Rating: 
Summary: Is this a good movie , or not?
Review: These are my rating and reasons......Color:7/10
The color was good but it some parts the color was too dim or faded.
Music:9/10
The music was absolutely wonderful . The music matched the way the movie was playing.
Structure:7/10
The structure was switching back and forth in the movie.
Acting:9/10
The acting was very well acted . There was , I think there just one part that was a tiny bit weird on how they responded when Anakin lifted off in the spaceship thingy.
Sound:8/10
The sound was noticeable but some sounds were too quiet top hear.
Special Effects:7/10
The special effects were not all that good because if u compare to a computer animated scene with a real scene , you would be able to tell the difference.
Cinematography:8/10
The scenes in the movie were wonderful but a little ... to look at.
Costumes and Makeup:9/10
The makeup was wonderful and the costumes were nicely done.
Emotional:6/10
The movie wasn't really suppose to make u sad , mad , or happy . The movie was only exciting . It has barely and emotional impact .
Overall:(70/90)~~~>77% My personal of the movie is 6/10!
Rating: 
Summary: Where has the heart and soul of Star Wars gone?
Review: These are the nine reasons [...] why I thought Episode I was both a bad film and a poor entry into the Star Wars canon: 1. Paper-thin characterizations. [...] 2. Mediocre cinematography. While there were some spectacular shots of Naboo and Coruscant, for the most part I thought the cinematography--during the non-action sequences--ranged from fairly decent to merely passable. There were a few action sequences, however--Qui Gon and Obi Wan arriving on Naboo, the space battle with the Trade Federation, the Gunguns versus the droids and the final lightsaber duel, in particular--where I felt the established semiotics of cinema photography and composition were so bent, broken or twisted in nearly every frame that it actually fractured my "willing suspension of disbelief." Frame composition is every bit as important for action films (John Woo, anyone?) as it is for sweeping epics, or romances, etceteras. 3. A weak script. [...] In Episodes IV-VI, I felt Lucas accomplished his objectives with a much higher degree of subtlety. Episode I was about as subtle as a punch in the face with a clenched fist. Plus, I'm personally offended at the arrogance of Lucas to believe that we, as the audience for Star Wars, would simply slavishly accept whatever [...] he thinks he can get away with forcing down our collective maws: Midi-chlorians, for God's sake [...] much less the "virgin birth."[...] 4. Unconvincing special effects. [...]They topped themselves several times over in Episode I when it came to rendering believable capital ships, fighters and space battles. Nevertheless, not once, not ever--not even accidentally--was Lucasfilm or Lucas himself, as a filmmaker, able to assist me in suspending my disbelief long enough to allow that Jar-Jar and the Gunguns were real, living, breathing creatures. You need look no further than the scene when Jar-Jar is jumping up and down on the remains of the battle droid for an example of an unreal moment. [...] 5. Poor direction [...] Three words: Sam Jackson's "performance." Three more words: Jake Lloyd's "performance." [...]The problem with Sam Jackson was that he was TRYING TO ACT LIKE A JEDI KNIGHT (say it the way Jon Lovitz would when he says "I am an AC-TOR.") [...]That one moment when he tries so hard to look thoughtful he actually strokes his chin, I literally laughed out loud [...] 6. Poor editing. [...] "American Graffiti" and "Star Wars" were better-edited films. 7. John William's score. [...]Threadbare, self-plagiarizing musical pabulum completely without merit[...] I believe JW may have run out of ideas. [...] 8. A plot point so abhorrently disingenuous, so egregiously thick-headed that it deserves a mention all its own: 9-year old Anakin destroys the Trade Federation ship all by himself. [...] This is reptilian in its repellence. [...] 9. Jar-Jar Binks. [...] Lucas shot himself in the foot every time he turned around by including Jar-Jar's antics as the 'punch line' to the scenes he was in. I'm as big a fan of Star Wars as anyone, and I have been for 24 years. I was thrilled beyond human comprehension when I landed a multi-year gig writing LucasArts's Star Wars game guides [...]. However... I refuse to slavishly accept whatever George tries to force down my throat.[...]For Episode I to be merely workmanlike and competent is, measured against its potential, a huge disappointment.
Rating:
Summary: Embarasing
Review: These new star wars movies are an embarasement to Lucas. Nothing but lipservice to the first trilogy. A disgrace with no merit of their own.
Rating: 
Summary: please make it stop
Review: They just had to cash in on the Star Wars fanatics. The special effecs, however, saved the movie. I am so discusted with this movie I can't say any more.
Rating: 
Summary: At last we shall reveal ourselves to the Jedi.
