Rating: 
Summary: the Way To Go
Review: This has to be the best WAY to be rememberd.go Monty P. George Loved you TOO. Ravi and Company did Justice to Your Memory.
Rating:
Summary: George was ALMOST right...
Review: If you are over 40, you will laugh, cry and sit in utter disbelief when you watch this concert. If you are under 40 (and you appreciate the music of the 70s and 80s) you will simply sit in utter disbelief. It does not get any better than this. I don't think it's an exaggeration to say that this is a concert of epic proportions. Virtually every song is stunningly performed by brilliant musicians who clearly loved George Harrison. Toward the end of the concert, you will witness a 3-song series that has to be one of the best live performances ever recorded - All Things Must Pass (sung by Sir Paul), While My Guitar Gently Weeps (sung by Mr. Clapton of course) and My Sweet Lord (sung by the ever-soulful Billy Preston). Among the many "legends" on stage are Eric Clapton, Ringo Starr, Paul McCartney, Jeff Lynne, Tom Petty, Billy Preston, Jim Capaldi and George's son, Dhani. George was almost right, all things must pass EXCEPT music that makes us feel this good for this long.
Rating: 
Summary: Concert for George
Review: A truly great album (DVD) and worthwhile tribute to George
Rating:
Summary: A must see for all music lovers
Review: Please take the time to watch both CDs in this set. The first is the actual concert in running order complete with all the eastern music that Harrrison is so famous for bringing to the West. The second, an edited down version that was the theatrical release with fewer songs but containing interviews with the participants with insights into the life of a very private, honest, and spiritual man.As someone who had his musical awakening from the live performance of The Beatles on the Ed Sullivna show - I both laughed and cried when I watched the CD. The musicians on stage and their reason for being there a reminder that the era they celebrated is quickly coming to an end as the participants age and/or die. Harrison's songs are all gems in one form or another and their covers by the people who new and loved him are excellent. The love on that stage is evident and will surely stir your emotions and memories of the past. Whether you lived through the era or not . . . this concert has some excellent music worthy of your ears and is a credit to the love and respect generated by one of the great musicins of our time.
Rating:
Summary: WOOOOOOW!!!!!!
Review: This is an excellent concert, you won't regret this.
Please do yourself a favor and buy it now!!!
Rating:
Summary: Beautifully Done!
Review: The wonder of the DVD is that you can watch it over and over again, and never tire of it; yet, it's sad that a previous reviewer on this site brought up an error that Eric Clapton made during the introduction. He accidentally referred to Dhani Harrison as George's wife, and was ribbed by Paul McCartney at one point. These comments were indeed edited out. However, Paul McCartney's comments were not tacky - in fact - Clapton's error was a running joke onstage throughout the night. Dhani Harrison and various artists jibed him about it at various points in the concert, and it actually hysterical. So don't let this background give you pause. It was all in good fun, and feelings were warm throughout. It's actually too bad they trimmed this off the DVD, but that doesn't diminish this touching concert. It went off with the greatest intentions. This DVD is wonderful. The music is gorgeous, and the feelings among the artists on stage who loved the man is strong. As for there being 2 DVDs - it's appropriate. As for Dylan not being there - we know, we know....he was on tour. It's just a shame his calendar couldn't permit him attending. Just buy the DVD and enjoy without thinking of the nit picking here. The votes are in - almost 100 people here have given this double disk set 5 stars. Very well earned. This is pure Harrison.
Rating:
Summary: A TRULY APPROPRIATE TRIBUTE TO GEORGE
Review: This DVD is wonderful on many levels. Where to begin. The opening Indian sequence is superb with the musicianship shown by Anoushka Shankar breathtaking to behold. The Indian Orchestra are no slouches either!! While it may be a little tempting for some to skip ahead to the "western" part, this opening section of the concert has to be seen and heard to be believed. Originally "The Inner Light" was issued in 1968 as a Single B-Side to "Lady Madonna". I've always loved this song. Here it's given beautiful treatment in a sublime performance by Jeff Lynne, Anoushka, Indian players along with George's son, Dhani Harrison on piano. I hadn't fully appreciated the intricasies of this song until I watched Anoushka perform it on the Sitar. She then proceeds to conduct the Indian Orchestra on "Arpan", a specially composed piece by her father, the Legendary Ravi Shankar. With an amazing interplay between the Indian players and a Orchestral String Section plus Eric Clapton on Acoustic Guitar, the song takes us on a marvellous journey. Yes Dhani, your Dad would love this.
