a lack of real information. I would have liked to see more details on Greek philosophy, drama and poetry. The way this program was made, you'd think the Greeks didn't do very much - not a very good way of seeing them!
Rating:
Summary: Not perfect, but very good
Review: The title of this DVD is not altogether accurate. If the writers had been interested in choosing a title which had veracity, the DVD would have been called "Athenians, Crucible of Civilization." For it is the Athenians, not the Greeks in general, which this documentary focuses on. Lacedamon, the other Superpower in Greece, as well as minor city states such as Corinth and Attica, are only mentioned in passing. Even then, the purpose for speaking of these places is almost always just to point out how they related to Athens. Now, this is not necessarily a bad thing. It is true that Athens was a watershed for western culture with its impressive contributions to political ideology, art, literature, theatre, architecture, philosophy, science, polemic techniques and so much more. All of these above topics were shunned by the people of Sparta, and the rest of the city states in Greece paled in comparison, insofar as these fields are concerned, when compared to the grandeur of the ostentatious Athenians. One place in which this preference for Athens is taken too far, however, is in the treatment of the Persian War. There were four major battles in this war; Marathon, Thermopylae, Salamis & Plataea. Only Marathon and Salamis are noted in this work; Thermopylae and Plataea are not cited at all. Apparently, the reason for this is that Marathon & Salamis were the two battles where the Athenians faced the Persians alone [at least for the most part; there were some allied ships sprinkled into the mix @ Salamis]. At Plataea they squared off against the Persians shoulder-to-shoulder with the Spartans and other Greeks. The Athenians were not involved @ Thermopylae at all. Persons who are unfamiliar with Greek history would be likely to walk away from this presentation thinking that there were only 2 major battles in the Persian War, and the Athenians deserve all the credit for saving Greece. That is a skewed understanding of history, and as such, not a good thing. The biggest oversight of the DVD resides in its chapter on the battle of Marathon. We are told that after his 140 mile jaunt to Sparta, the messenger Pheidippides' plea for help was refused by the Laconians. That is very, very, very misleading. The Lacedamons did NOT intentionally hang their Athenian brethren out to dry in the face of the Persian invasion of Marathon. Rather, it was due to religious protocal which prevented the Spartan army from setting out right away. Here is the passage in Herodotus which details the Lacedamons' answer to Pheidippides: "...the Spartans wished to help the Athenians, but were unable to give them any present succour, as they did not like to break their established law. It was then the ninth day of the first decade; and they could not march out of Sparta on the ninth, when the moon had not reached the full. So they waited for the full of the moon." (Herodotus, "Histories," Book VI [Erato], p. 342, trans: George Rawlinson) When the Spartans did send their army, they arrived @ Marathon within an astonishing 3 days. Unfortunately, by then, the fighting was already over & the Athenians had earned a glorious (not to mention improbable) victory. So, the Laconians congratulated the Athenians and headed home. The (mostly Ivy league) historians who put this documentary together should have known better than to omit these facts. By now you're probably thinking that I have nothing but bad stuff to say about this work, right? Well, no, that's not quite true; I've said all the negative things I am going to say (after all, I did give it 5 stars, right?). Now it's time to detail why I loved this DVD so much. First of all, what the DVD does cover, it covers very well. The major epochs of Athens are detailed down thru the ages until the end of the Peleponnesian War. The work goes over such diverse subjects as the role of women in ancient Athens, the tactics and tools of warfare and the paradigms of pottery & architecture. Also, the lives of such great men as Themosticles, Pericles and Socrates are scrutinized extensively. As an added bonus the narrarator is none other than the venerable Liam Neeson, and the score is nearly movie-soundtrack calibre. Despite my criticisms, I would highly recommend this DVD to all persons who have any interest at all in Greek history and / or the foundations of western thought.
