Our Favorite Things - Christmas in Vienna

Rating:
Summary: A Sterile Xmas with Charlotte
Review: Any time you bring together artists for Christmas songs, the one ingredient you look for is warmth. This is the commonality of all Christmas songs which we look for when listening to such fare. Fortunately, 3 of the performers here, Tonny Bennett, Placido Domingo and Vanessa Williams provide us with this holiday necessity in a variety of favorites. The 4th, Charlotte Church, however, simply belts out some traditional songs with about as much warmth as a snowball. When I hear songs by an individual, I expect more than just a choir-girl rendition. If Miss Church is unable to meet this expectation, she should stay home, enjoy her Christmas and listen to those that do.

Rating:
Summary: A Sterile Xmas with Charlotte
Review: Any time you bring together artists for Christmas songs, the one ingredient you look for is warmth. This is the commonality of all Christmas songs which we look for when listening to such fare. Fortunately, 3 of the performers here, Tonny Bennett, Placido Domingo and Vanessa Williams provide us with this holiday necessity in a variety of favorites. The 4th, Charlotte Church, however, simply belts out some traditional songs with about as much warmth as a snowball. When I hear songs by an individual, I expect more than just a choir-girl rendition. If Miss Church is unable to meet this expectation, she should stay home, enjoy her Christmas and listen to those that do.

Rating:
Summary: I LOVE CHRISTMAS, BUT NOT THIS COLD CONCERT CATASTROPHE!
Review: Each individual element of this event had potential of providing a warm and memorable Christmas evening, but together they are lost in a blinding snowstorm. As much as I love Christmas, its music and all things wonderful about it... this video does not deliver!

Rating:
Summary: Charlotte saves it
Review: I agree with some of the earlier posters. Domingo and Charlotte are excellent. Bennett needs to retire and Williams is mediocre, at best.

I heard this special just last month and was very impressed when I heard Charlotte. Bennett and Williams, however, did not impress me much. When Bennett would sing, I would feel sorry for him. The voice just wasn't making it. Williams to me seemed to believe she was better than she is...and, perphaps my imagination, but seemed to not like it much when Charlotte was on stage with all of them...at least at the end of the special.

I will buy this DVD purely for Charlotte and Domingo's performances. 3 stars because Bennett and Williams decrease it by 2.

Rating:
Summary: Very Enjoyable
Review: I just watched this DVD and can't begin to understand why such poor reviews. Let me preface this by saying that I know nothing about the nuances of music or sound quality. I'm an average Joe would would normally choose watching football over a Christmas concert. I found this presentation to be very enjoyable. Having four talented people from very different backgrounds performing together was an absolute treat. Don't buy into the 1 star reviews by snobby Opera geeks. I believe that most people will find it to be very well done moving.

Rating:
Summary: Very Enjoyable
Review: I just watched this DVD and can't begin to understand why such poor reviews. Let me preface this by saying that I know nothing about the nuances of music or sound quality. I'm an average Joe would would normally choose watching football over a Christmas concert. I found this presentation to be very enjoyable. Having four talented people from very different backgrounds performing together was an absolute treat. Don't buy into the 1 star reviews by snobby Opera geeks. I believe that most people will find it to be very well done moving.

Rating:
Summary: There's lots of echo but where's Charlotte ??????
Review: This DVD is simply a big disappointment. You don't have to read any more.

Sony Classical worked hard to make sure Charlotte Church only sings two songs even though they promote her name heavily with this DVD.

Sony Classical also worked hard to put in as much echo as possible. No doubt because Vanessa Williams and Tony Bennett need all the help they can get. That echo spoils the little singing that Charlotte does and it spoils all of Placido's singing. Maybe Sony Classical thinks that this sound track should be played with heavy echo on $... boom boxes.

What a great missed opportunity for Sony Classical to have Placido Domingo and Charlotte Church sing a few christmas carols together on a DVD without distortion.

There's obviously a lot of reasons why this DVD is now being heavily discounted. Sadly, it's just a big rip off.

Rating:
Summary: mercy!
Review: What a travesty, the great Domingo soldiers on with a group of motley artists (Charlotte excepted). I mean, Tony Bennett should retire and enjoy his millions, he is REALLY past it! It was painful to watch him and Placido mangle beautiful Christmas music and it would have offended the ears of The Creator.
Charlotte however, is showing more maturity in her singing.
The other female pop star lacked diction, and was clearly out of her depth.
These annual Christmas in Vienna shows have been really tacky over the last few years.......check out 'Christmas Glory at Westminster Abbey', the BBC will show how it is supposed to be done.