In a fashion only George could appreciate and approve of, the seriousness of the preceeeding wonderful moment is consigned to fading memory as the Monty Python "Barber Shop Quartet" regales us with "Sit On My Face", bare backsides and all with respectful bows to George's portrait. Michael Palin then leads the guys into "The Lumberjack Song" after a funny but fruitless "tribute" to George. Tom Hanks guests as a stand-in Mountie.
After a brief intermission we are entertained by an amazing band, all George's mates, led by Eric Clapton. It was also eerie on 2 fronts (1) the image of Dhani on centre stage with his peers playing rhythm guitar as part of the band all the while looking like George circa 1963-64 and (2) the most amazing aspect of the band itself was the sound it generated, with George's slide sounds particularly replicated so accurately, you'd think George was up there with them...I'm sure he was in spirit!. The special moments are numerous. Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers, Jeff Lynne, Joe Brown and daughter Sam, Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr, Billy Preston, Gary Brooker & Eric Clapton all contribute truly faithful renditions of George's classic songs. Ringo also chipped in with "Honey Don't", a Carl Perkins classic, truly appropriate as Carl was a hero to George. No egos, no grandstanding, just beautiful musicianship from all concerned. The tributes to George were very understated, the introductions to the various performers simple and to the point. Yeah Ringo was jolly, but that's Ringo. Paul's ukele version of "Something" with Eric Clapton & band joining in halfway was nicely contrasting while moving. His rendition of "All Things Must Pass" was very poignant while "For You Blue" brought back memories of "the old 12 bar blues". He then takes a back seat like the other guys and just plays piano and sings along. Billy Preston's take on "My Sweet Lord" is very special indeed. Sam Brown is exceptional on "Horse To The Water". Petty & Co. on "Taxman", "I Need You" and with fellow Wilbury Jeff Lynne on "Handle With Care" do George proud. Again, "Taxman" is a real highlight because George's great original guitar work is accurately reproduced here and it's only now, after watching it played, can I realise it's complexity. George was a much better guitarist than I had previously realised. Many other special moments are too numerous mention. However the Joe Brown ukelele finale "I'll See You In My Dreams", complete with red and yellows flowers dropping like confetti into the grand looking Albert Hall, a very apt venue, is a "suitable ending" to momentous occasion. Unlike many recent concert DVD's, the camera work here focuses on the musicians at hand and the concerts many highs are beautifully presented as a result. Thank you. It was a truly emotional occasion for all present, be they performers or audience and it was a fitting tribute to George's memory.
The 2nd disc includes a shorter cinematic version as well as interviews and rehearsals which are a wonderful experience to watch. The preparations during the "Indian" rehearsals are fascinating and watching Ravi Shankar compose on the fly and then try to interpret his intentions to the String Section make for some really nice moments. The interviews with Dhani are particularly special especially when he demonstrates things his Dad showed him to play and when he talks about the experience of being on stage with such a huge band... 8 guitarists, 4 drummers...wow! Python backstage is also great fun and the rehearsals very entertaining. Overall if you don't like this DVD then you've probably got a heart of stone and ice in your veins or you're just very hard to please indeed. I can't fault it and I utterly, utterly recommend it to anyone who love George Harrison's music but also those who love concert DVD's.