Rating:
Summary: Not perfect, but very good
Review: The title of this DVD is not altogether accurate. If the writers had been interested in choosing a title which had veracity, the DVD would have been called "Athenians, Crucible of Civilization." For it is the Athenians, not the Greeks in general, which this documentary focuses on. Lacedamon, the other Superpower in Greece, as well as minor city states such as Corinth and Attica, are only mentioned in passing. Even then, the purpose for speaking of these places is almost always just to point out how they related to Athens. Now, this is not necessarily a bad thing. It is true that Athens was a watershed for western culture with its impressive contributions to political ideology, art, literature, theatre, architecture, philosophy, science, polemic techniques and so much more. All of these above topics were shunned by the people of Sparta, and the rest of the city states in Greece paled in comparison, insofar as these fields are concerned, when compared to the grandeur of the ostentatious Athenians. One place in which this preference for Athens is taken too far, however, is in the treatment of the Persian War. There were four major battles in this war; Marathon, Thermopylae, Salamis & Plataea. Only Marathon and Salamis are noted in this work; Thermopylae and Plataea are not cited at all. Apparently, the reason for this is that Marathon & Salamis were the two battles where the Athenians faced the Persians alone [at least for the most part; there were some allied ships sprinkled into the mix @ Salamis]. At Plataea they squared off against the Persians shoulder-to-shoulder with the Spartans and other Greeks. The Athenians were not involved @ Thermopylae at all. Persons who are unfamiliar with Greek history would be likely to walk away from this presentation thinking that there were only 2 major battles in the Persian War, and the Athenians deserve all the credit for saving Greece. That is a skewed understanding of history, and as such, not a good thing. The biggest oversight of the DVD resides in its chapter on the battle of Marathon. We are told that after his 140 mile jaunt to Sparta, the messenger Pheidippides' plea for help was refused by the Laconians. That is very, very, very misleading. The Lacedamons did NOT intentionally hang their Athenian brethren out to dry in the face of the Persian invasion of Marathon. Rather, it was due to religious protocal which prevented the Spartan army from setting out right away. Here is the passage in Herodotus which details the Lacedamons' answer to Pheidippides: "...the Spartans wished to help the Athenians, but were unable to give them any present succour, as they did not like to break their established law. It was then the ninth day of the first decade; and they could not march out of Sparta on the ninth, when the moon had not reached the full. So they waited for the full of the moon." (Herodotus, "Histories," Book VI [Erato], p. 342, trans: George Rawlinson) When the Spartans did send their army, they arrived @ Marathon within an astonishing 3 days. Unfortunately, by then, the fighting was already over & the Athenians had earned a glorious (not to mention improbable) victory. So, the Laconians congratulated the Athenians and headed home. The (mostly Ivy league) historians who put this documentary together should have known better than to omit these facts. By now you're probably thinking that I have nothing but bad stuff to say about this work, right? Well, no, that's not quite true; I've said all the negative things I am going to say (after all, I did give it 5 stars, right?). Now it's time to detail why I loved this DVD so much. First of all, what the DVD does cover, it covers very well. The major epochs of Athens are detailed down thru the ages until the end of the Peleponnesian War. The work goes over such diverse subjects as the role of women in ancient Athens, the tactics and tools of warfare and the paradigms of pottery & architecture. Also, the lives of such great men as Themosticles, Pericles and Socrates are scrutinized extensively. As an added bonus the narrarator is none other than the venerable Liam Neeson, and the score is nearly movie-soundtrack calibre. Despite my criticisms, I would highly recommend this DVD to all persons who have any interest at all in Greek history and / or the foundations of western thought.
Rating:
Summary: Lavish? Hardly.
Review: This DVD is described on Amazon as a lavish production. I don't think looking at the same urns, men standing still, ruins, etc. over and over again is much of an achievement. Actually I would say it was cheaply produced. You could turn the picture off and listen to the narration and learn just as well. Informative but boring to look at.
Rating:
Summary: Great Documentary
Review: This is a sort of "Ancient Greece for Dummies" DVD (I would include myself among the dummies). It is excellent for people who know almost nothing about Athens 5th Century BC or for those who may have a passing familiarity with the names Homer, Plato, Pericles, Darius, Xerxes. This really brings home the awesome debt our Western culture owes the Greeks--everything that makes us "civilized" (philosophy, science, literature, mathematics, you name it) came from Ancient Greece. We are truly standing on the shoulders of giants. It is shameful that the average American knows so little about the culture to which we owe so much. Our traditions of democracy and the rule of law (granted, the Greeks practiced direct/participatory democracy rather than the representative type we practice, but that was because their state was so much smaller) come from them. The re-enactments and the narrations of famous battles, the death of Socrates, the building of the Parthenon, etc., are hypnotic and breathtaking. Liam Neeson was an excellent choice for a narrator. Great buy and well worth the money. My only complaint is that it isn't longer.
|
