Rating: 
Summary: Picking at Nits, and other humbuggery
Review: I must say I agree very much with David: This was a film written for the public at large, and not for the "Trekkie", as it were. One thing that they could easily have played off of from the series was character of B4. In the series episode titled "Inheritance", Data's mother did indeed hint that there were more androids like Data than just Lore. But for a few words, this easily could have given more die-hard fans somthing of what they wanted; An obscure reference to the series. I do disagree with some other critisims about Picard in the area of him becomming an action hero. There were plenty of situations where Picard demonstrated his physical prowness in the series (rock climbing, bar fights, tactical training, and so on). But I do agree on the point that the movie was too Picard centered. To be fair, however, if the general story of the movie had been an episode in the series, I think it would have been remembered as one of the best episodes (along with Chain of Command, and All Good Things...). I close by saying that I hope very much that this is not the final movie with this cast, as there are too many loose threads and unanswered questions.
Rating: 
Summary: The Last Science Fiction Film Of The 20th Century
Review: This film was an brilliant essay on the end of twentieth century science fiction, as it regurtitates old archetypes in (what it hopes is) a new way. Take the Remans, for example. What are they but Nosferatu wearing leather coats from the Matrix? By stealing from the roots of sci-fi (horror) and the style of new sci-fi (currently, leather) Rick Berman's crew proves that they're creatively bankrupt. And the clone of Jean-Luc Picard almost exists as if to brag, "So clones and baldness are cool now? Well we did it first!" Poor Brent Spiner in his pancake makeup proves eloquently that a new coat of paint won't fix the basic problem--that Trek is dead--a point further proved when they uncover his new "brother" in the stripmined desert wasteland of action movies (another false refuge for ailing sci-fi). Science fiction is good when it's about character--just like any fiction. Heck...it was Star Trek that proved that the science doesn't have to be good for the story to be there (way back when Bones declared that the self-replicating tribbles were "bisexual"). Trek had some great moments, like Data defending his free will in "The Measure of a Man" and that time the doctor told Jeri Ryan he had to check out her "implants." But the sad desire to milk what was once good reflects what's happening to all outmoded space-ship driven Sci-Fi, and makes Nemesis embarrassingly bad. When Jean-Luc Picard is fighting a younger version of himself...what are we to take it for? Good writing? How about a metaphor for a sickly genre fighting its own old age? If you want to see cool characters wearing leather outfits standing against a hazy green backdrop, forget Trek, or even Patrick Stewart's other burgeoning franchise...Save your money folks. Buying Nemesis is like taking the blue pill--and choking on it.
Rating: 
Summary: Nemesis worth the purchase
Review: Having followed the TNG cast since day 1, I think Star Trek fans will find Nemesis as a very satisfying ending to what was by all accounts a wonderful series. That being said, I doubt non-Trek fans will find this installment of Trek very appealing. Producer Rick Berman was in charge of all four TNG movies (Generations, First Contact, Insurrection and Nemesis) and as a fan I would rank this movie somewhere in between First Contact and Generations, with Insurrection being the worst of the four.
Berman and the Star Trek franchise got the formula right with First Contact. It offered a solid story line with spectacular action, character development on all ends of the spectrum and an enemy that even non-Trek fans could appreciate in the Borg. With Nemesis, there is somewhat of an appeal similar to that in First Contact, but it falls slightly short. The B4/Data development should have had more time in this movie and the Picard/Shinzon conflict never materialized in a particularly realistic fashion. Still, Trek fans will appreciate the action sequences towards the beginning of this movie as well as the battle between starships towards the end. Fans will also appreciate the chemistry between Riker and Troi as they take a big step in their life. I walked out of this movie depressed about the ending and I won't say why but you'll understand when you see the movie. Overall, I would recommend that Trek fans purchase the DVD for its value as an action flick and the fact that its loaded with tons of extras. As for me, while I will buy the DVD and I'm really hoping they use the actions scenes from the movie and turn it into something even more fun, a Playstation 2 game.
Rating: 
Summary: Great Movie
Review: I laugh at some of the people who critique a sci-fi movie like this. They obviously shouldn't go see these kinds of movies because they will be dissappointed every time. I loved this movie as it had a good plot, was funny, and had a great climatic battle at the end. These movies are for enjoyment of the imagination, nothing more. Some people need to get a more broad imagination when it comes to sci-fi movies. I'll buy this on DVD when it comes out.
Rating: 
Summary: A total disappointment.
Review: I've been a Trek fan since the Original Series, seen all the movies, all the television series. This was the greatest disappointment I've had in a Star Trek motion picture. A horrible way to end the Next Generation franchise, and quite possibly the end to the entire Trek lineage.