Rating: 
Summary: No need for Two Disc
Review: First of all the concert was fine. There were some songs I could have done without, but thats true with most concerts. As for Ringo being happy, whats wrong with that. He states I loved George and George loved me. Is he suppose to cry while he sings - The Disc is a great tribute, but it is his friends celebrating his music, and they do a great job of it. Eric Clapton, Billy Preston, Joe Brown really impressed me with the feeling they put into the songs. You could tell they were not just going through the motions. Now the only problem I have with this 2 set dvd is that your buying a two disc set thinking wow a lot of stuff here. You watch the first one great. You put in the second one, and its the same - exact same concert, except put in different order ( not even different takes) - They do cut a few of the songs short or fad out with an interview in the middle of the song???????????? Why not just have a disc with interviews. I see no reason in watching the same concert again with 80% the the exact as disc one, with the cut to an interview, in which the interview was in the middle of the song or maybe at the end or just wherever. It really made no sense. I would have rather had One concert, and on Disc two the 20 min. of interviews. They did it as a money making gimmick. As for getting the DVD or the CD, well if you can pick up the DVD for a few bucks more, I would get only the DVD, and download it on to a blank cd. I wouldn't buy both the DVD and Cd, and since the 30 price on the Dvd is already down to sale price of 20 in stores, and the Cd remains at the 20 dollar level - I'd get the DVD. I guess though it really depends on how big of a George Harrison fan you are. It was a very good show, and I believe overall you will enjoy Disc one, but please if someone can explain any sound reason for playing the concert a second time (Disc Two) - One final note. Quit giving Bob Dylan down the road. Look up his web concert sight. He had booked concerts back to back far in advance. Yes it would have been great to have Bob there, and I'm sure if possible he would have, but it isn't easy to call off 5 or 6 concerts to fly in to do this one show - They could have taped him, and shown him and his band doing a tribute, while he was on the other side of the world if they had wanted to. Bob did it for a Johnny Cash special a couple of years before he died.
Rating:
Summary: A Must Have In Your DVD Collection!
Review: If your a George Harrison/Beatle fan, then your probably going to purchase this DVD and accompanying CD. I don't need to convince you. If your a music fan, and want the best DVD concert for your collection, then please pick this up. You won't be sorry! One year to the day after George's death, Eric Clapton gathered many of George's friends and musicians (many of those who were on the original recordings) at the Royal Albert Hall, for a benefit concert honoring George's life & works. I had honestly forgotten how many great songs George wrote, (many are included on the DVD) and what a talented song writer he was. If George's songs doesn't want too make you run out and buy this DVD, then the all star line up on stage should. Where else can you see Eric Clapton, Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr, Jeff Lynne, Tom Petty, Billy Preston plus to many else to mention here, onstage, all at once. Truly remarkable & historical! This DVD will make you laugh, cry, and even have a chill run down your spine watching George's son Dhani (who is the spitting image of his father) playing guitar onstage. Trust me...buy this DVD, turn the lights down low, crank up the sound, and reminisce. You will truly enjoy watching this concert over and over and over again!
Rating:
Summary: Focus on the music and you'll be fine...
Review: Many have already written glowing reviews of this DVD, and rightfully so - it is truly a captivating concert, captured beautifully on film. (It sounds incredible as well.) All the musicians and performers are in top form (save Tom Petty, whose voice seems unusually whiny even for him and who looks like the Scarecrow from "The Wizard of Oz" with bleached blond hair), and seem to genuinely be enjoying both the experience and the music of George Harrison. The two comments I would like to add are that it's nice to see Jeff Lynne featured so prominently, as it seems he gets little respect as a performer despite the great music he's made both with ELO and with others, and that I think it's sad that so many reviewers seem determined to assault Paul McCartney. Whatever Paul might have said to Eric Clapton that was edited out is inconsequential - he was probably just attempting to be humorous, and I would imagine wasn't meant to be insulting. (Even rock icons can get it wrong occasionally - that doesn't make them mean-spirited or vindictive, just human.) It just seems that so many people enjoy bashing McCartney, and, while his boundless energy and constant rah-rah kind of behavior can be grating at times, he truly seemed touched and honored to be part of the show. Certainly, his performances of "For You Blue", "All Things Must Pass", and "Something" are among the highlights of the concert - and, for those who want to call his late arrival onstage as "grandstanding", remember that Ringo had appeared only two songs earlier. In any case, the way they both participated was perfectly suited to the occasion - since I'd imagine George wouldn't have wanted his tribute to be primarily about the two surviving Beatles being onstage together again. Just buy the bloody thing.
|