Review: Think about this revelation alone: "At last, we shall reveal ourselves to the Jedi. At last, we will have revenge." This alone ought to tell you what else 'out there' awaits us in the next movie adventure {Hint:Who is the 'we' Maul is referring to?}. I got over Jar Jar one of the first few times I saw the actual movie at the theatre and did so knowing this had to lead to something bigger and better in the next motion picture. Many questions were arisen. Why Darth Maul only used half of his saber when attacking Qui Gon on Tattooine instead of both blades is one and why Obi Wan did not 'flash' over to his mentor to help him when being attacked by Maul much as he had earlier to escape the attack droids is another. Where did all of the Trade Federation ships disappear to in the battle at the end of the motion picture? These curiousities will surely be answered in Episode 2 as well as I am sure all of the others. The Phantom Menace was well worth the wait, in my humbled opinoin. Recently I had the chance to see for the first time Saving Private Ryanand must say this excuse for taking up well over two hours of my time hardly had a deep storyline and took forever to get to what turned out to be the obvious. The Star Wars galaxy is vastly populated with many the unknown and in a few years time, Episode 2 will easily erase any doubts we fans may have with the end result of Episode 1. Until then, take solace upon yourself and enjoy this awesome movie package relaesed by George Lucas. You will be glad you did!
Rating: 
Summary: The Phantom Menace
Review: This "Star Wars" entry was a little weaker than the origanal three story wise. That dose not mean that it is a bad movie. Set thirty years before "A New Hope". Quigon Ginn and Obi-Wan Konobie go to Naboo to oversee a trade agreement. They stumble upon an invasion in a conspiracy that goes all the way to the Senate. There are all kinds of technological achivements in the film. The pod race was easily the most exciting sequence of the film. Liam Neeson is a great elderly, slightly rebellious Jedi. Ewen McGregor dose pretty well as the younger, yet disaplined student, just slightly reckless. Jar Jar Binks is the embaresment of a lifetime for Goerge Lucas. Jake Lloyd is Anikin Skywalker, you know, Baby Vader. He's alright, a little winny for my taste, but he did ok. All in all it's a good movie, just not up to snuff of the origanal triligy; but there probably never will be.
Rating:
Summary: A great DVD, perfect for any collection
Review: This 2 disc set is one of the best available, not to mention its a Star Wars movie. The picture and sound are fantastic, espescially when viewed and heard on a high def. 57" widescreen with surround sound. Each lightsaber strike is crisp and clear, as though it were happening live in front of you. The second disc has tons of special features including deleted scenes, movie posters from around the world, extended scenes, and the music video for "Duel of the Fates". Though this might not be considered the greatest of the Star Wars movies, the movie is dramatically enhanced when viewed on DVD.
Rating:
Summary: Bonus material is great!
Review: This 2-dvd set is worth it just for all the extra stuff on there! The documentary, the deleted scenes, the audio commentary, not to mention a great movie!
Rating:
Summary: total dissapointment
Review: This anticipated prequel left everyone begging for less. Less low brow Jar-Jar (better left on the cutting room floor in its entirety). The plot was threadbare, the characters two-dimentional, and the whole feel was lacking. Not worthy of the starwars name.
Rating:
Summary: To all Star Wars fans' past, present & future' I am all 3..
Review: This avid STAR WARS fan saw the movie, has the book, of course & purchased the DVD. No other galaxies far, far away or near, can compare with the stories that arise from Lucas' original Trilogy. I (as I hope other viewers do/did) am positively amazed and in awe of the STAR WARS world. THE PHANTOM MENACE, Episode I, even in the DVD, is clearly transcribed, imaginatively on top with the STAR WARS legacy. Technical, film-making, amazing techniques and visionary aspects of the DVD are clear and formidable. One could not have put together a better line of actors/actresses to get into the mode of pre-trilogy numbers 4/5/6 characters' as well as players who do not go into the future episodes. Liam Neeson as Qui-Gon Jinn is the Master Jedi/teacher of Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) -- the on-screen presence of these two fine actors is obviously a "made to be", charismatic interaction. Queen Amilda (Natalie Portman) carries herself royally and regally with sophistication and confidence, and "kicks..." at the "where applicable". The delightful Jar Jar is a little weak and difficult in the diction path, but added a wonderfully humorous character to the Episode. And, yes, it was hard to envision young, innocent-faced Anakin (Jake Lloyd) entering the future role of Darth Vader; however, Jake Lloyd plays the part to a "tee", not too young but yet not too old. I desire to see more of Yoda, R2-D2 and C-3PO' Episode I allows the viewer insight as to their beginnings with STAR WARS. Although I do hope some author will run the gamut of portraying Yoda "from whence he came'" -- this viewer finds all from I to VI short on the history of Yoda, an endearing, unusual, highly-intelligent, philosophical, gentle being. The costuming, makeup and representation of Darth Maul (Ray Park) is mind and eye-catching; Mace Windu (Samuel Jackson) contributes pizzazz and believability as one of the "best among the best" of the Jedi Force Knights' this viewer/fan looks forward to Jackson's carry over into Episode II (already a done deal) and the future III. (And, thank you Mr. Jackson for choosing purple as your light saber... my favorite color.) When "the Trilogy" came out years ago (and also saw the anniversary showings) in New York City, a fan or viewer cannot help but associate the faces of Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, Han Solo, Chewbacca, et al. without transferring in thought and mind their outstanding performances from Episode 4/5/6, in comparison with the portrayals and acting talents in Episode I II and III (the latter to be determined). Definitely buy the DVD and number II, of course. What would life be, without STAR WARS!
| 