Rating:
Summary: Good CGIs, Decent Plot, and Weak, Indecisive Ending
Review: The 10th Star Trek movie finally came, and as an avid Trek fan I waited for the occasion. OK, let me say what I felt. The film is not as bad as I was afraid, showing some good special effects and interesting cameos like Brian Singer or Kate Mulgrew. And there is an ending that is clearly intended to surprise us, but ... yes, that is exactly the problem. The fate of one of the beloved crew doesn't have enough impact to move us. I think everything could be different with another directo like Jonathan Frakes, who surely knows and respects the world of Star Trek. The story is a decent one, if not perfect or original. Shinzon (Tom Hardy), "nemesis" of Captain Picard, shows up before the starship Enterprise to threaten the mass destruction of the whole universe. This time he seems more powerful (and human) than previous enemies like Borg, and before we know it, he can control the politics of the Romulans, one of the most strong groups of the space. Along this main plot, there are some about the long-delayed marriage of Riker, and the android named B-4, another "alter ego" of DATA. Let us not talk about the coherence about the story. Yes, we don't know why Worf is here while we think we saw him at Deep Space Nine. We are glad to have him as long as the total result of the film is good. To be fair, the film gives more actions enhanced by recent CGIs, so the battle sequences are better than anything you ever saw before. At least writer John Logan ("Gladiator") is a fan of the series, and he inserts some good in-jokes concerning the series. And he didn't forget to give some lines to say to Beverly Crusher, who had been always treated as if she isn't there. But ... I didn't like the film very much. Sorry, but fans, how can you forgive it when you see Wesley Crusher in the opening scene, but doens't have any line to say? You will miss him if you blink, and the scene looks as if the editor thought he is not worth giving some time to reappear in the film. Or, see how the film ends, like I said. Yes, the impact should be much, much more. But what you see is just a hurriedly done wrap-up of the confused situation. I cannot disclose much, but I can say this; they should have seen the "The Wrath of Khan" again, and how to make a truely emotional conclusion of the film. Alas, but in "Nemesis" he is just wasted. The greatest problem is perhaps the film looks very indecisive about whether or not the series should go on. Some say the 10th installment is the last while others deny it. I don't know which is true, but the film tries to satisfy the both views, and as a result lacks the courage to push the story further than on TV. Director Stuwart Baird, it is clear, is trying to meets the needs from fans and non-fans, but as a result, though it is not a bad one like the fifth Trek film, it lacks the momentum to reach the best, namely "Khan."
Rating:
Summary: Trekker News
Review: This was a good movie. I don't know why people didn't like it. The actors worked hard on making this movie just to entertain fellow trekkers. I for sure am buying the movie to show support for Star Trek. This DVD is worth buying in my opinion. Buy the movie and take a look at the special features after watching the movie. I think they'll be worth taking a look.
Rating:
Summary: Decent
Review: "Nemesis" kept up the tradition of the even-numbered films being better than their odd-numbered counterparts. Before I continue, I must say that if you grew up on TOS like me, it more than likely won't beat out "Khan." Nothing will, case closed. I'd put it behind "First Contact" and ahead of the other two films for sure. Contrary to what others have stated, it is NOT the worst film. Anyone else recall that debacle known as "The Final Frontier?" Its low ticket sales don't do it justice (USA Today had even touted it as getting around the [money amount]-mark...maybe a kiss of death, I don't know). It does succeed in coming full circle with regards to some of the characters we met on the pilot. Troi and Riker have some kind of past together in the show, and that's finally brought to a close in this movie with their wedding. Data's desire to be human is met (according to some of his friends). Last it shows that this crew has grown closer together as a family, in contrast to the beginning when hardly anyone knew each other, and Picard seemed to be pretty stuffy. The movie I think follows a blueprint of Star Trek VI. Almost everyone gets one last moment to shine, "let's make peace with an enemy," etc. Yes, it does have its flaws, but if you're more into movies for the content rather than worrying if Picard was truly bald during his academy days, or some other tidbit, check out the movie.
Rating:
Summary: The best movie ever
Review: I don't know why you people complain about evry little thing. This movie was a great movie I thought it was right up in the ranks of FIrst contact. It is a movie worth watching. You guys need to instead of complaing you need to congratulate the people who worked so hard on this movie to make us happy. They can just take star trek away from us if we keep complaing about it so just shut you complaing and be happy with what you got.!!!!
Rating:
Summary: A different kind of movie
Review: This is a much different kind of Trek movie than what we're all used to, everyone would agree. I wouldn't say it was a particularly bad movie. The shame here is that no one thought to make a DS9 movie, or one centered around another Trek race as the primary plot, perhap a good Ferengi adventure story?
|
